Can a Tenant Be Evicted Without a Tenancy Agreement?

Can a Tenant Be Evicted Without a Tenancy Agreement?
05 Oct

A tenant may be evicted even if the lease agreement was not made in writing. The absence of a written agreement does not automatically make the tenant's use of the property unlawful. Under the Turkish Code of Obligations, a lease agreement may be established through the mutual consent of the parties, and the existence of the lease relationship may be proven through various forms of evidence.

Therefore, a landlord cannot remove a tenant from the property on their own simply on the grounds that "there is no written lease agreement." One of the grounds for eviction regulated by law must exist, and the required legal procedure must be followed for the eviction to take place.

Can a Tenancy Exist Without a Written Lease Agreement?

Yes. As a general rule, a lease agreement does not have to be made in writing as a validity requirement. A tenancy relationship may be established when the parties agree to allow the tenant to use the property in return for the payment of rent.

Therefore, rental payments made through a bank, messages, correspondence between the parties, witness statements, and other documents may be important in establishing the existence of the tenancy relationship.

Is an Oral Lease Agreement Valid?

An orally concluded lease agreement may be valid unless the law specifically requires a particular form. However, in the absence of a written agreement, disputes between the parties are more likely to arise regarding the amount of rent, the commencement date of the tenancy, the duration of the lease, and other terms.

Therefore, regulating the tenancy relationship through a written agreement is a safer method in terms of proving the terms of the agreement for both the landlord and the tenant.

Can the Landlord Evict the Tenant Whenever They Want If There Is No Lease Agreement?

No. The absence of a written lease agreement does not give the landlord the right to evict the tenant whenever they want. If the existence of the tenancy relationship is accepted, one of the grounds for eviction regulated under the Turkish Code of Obligations must exist for the tenant to be evicted.

For example, the tenant's failure to pay rent or ancillary expenses, the tenant's execution of an undertaking to vacate, use of the leased property contrary to the agreement, or the existence of the statutory conditions for eviction due to a genuine need may give rise to different eviction procedures. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun states that, in tenancy disputes, it is important to correctly determine the ground for eviction and to follow the procedure prescribed by law.

In Which Cases Can Eviction Be Requested Without a Written Lease Agreement?

Even if there is no written agreement, the grounds for eviction regulated by law may be invoked depending on the terms of the existing tenancy relationship. The parties' actual practices and the circumstances under which the tenancy relationship was established are important in determining the ground for eviction.

  • Failure to pay the rent or ancillary expenses for which the tenant is responsible,
  • Use of the leased property contrary to the agreement or in breach of the duty of care,
  • The existence of a valid undertaking to vacate,
  • The landlord having a genuine need for a residence or business premises for themselves or the persons specified by law,
  • The occurrence of other grounds for eviction regulated by law.

Can the Landlord Request Eviction in Order to Live in the Property Themselves?

If the landlord, their spouse, descendants, ascendants, or persons whom they are legally obliged to support have a need for a residence or business premises, eviction due to necessity may be requested. Article 350 of the Turkish Code of Obligations specifically regulates this situation.

However, merely stating "I will live in my house myself" is not sufficient on its own for eviction. The need must be genuine and sincere, and the time limits and procedural requirements prescribed by law must be complied with. In disputes arising from the tenancy relationship, assessments made within the scope of real estate law may also be important.

Can a Tenant Be Evicted Without a Written Lease Agreement If Rent Is Not Paid?

Yes. The absence of a written agreement does not eliminate the tenant's obligation to pay rent when rent is unpaid. If the tenancy relationship and the amount of rent can be proven, eviction proceedings may be initiated due to the tenant's default.

Under Article 315 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, if the tenant fails to pay rent or ancillary expenses, the landlord may give written notice granting a period for payment and state that the agreement will be terminated if payment is not made. For residential and roofed commercial premises leases, this period is at least 30 days.

How Does the Eviction Process Work If There Is No Lease Agreement?

Stage
Action to Be Taken
Determining the tenancy relationship
It is determined whether a tenancy relationship exists between the parties, whether it was established orally or through actual conduct, and what its terms are.
Determining the ground for eviction
Unpaid rent, an undertaking to vacate, necessity, or other statutory grounds for eviction are assessed.
Notice or enforcement proceeding
Depending on the ground for eviction, a notice, enforcement proceeding, or other necessary legal actions are initiated. Where enforcement proceedings are required, the legal process may be assessed within the scope of enforcement and bankruptcy law.
Eviction process
If the necessary conditions are met, eviction is requested through a lawsuit or enforcement proceedings.

