Can a Decision to Disinherit an Heir Be Challenged?

Can a Decision to Disinherit an Heir Be Challenged?
05 Oct

​

A person who has been disinherited may challenge the deceased’s decision. Under Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code, the disinherited person may argue that the stated ground did not exist, was insufficient, or was not specified in the will. Depending on the circumstances, an action for cancellation or reduction may be available.

For disinheritance to be valid, the statutory conditions must exist and the ground must be stated in the testamentary disposition. As a rule, the heir or legatee who benefits from the disinheritance bears the burden of proving that ground. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can review the will and inheritance documents and assess whether the challenge should be pursued through cancellation, reduction, or another appropriate claim.

What Is Disinheritance?

Disinheritance is a testamentary disposition by which the deceased deprives an heir with a reserved share of inheritance rights when one of the statutory grounds exists. Article 510 of the Turkish Civil Code provides two principal grounds:

  • The heir has committed a serious crime against the deceased or a person close to the deceased.
  • The heir has seriously failed to perform family-law obligations owed to the deceased or members of the deceased’s family.

A disinheritance made without these conditions may become the subject of a legal dispute. Like other succession disputes, the matter may require an assessment under inheritance law.

Can a Disinheritance Decision Be Challenged?

Yes. A disinherited person who believes the disposition is invalid may challenge it in court. A challenge may be based on the will’s failure to state a ground, the stated ground’s failure to meet statutory requirements, or the fact that the alleged conduct never occurred.

Under Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code, the burden of proving the stated ground rests on the heir or legatee who benefits from the disinheritance.

Must the Ground Be Stated in the Will?

Yes. Disinheritance is valid only if the deceased states the ground in the testamentary disposition. Merely writing that an heir is disinherited may therefore be insufficient unless the other statutory requirements are also satisfied.

If no ground is clearly stated, or if the stated ground does not meet the legal conditions, the disinherited heir’s rights connected with the reserved share may arise.

What Happens If the Ground Cannot Be Proved?

If the alleged ground cannot be proved, the disposition is subject to the consequences set out in Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code. As a rule, it may remain effective only to the extent that it does not infringe the heir’s reserved share.

Turkish Court of Cassation practice also recognizes that, where the ground cannot be proved, the heir may claim the reserved share and the dispute may be examined under the rules governing reduction.

On What Grounds May Disinheritance Be Challenged?

Depending on the facts, a disinherited heir may rely on more than one legal ground. The appropriate action must be determined by considering why the disposition is allegedly invalid and how the remaining provisions of the will are affected.

  • No ground for disinheritance is stated in the will.
  • The stated ground does not satisfy the statutory requirements.
  • The stated ground did not exist in fact.
  • The stated ground cannot be proved.
  • The will does not comply with formal requirements.
  • The deceased lacked legal capacity to make the will.
  • There are general grounds for cancellation, such as a defect of intention.

Should a Cancellation Action or a Reduction Action Be Filed?

The correct action depends on the legal basis of the challenge. If the testamentary disposition itself is alleged to be invalid, an action for cancellation may be appropriate. If the disposition infringes a reserved share and must be limited to that extent, an action for reduction may arise.

The Court of Cassation accepts that a disinherited person may, depending on the conditions, bring either a cancellation or reduction action. Successful cancellation can affect the heir’s full inheritance right, whereas reduction protects the reserved share.

Who Bears the Burden of Proof?

When the disinherited person disputes the stated ground, the heir or legatee who benefits from the disinheritance must prove that the ground existed. This rule is expressly stated in Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code.

For example, if the will alleges that the heir seriously failed to perform family-law obligations, that allegation must be supported by concrete evidence.

Against Whom Is the Action Filed?

It is important to identify the correct defendants in a cancellation or reduction action concerning disinheritance. Current Court of Cassation practice indicates that an action for cancellation should be directed against the heirs who benefit from the disinheritance.

Before filing, the will, the identity of the heirs, and the persons who benefit from the disposition should therefore be determined.

Which Court Has Jurisdiction?

Contested disputes arising from disinheritance are generally heard by the Civil Court of First Instance. The Court of Cassation likewise recognizes that the effect of disinheritance on heirship status and inheritance shares should be determined by that court in contentious proceedings.

Territorial jurisdiction must be assessed by considering the deceased’s last residence and the special jurisdiction rules for inheritance disputes.

What Evidence May Be Used?

Evidence showing whether the disinheritance is valid and whether the alleged ground actually existed may be submitted. The appropriate evidence depends on the circumstances. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assist in identifying and presenting relevant evidence in a manner consistent with procedural and evidentiary rules.

  • The will or another testamentary disposition
  • The certificate of inheritance
  • Witness statements
  • Correspondence and message records
  • Criminal investigation or court files
  • Documents concerning health or care needs
  • Documents relating to family-law obligations
  • Other lawfully obtained evidence

Is There a Time Limit for Challenging Disinheritance?

The applicable limitation or forfeiture period depends on the legal remedy. The time limits for cancellation and reduction actions are not identical.

The date on which the will was opened, the date of death, and the legal nature of the dispute must therefore be examined separately. Missing a time limit may cause a loss of rights. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assess the applicable periods by reference to the opening of the will and the specific claim contemplated.

Disinheritance and Reduction Compared

#
Criterion
Disinheritance
Reduction
1
Purpose
To deprive an heir with a reserved share of inheritance rights.
To protect the infringed portion of a reserved share.
2
Challenge
The heir may allege that no valid ground existed.
The heir alleges that the reserved share was infringed.
3
Result
Depending on the conditions, disinheritance may become wholly or partly ineffective.
The portion exceeding the disposable part may be reduced.

Important Points

  • Check whether the will clearly states the ground for disinheritance.
  • Assess whether that ground meets the requirements of Article 510 of the Turkish Civil Code.
  • Remember that the opposing party bears the burden of proving the ground.
  • Distinguish carefully between cancellation and reduction actions.
  • Direct the claim against the correct defendants.
  • Assess the relevant time limits and limitation rules separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a disinheritance decision be challenged?

Yes. Depending on the circumstances, the disinherited person may challenge the disposition through a cancellation or reduction action.

Who must prove the ground for disinheritance?

As a rule, the heir or legatee who benefits from the disinheritance must prove that the ground existed.

What happens if the will does not state a ground?

Under Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code, the disinheritance is not valid; the effect of the disposition beyond the reserved share must be assessed separately.

Which court hears a disinheritance case?

Contested disinheritance disputes are heard by the Civil Court of First Instance.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer, Reinstatement Case Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…