Lawyer support in Istanbul for illegal electricity reports, prosecutor summons and enforcement proceedings. Document preparation and legal process for BEDAŞ and AYEDAŞ files.
Support from an illegal electricity crime lawyer in Istanbul covers the criminal investigation opened on an allegation of illegal use, as well as related processes such as objecting to the electricity bill, enforcement proceedings and a declaration of non-indebtedness. Because of the same report, the distribution company may demand payment and the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office may also conduct an investigation. These processes differ in their remedies, time limits and legal consequences.
The act commonly called the "illegal electricity crime" is, where its conditions are met, assessed under the offence of unlawful benefit in Article 163/3 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK). However, not every illegal electricity bill means an offence has been committed in criminal law terms. Whether the measurement of consumption was prevented, the nature of the interference, the actual user and intent must be investigated separately. [1]
In a legal assessment with Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun, the report, meter inspection documents, consumption history, lease or subscription records and notifications can be examined together. The fact that the action in Istanbul was taken by BEDAŞ or AYEDAŞ does not change the need to examine the technical and legal aspects of the specific case separately.
Under TCK Art. 163/3, electrical energy must be used without the consent of the rights holder and in a way that prevents the amount of consumption from being determined. For criminal liability, it is not enough to look only at whose name the subscription is in; it must also be shown that the alleged act was carried out by the person knowingly and wilfully. [1]
For this reason, answering the following questions is important in a criminal file:
For example, the detection of interference made before a new tenant moved in does not automatically make the new tenant guilty. The time of the interference, the period of use and the person's knowledge are examined on the basis of concrete evidence. Likewise, being unable to pay the electricity bill for financial reasons is not, on its own, sufficient for this offence.
The Electricity Market Consumer Services Regulation regulates illegal consumption and irregular consumption in different provisions. This distinction is important in determining the procedure to be applied and the grounds for objection. Under the Regulation, a use being treated as illegal and an offence being committed under the TCK are also not the same assessment. [1][2]
| Situation | Example | Legal assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Illegal electricity consumption | Use through a line bypassing the meter, interference affecting measurement, or unauthorised reconnection of electricity lawfully cut off | An illegal-use charge may be issued under the Regulation. For criminal liability, the elements of the offence are examined separately. |
| Irregular electricity consumption | Continuing to use electricity by paying the previous consumer's bills without making a contract in one's own name | The procedures and obligations in Article 48 of the Regulation are assessed. |
| Non-payment of a normal bill | Failure to pay the correctly measured consumption charge on time | Collection and disconnection processes may arise; non-payment of the debt alone is not sufficient for TCK Art. 163/3. |
For irregular use, the Regulation provides for a 15-day period to fulfil the obligations and, where the situation is not remedied in time, collection of five times the relevant disconnection-reconnection fee and disconnection. However, in certain cases specified in the Regulation, documenting that an application was made before the detection may prevent the irregular-use provisions from being applied. Subscription application records should therefore be kept. [2]
The penalty for the offence of unlawful benefit under TCK Art. 163/3 is imprisonment from one to three years. This range is the basic penalty provided by law. The actual outcome is determined by proof of the offence, the circumstances of the case, applicable reduction provisions and the person's legal situation. [1]
The bill issued by the distribution company, known as the "illegal electricity penalty", is not a judicial fine imposed by a court. This document is a claim for a consumption charge based on the calculation rules in the Regulation. Cancellation or reduction of the bill and the outcome of the criminal file must be assessed separately.
Without examining the file, it is not correct to state outcomes such as "a prison sentence will definitely be given", "there is no penalty for a first incident" or "if the debt is paid, the file is closed in every case".
Effective repentance for the offence of unlawful benefit is specifically regulated in TCK Art. 168/5. Full compensation of the loss has different consequences depending on the stage at which it is made. The law also states that this provision cannot be used more than twice. [1]
| Stage at which payment is made | Basic consequence under the law |
|---|---|
| Before the investigation is completed | If the loss is fully compensated under the statutory conditions, no public prosecution is brought. |
| After the investigation is completed, until judgment | If the loss is fully compensated under the statutory conditions, the penalty is reduced by up to one third. |
The total bill calculated by the distribution company at an increased tariff and the loss determined for effective repentance in the criminal file may not be the same. In Court of Cassation practice, it is important that the actual loss including tax and excluding penalties be determined by an expert and that the opportunity to pay be notified properly. The assessment should therefore not be made only on the total figure reported by the company. [5]
Being granted instalments or paying part of the debt does not, on its own, show that the full compensation required by law has been made. The payment plan, the stage of the investigation and the period given must be assessed together.