How Is the Lease Term Determined If There Is No Lease Agreement?

When there is no written agreement, the duration of the tenancy may be determined according to the parties' agreement and their actual practices. If the parties have not agreed on a specific period, the lease agreement may be considered to have been concluded for an indefinite term.

Determining the lease term is particularly important in terms of determining when an eviction action may be filed. Therefore, the commencement of the tenancy and the agreements made by the parties should be established through documents to the greatest extent possible.

What Must Be Proven in an Eviction Action Without a Lease Agreement?

The court first assesses whether a tenancy relationship exists between the parties and the ground for eviction underlying the dispute. Since there is no written agreement, bank records concerning rental payments, receipts, messages, and other documents may become important.

The landlord must establish the legal ground on which the eviction request is based and, where necessary, the events constituting that ground. The tenant may also present evidence regarding the terms of the tenancy relationship or their defenses against the eviction request.

Is an Undertaking to Vacate Valid Without a Lease Agreement?

The absence of a written lease agreement between the parties does not, by itself, prevent an undertaking to vacate from being considered. However, the conditions prescribed by law must be satisfied for the undertaking to vacate to be valid.

Under Article 352 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, if the tenant undertakes in writing, after the leased property has been delivered, to vacate the property on a specified date, and the property is not vacated on the promised date, the landlord may initiate enforcement proceedings or file a lawsuit within the period prescribed by law.

Can the Landlord Change the Locks Without a Lease Agreement?

No. If a tenancy relationship exists between the parties and the tenant has a legal right to use the property, the landlord's unilateral replacement of the locks or prevention of the tenant from entering the property is not a lawful method of eviction.

If the tenant needs to be removed from the property, the eviction procedures prescribed by law must be used. The landlord's taking direct physical action may also lead to other legal disputes.

Is Mediation Required Before Filing an Eviction Action Without a Lease Agreement?

If the dispute is an eviction dispute arising from a tenancy relationship, the mandatory mediation requirements must be applied before filing a lawsuit. The absence of a written agreement does not eliminate this requirement if the dispute is considered to arise from a tenancy relationship.

If no settlement is reached during the mediation process, an action may be filed, where the conditions are met, following the issuance of the final mediation record. The procedure to be followed must be determined separately according to the nature of the ground for eviction. In tenancy disputes, obtaining mediation services regarding alternative dispute resolution methods may also be considered.

How Long Can a Tenant Stay Without a Lease Agreement?

The absence of a written agreement does not give the tenant an automatic right to leave the property after a certain period, nor does it give the landlord the right to evict the tenant whenever they wish. The duration of the tenancy is determined according to the parties' agreement and the circumstances of the specific case.

Therefore, there is no general rule stating that "if there is no agreement, the tenant is evicted after one year" or that "if there is no agreement, the tenant can stay as long as they want."

Points to Consider

  • The absence of a written lease agreement does not mean that there is no tenancy relationship.
  • An oral lease agreement may be valid depending on the circumstances of the specific case.
  • The landlord cannot evict the tenant merely on the basis that the lease agreement is not in writing.
  • The eviction must be based on a valid ground regulated by law.
  • If rent is not paid, the required notice and payment period under Article 315 of the Turkish Code of Obligations must be observed.
  • If there is an undertaking to vacate, the date on which the document was executed and its contents should be separately examined.
  • The mandatory mediation requirements must be taken into account in eviction actions arising from tenancy relationships.
  • The landlord changing the locks or forcibly removing the tenant is not an appropriate method of eviction.

The absence of a written lease agreement requires the legal basis for eviction and the applicable procedure to be assessed according to the circumstances of the specific case. Therefore, the establishment of the tenancy relationship, payment records, and ground for eviction should be examined together. The legal assessment to be made by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may assist in determining which eviction procedure can be applied.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a tenant be evicted if there is no lease agreement?

Yes. However, the absence of a written agreement is not, by itself, a ground for eviction. One of the grounds for eviction prescribed by law must exist.

Is an oral lease agreement valid?

Yes. As a general rule, a lease agreement does not have to be made in writing as a validity requirement. However, proving the terms of the agreement becomes important.

Can the landlord immediately evict the tenant because there is no agreement?

No. One of the statutory eviction procedures must be used for the tenant to be evicted.

Can a tenant be evicted without a lease agreement if rent is not paid?

Yes. If the tenancy relationship and rental debt can be proven and the relevant statutory requirements are fulfilled, eviction due to default may be pursued.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…