Appealing a Prosecutor’s Decision Not to Prosecute

Appealing a Prosecutor’s Decision Not to Prosecute
05 Oct

A non-prosecution decision issued by the Public Prosecutor's Office, legally referred to as a decision of non-prosecution (KYOK), is issued when, at the end of the investigation, it is concluded that there is insufficient evidence to establish reasonable suspicion required to initiate a public prosecution or that prosecution is not legally possible. The person who has suffered harm from the crime may object to this decision in accordance with the period and procedure prescribed by law.

Under Article 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK), an objection to a non-prosecution decision must be filed within two weeks from the date the decision is served on the person who has suffered harm from the crime. The objection is submitted to the Criminal Judgeship of Peace located in the place where the assize court in the judicial district of the Public Prosecutor who issued the decision is located.

What Is a Non-Prosecution Decision?

A non-prosecution decision is a decision indicating that the Public Prosecutor does not consider it necessary to initiate a public prosecution at the end of the investigation. Under Article 172 of the CMK, a decision of non-prosecution may be issued where sufficient evidence establishing the required level of suspicion for initiating a public prosecution cannot be obtained or where prosecution is not legally possible.

The issuance of a non-prosecution decision does not mean that the person who was reported has been conclusively determined to be innocent by a court judgment. The decision means that the investigation stage ends without initiating a public prosecution.

Can a Non-Prosecution Decision Be Challenged?

Yes. The person who has suffered harm from the crime may object to a decision of non-prosecution issued by the Public Prosecutor under Article 173 of the CMK. The purpose of the objection is to ensure that the decision issued by the prosecution and whether the investigation was sufficient are reviewed by the competent judicial authority.

The objection petition should not merely state that the decision is unjust. Specific facts and evidence that may require the initiation of a public prosecution must be explained.

How Long Is the Time Limit for Objecting to a Non-Prosecution Decision?

Under the current Article 173/1 of the CMK, the period for objecting to a non-prosecution decision is two weeks. The period begins on the date the decision of non-prosecution is served on the person who has suffered harm from the crime.

It is possible to encounter a 15-day objection period in older sources. However, for decisions issued on or after June 1, 2024, the current regulation applies a period of two weeks. Therefore, the date of service of the decision should be carefully monitored and the objection period should not be missed.

Where Should an Objection to a Non-Prosecution Decision Be Filed?

A non-prosecution decision is not directly challenged before another Public Prosecutor. Under Article 173 of the CMK, the objection must be filed with the Criminal Judgeship of Peace located in the place where the assize court in the judicial district of the Public Prosecutor who issued the decision is located.

In practice, the objection petition may also be submitted through the relevant Chief Public Prosecutor's Office to be forwarded to the competent Criminal Judgeship of Peace. The investigation file number, decision number, and date of the decision should be clearly stated in the petition.

How Is an Objection to a Non-Prosecution Decision Made?

The objection is made through a written petition. The petition should first specify which Chief Public Prosecutor's Office issued the non-prosecution decision and the investigation and decision numbers of the relevant file. The reasons why the decision is contrary to law or the contents of the case file should then be explained.

The most important part of the objection is identifying the facts and evidence that may require the initiation of a public prosecution. For example, if there is a camera recording that was never investigated by the prosecution, a witness who was not heard, a bank transaction that was not examined, or a document that was not taken into consideration, these matters should be clearly specified.

What Should Be Included in an Objection Petition Against a Non-Prosecution Decision?

  • Name of the competent Criminal Judgeship of Peace
  • Name and contact information of the person filing the objection
  • Attorney's information, if applicable
  • Information about the suspect
  • Name of the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office
  • Investigation number
  • Date and decision number of the non-prosecution decision
  • Date on which the decision was served
  • Grounds for objecting to the non-prosecution decision
  • Evidence that was insufficiently investigated or not taken into consideration
  • Newly submitted documents, if any
  • Requested relief

At the end of the petition, a request may be made for the decision of non-prosecution to be revoked and, if deemed necessary, for the investigation to be expanded or for the necessary procedures to be carried out to enable the initiation of a public prosecution.

What Grounds Can Be Used When Objecting to a Non-Prosecution Decision?

The grounds for objection vary depending on the characteristics of each investigation. If it is believed that the prosecution failed to collect sufficient evidence, incorrectly assessed existing evidence, failed to hear witnesses, failed to investigate camera recordings, or failed to conduct an expert examination, these matters may be explained specifically.

It may also be argued that there is a contradiction between the conclusion reached in the prosecutorial decision and the evidence contained in the case file. However, rather than using general statements such as “I request that the decision be revoked,” it is important to provide specific explanations demonstrating why there is sufficient suspicion to require the initiation of a public prosecution.

Can an Incomplete Investigation Be a Ground for Objecting to a Non-Prosecution Decision?

Yes. If it is believed that the investigation was not conducted with sufficient scope, this may be explained in detail in the objection petition. In particular, the failure to collect evidence that is important for clarifying the incident may be significant when filing an objection.

For example, circumstances such as failing to investigate camera recordings even though cameras were present at the location of the incident, failing to hear witnesses who had information about the incident, or failing to conduct a necessary expert examination may be presented as grounds that could require the investigation to be expanded.

What Should Be Done If There Is New Evidence?