In its judgment dated 24.02.2026, docket 2026/1211, decision 2026/3467, the Court of Cassation 2nd Criminal Chamber emphasised that the actual loss should be calculated by an expert during the investigation and that the person should be given a proper payment notification. In that case, where this was not done properly and the loss was fully paid during prosecution, the Chamber held that the case should be dropped. [5]
This assessment does not mean that every payment made after the case is filed will cause it to be dropped. The content of the previous warning, the amount notified, the payment period and the other circumstances of the file must be examined.
Receiving a summons from the police or the prosecutor to give a statement about illegal electricity does not mean the person has been found guilty. At this stage it is important to learn the accusation, examine the evidence and base the defence on the real circumstances of the case.
Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, a suspect has the right to the assistance of a lawyer, the right not to make a statement about the accusation and the right to request that concrete evidence in their favour be collected. Obligations regarding identity information apply separately. [3]
Before the statement, documents on the moving-in date, the start of the subscription, meter changes, the business's period of activity and the previous user can be prepared. Rather than guessing on unknown technical matters, the limits of one's knowledge should be stated clearly. Statements made in the application to the company and in the criminal file should be consistent with the same event and documents.
If the elements of the offence are not present or there is insufficient evidence that the person committed the alleged act, depending on the stage of the file, a decision of non-prosecution or an acquittal may be considered. The outcome depends on the assessment of all the evidence in the file. [1][3]
The main points that can be examined include correct measurement of use, the interference not being attributable to the defendant, the property being used by another person during the alleged period, and contradictions between technical records. These should not be seen as automatic grounds for acquittal; each must be explained in connection with the specific case.
No public prosecution being brought, or the case being dropped under certain conditions, because of effective repentance does not have the same legal consequence or reasoning as an acquittal. In addition, the effect of the decision in the criminal file on a case concerning the electricity debt is examined separately according to the finding on which the decision is based.
Simply waiting for the bill after the detection may make it harder to track the evidence and application deadlines. At the first stage, the following steps are useful:
The Regulation requires the detection of illegal consumption to be based on accurate findings and documents. It provides for the detection and procedures to be photographed and, for certain types of illegal use, for a video recording to be made as well. In an allegation of meter interference, meter replacement documents and laboratory examination become important depending on the nature of the case. [2]
| Document or record | Importance in the examination |
|---|---|
| Illegal electricity detection report | Shows the date, address, installation and detection method of the allegation. |
| Photographs and video | The concrete appearance of the alleged connection or interference is assessed. |
| Meter replacement and laboratory documents | The link between the identity of the meter examined and the technical findings is investigated. |
| Consumption and index history | Changes between periods and the basis of the calculation are examined. |
| Lease, handover and business records | The actual user and activity status in the relevant period are determined. |
Not signing the report does not automatically invalidate it; signing it does not remove every right to object either. The content of any statement in the document also matters. The absence of a photograph or a procedural defect does not automatically lead to cancellation in every case; the effect of the defect on the reliability of the detection and on the defence is assessed.
The illegal electricity consumption charge is not simply a unit price multiplied by a coefficient. First, the amount of consumption and the period on which the calculation is based are determined. Factors such as the type of illegal use, data from a correctly recording meter, comparable consumption history, power and operating time are assessed according to the relevant method. [2]
Article 46 of the Regulation sets the basic coefficient at 2. If illegal consumption by the same consumer has been detected at the same or another place of use within the past three years, a coefficient of 2.5 may apply. A previous detection belonging to another user does not justify applying the repeat-use coefficient directly to the new user. For older incidents, the applicable legislation must be determined separately. [2]
The following points are examined in particular when checking the calculation:
Rather than a general objection that "the bill is too high", explaining which parameter is wrong and why makes the technical examination concrete.
An objection to the illegal-use bill and its calculation is addressed to the distribution company that carried out the procedure. Under Article 47 of the Regulation, an objection may be made with evidence and documents within six months of the notification date; the company must conclude the objection within ten working days at the latest. Making the application does not automatically remove the obligation to pay. [2]
The petition should clearly show the report and bill details, the period objected to, the correction requested and the grounds. Objections relating to the actual user, the detection method and the calculation can be explained separately. The application number or delivery receipt should be kept.
Further explanations on the content of the application and how to organise the documents can be found in our article on objecting to an illegal electricity use penalty. An application to the company does not replace an objection that must be made to the enforcement office or the defence in the criminal file.
| Step | Time limit or basic rule | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Sending the illegal-use bill | No later than 3 working days from the detection date | EPTHY Art. 47/1 |
| Payment period given in the bill | At least 10 days | EPTHY Art. 47/1 |
| Objection to the company against the illegal-use bill | 6 months from the notification date | EPTHY Art. 47/2 |
| Company concluding the objection | No later than 10 working days | EPTHY Art. 47/2 |
| Payment notice before legal action | As a rule, notice that the debt must be paid within 15 days | EPTHY Art. 47/4 |
| Objection in general enforcement without judgment | As a rule, 7 days from service of the payment order | IIK Art. 62 |
| Recovery under IIK Art. 72 | For a payment made under the conditions of the article, 1 year from the payment date | IIK Art. 72 |
| Effective repentance preventing prosecution | Full compensation before the investigation is completed, under the statutory conditions | TCK Art. 168/5 |
These time limits start at different points. The six-month period for objecting to the company is not a common period applying to all lawsuits and enforcement remedies. In addition, exceptions in the Regulation, such as the required notification having been made within the last year for the collection of ongoing illegal use, must be taken into account. [1][2][4]
In general enforcement proceedings without a judgment, the period to object to the payment order is, as a rule, seven days from service. The type of proceedings and whether service was proper must also be checked. The effect of an objection made in time depends on its scope. [4]
Having previously submitted a petition to the distribution company does not automatically stop enforcement proceedings. Even if the period to object to the debt has passed, it cannot be said that every legal remedy has gone; a negative declaratory action, a complaint of improper service or other relevant applications are examined according to the specific circumstances.
If an enforcement payment order has arrived, you should record not only the amount of the debt but also the service date, file number, the full trade name of the creditor company and any additional items claimed.
A negative declaratory action aims to establish that all or part of the alleged debt does not exist. Claims that illegal use did not occur, that the charge was demanded from the wrong person or that the calculation is wrong may be assessed in this context.
If the debt has been paid, a claim for a refund, that is recovery, may arise depending on the circumstances of the payment. The one-year period in IIK Art. 72 relates to full payment of money not owed because of enforcement proceedings, as described in that article. It is not correct to apply the same period to every electricity payment. [4]
Filing a negative declaratory action does not automatically stop enforcement proceedings. The scope of interim legal protection may vary depending on when the proceedings began, the dates of mediation and the lawsuit, security conditions and the court's decision. For detailed explanations, see our article on the negative declaratory action for an illegal electricity debt.
Article 47/3 of the Regulation allows electricity to be reconnected until the objection is concluded, on condition that security is provided for the amount objected to. However, filing an objection or a lawsuit does not, on its own, result in the electricity being reconnected automatically. [2]
Especially for business premises, the effect of the disconnection on operations can be documented. Security, subscription obligations and the interim legal protection the case requires are assessed together. Rather than the user reconnecting the electricity without permission, the distribution company's official connection process should be followed.
It must be determined in whose period the illegal use took place. The lease, key handover document, subscription dates and usage records are important in this distinction. A new tenant does not incur criminal liability for the previous tenant's act merely because they moved into the same property. [1]
If a subscription cannot be opened because of a previous user's debt, this issue should be handled separately from the illegal-use allegation. The relevant remedies are explained in our article on a subscription refused because of a former tenant's debt.
Owning the property does not, on its own, mean committing the offence of unlawful benefit. Criminal liability is personal. On the other hand, matters such as who carried out the use, the owner's participation in the interference and the subscription relationship may be investigated. Criminal liability and liability for a debt under private law should not be confused.
At business premises, a company subscription or the status of manager or employee does not on its own determine criminal liability. The position of the individuals who made the interference, had it made or knowingly took part in it is examined. In transfers of a business, the previous and subsequent periods of activity, the transfer documents and actual use should be assessed together.
Electricity distribution on Istanbul's European Side is carried out by BEDAŞ and on the Anatolian Side by AYEDAŞ. The distribution company's procedures are important in the detection and charging of illegal consumption. The electricity distribution company and the supply company that is party to the retail sales contract should not be treated as the same legal entity. [2][8][9]
| Area | Distribution company | Information to check in the application |
|---|---|---|
| Istanbul European Side | BEDAŞ | The company that issued the report and bill, installation number and place of use |
| Istanbul Anatolian Side | AYEDAŞ | The company that issued the report and bill, installation number and place of use |
The basic legislation is the same for a file in Kağıthane, Şişli, Beşiktaş, Bakırköy or Esenyurt as for one in Kadıköy, Üsküdar, Ümraniye, Kartal or Pendik. The office to apply to and the court's jurisdiction, however, are determined by the place of use and the nature of the dispute. A lawsuit or objection is not prepared on the basis of the company's brand name alone; the full trade name in the documents is used.