If new evidence has been obtained during the objection against a non-prosecution decision, the nature of the evidence and its significance for the investigation should be explained in the petition. New evidence may include camera footage, a document, messages, a witness, a bank record, or another piece of data that may contribute to clarifying the incident.

If the objection period has expired, the emergence of new evidence becomes particularly important. However, reopening an investigation for the same act after a finalized non-prosecution decision is subject to the conditions set out in Article 172 of the CMK. Therefore, it should be separately assessed whether the evidence is genuinely new and whether it is significant in terms of initiating a public prosecution.

Which Court Reviews an Objection to a Non-Prosecution Decision?

An objection to a non-prosecution decision is reviewed by the competent Criminal Judgeship of Peace under Article 173 of the CMK. When determining jurisdiction, the judicial district of the Public Prosecutor who issued the decision and the location of the assize court to which the prosecutor is attached are taken into consideration.

If the Criminal Judgeship of Peace considers that the existing case file is insufficient for an assessment, it may request the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office to expand the investigation. If it concludes that there are insufficient grounds to initiate a public prosecution, it rejects the objection with reasons.

What Happens If an Objection to a Non-Prosecution Decision Is Accepted?

If the Criminal Judgeship of Peace finds the objection justified, the necessary procedures under Article 173 of the CMK and the process of initiating a public prosecution may come into question. When the judge finds the request justified, the Public Prosecutor prepares an indictment and submits it to the competent court.

However, acceptance of the objection does not mean that the suspect has been conclusively determined to be guilty. Acceptance of the objection opens the way for the transition from the investigation stage to the prosecution stage; whether the person is guilty is determined as a result of the subsequent criminal trial.

What Happens If an Objection to a Non-Prosecution Decision Is Rejected?

If the objection is rejected, the non-prosecution decision may become final. Under Article 173/6 of the CMK, the conditions set out in Article 172/2 of the CMK must be met for a public prosecution to be initiated again for the same act.

Therefore, new evidence that emerges later may be important regarding the same incident. However, the existence of new evidence alone does not automatically mean that a public prosecution will be initiated in every case; the statutory conditions must be satisfied.

The Importance of Evidence When Objecting to a Non-Prosecution Decision

For an objection to a non-prosecution decision to be successful, it is important to clearly identify the evidence contained in the case file or the evidence that is believed should have been collected during the investigation. The connection of the evidence to the incident and why it may establish sufficient suspicion to initiate a public prosecution should be explained.

Matter That May Be Raised in the Objection
Example
Missing evidence
Failure to investigate camera recordings, bank transactions, or documents
Witness not heard
Failure to hear a person who directly witnessed the incident or has information about it
Incomplete expert examination
Failure to conduct a technical, digital, financial, or forensic examination
Incorrect assessment of evidence
A contradiction between the existing evidence in the case file and the reasoning of the prosecutorial decision

How Is an Objection Petition Against a Non-Prosecution Decision Prepared?

An objection petition should clearly demonstrate why the investigation needs to be reconsidered. First, the grounds on which the non-prosecution decision was issued should be explained, followed by a specific demonstration, based on evidence, of why those grounds are inconsistent with the contents of the case file.

If the investigation needs to be expanded, the specific procedures that should be carried out should also be listed individually in the petition. For example, specific requests such as obtaining a particular camera recording, hearing a particular person as a witness, or sending a digital device or material for expert examination may strengthen the content of the objection.

Legal Assistance from an Attorney in Objecting to a Non-Prosecution Decision

When objecting to a non-prosecution decision, it is important not only to avoid missing the two-week deadline but also to provide specific and legally substantiated grounds for the objection. In particular, it is necessary to identify which evidence was not considered in the prosecutorial decision and which investigative procedures were not carried out.

Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may provide a legal assessment concerning the examination of the scope of the case file, identification of missing evidence, and specification of the grounds for objection during the process of challenging a non-prosecution decision. Depending on the nature of the criminal investigation, obtaining legal assistance in the field of criminal law may contribute to conducting the process in accordance with procedural requirements.

In particular, calculating the deadline, determining the competent authority, and clearly identifying the facts and evidence that may require the initiation of a public prosecution in the objection petition are important. A legal assessment by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun based on the specific characteristics of the case file may help determine which issues the objection should be based on.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many days are there to object to a non-prosecution decision?

Under the current Article 173 of the CMK, a non-prosecution decision may be challenged within two weeks from the date the decision is served on the person who has suffered harm from the crime.

Where should an objection to a non-prosecution decision be filed?

The objection must be filed with the Criminal Judgeship of Peace located in the place where the assize court in the judicial district of the Public Prosecutor who issued the decision is located.

Who can object to a non-prosecution decision?

Under Article 173 of the CMK, the right to object belongs to the person who has suffered harm from the crime.

What happens if an objection to a non-prosecution decision is accepted?

If the Criminal Judgeship of Peace finds the request justified, the necessary procedures are carried out and, within the framework of the statutory conditions, the Public Prosecutor prepares an indictment and the process of initiating a public prosecution begins.

Can a complaint be filed again if an objection to a non-prosecution decision is rejected?

Initiating a public prosecution again for the same act is subject to the conditions set out in Article 172/2 of the CMK. In particular, it is important whether new evidence has subsequently emerged.

Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may provide a legal assessment based on the specific circumstances of the case file to help determine the appropriate course of action in the process of challenging a non-prosecution decision.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer, Reinstatement Case Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…