Criminal proceedings for the offence of unlawful benefit are generally heard in the criminal court of first instance. Special situations, such as jurisdiction rules specific to children, are assessed separately. The same jurisdiction rule does not apply to a civil case concerning the electricity debt.
Whether the civil dispute arises from a consumer transaction, is a commercial case or is subject to general provisions affects whether it goes to the consumer court, the commercial court of first instance or the civil court of first instance. Where appropriate, the jurisdiction of the consumer arbitration committee and the monetary limit on the application date are also checked. No firm conclusion should be reached based only on "residence" or "business" being written on the bill.
In consumer court disputes, mediation is a precondition for filing a case, except for statutory exceptions. Pre-action mediation is also required in certain commercial money claims, annulment of objection, negative declaratory and recovery actions. Mediation in the civil dispute does not automatically end the criminal investigation. [6][7]
The lawyer's work may require assessing the criminal, billing and enforcement aspects of the file together. It is not limited to submitting a ready-made objection petition:
To have your file assessed by Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun based on its stage and the documents available, you can apply through the contact and appointment page. In the first assessment, the notification dates of the report, the bill and, if any, the payment order or prosecutor's summons are particularly important.
The absence of some documents should not be a reason to postpone seeking advice. Urgent deadlines can first be determined with the documents available; who to request the missing records from can be planned later.
One of the most common problems is believing that because an objection was made to the company, other time limits have also stopped. In addition, not obtaining the report and technical records, not documenting the moving-in date, objecting to the expert report only in general terms and signing a restructuring agreement without reading it can make the file harder to pursue.
It is also wrong to assume in the criminal file that any payment is sufficient for effective repentance without calculating the actual loss. The steps of objection, payment and defence should be determined by assessing the content of the documents and the stage of the file together.
No fixed time applying to all disputes can be given for the duration of the file. The need for technical examination, expert reports, notifications, hearings and appeals may affect the process. The ten working days provided for the company to conclude an objection is not the duration of court proceedings.
The scope of the lawyer's fee is determined by whether only an objection to the company will be made, whether representation in the criminal file is needed, and whether there are also enforcement proceedings or a civil case. The fee agreement should clearly show which work is covered and how litigation costs will be met.
This content has been prepared for general information purposes. A legal assessment should be made taking into account the legislation applicable on the date of the event and the documents in the file.
No. The report is a detection document. For criminal liability, the statutory elements of the offence, intent and the link between the act and the person are investigated. The debt dispute relating to the bill is also assessed separately. [1][2]
Not on its own. Actual use during the relevant period and your link to the interference are examined. However, private law liability that may arise from the subscription contract is a separate matter.
The timing and amount of the payment and the conditions of effective repentance are decisive. Full compensation of the loss under the statutory conditions before the investigation is completed may prevent a public prosecution. The outcome of later payments is assessed separately. [1][5]
Having made a payment does not, on its own, remove every possibility of objection or refund. However, the content of any settlement, waiver or restructuring document signed and the application deadlines must be examined.
The Regulation provides six months from the notification date for an objection to the distribution company. In general enforcement proceedings without a judgment, the objection to the payment order is, as a rule, seven days from service. These two applications are different. [2][4]
An objection to the company does not automatically remove the obligation to pay or the possibility of proceedings. The pre-action notification conditions should be checked; if a payment order is served, the enforcement deadline must be followed separately.
The user's absence during the detection does not automatically invalidate the report. The detection method, technical evidence and the rules on notification of the report are examined. Special notification exceptions in the Regulation must also be taken into account. [2]
A technical fault is not the same as deliberate interference that prevents consumption from being determined. The cause of the fault and its effect on measurement must be determined by technical examination. A mere fault does not show that the person intentionally committed an offence.
The distribution company issuing a bill or an investigation being opened does not, on its own, create a conviction record. The nature of the final decision and the criminal records legislation are decisive. Special records relating to effective repentance should not be treated in the same way as an ordinary conviction record.
Prosecution of the offence under TCK Art. 163/3 does not depend on a complaint. Therefore, the company withdrawing its complaint does not, on its own, end the criminal file. The conditions of effective repentance must be examined separately. [1]
The basic regulation and objection period for illegal consumption bills are the same in both distribution areas. The application must be made with the correct company and installation details.
It is useful to have the documents assessed once the report or bill arrives. If there is service of an enforcement payment order, a prosecutor's summons, a high charge or a disconnection at business premises, the assessment should not be delayed so that the relevant deadlines are not missed.