How Can a Landlord Evict a Tenant to Live in the Property Themselves?

How Can a Landlord Evict a Tenant to Live in the Property Themselves?
05 Oct

A landlord may evict a tenant in order to live in the property himself; however, merely wanting to use the property does not mean that the landlord can directly remove the tenant. Pursuant to Article 350 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, an eviction action due to necessity may be filed if the landlord, his spouse, descendants, ascendants, or persons whom he is legally obliged to support have a residential or commercial premises need.

Certain conditions and time limits must be complied with in evictions due to necessity. In addition, in rental disputes, the mandatory mediation process must generally be completed before filing a lawsuit. In this process, it is important to assess disputes within the scope of real estate law according to the circumstances of the specific case.

Can a Landlord Evict a Tenant by Saying That He Will Live in the Property Himself?

If the landlord's desire to live in the property is based on a genuine residential need regulated by law, it may constitute grounds for eviction. However, merely telling the tenant verbally, "I will live in the house myself," is not sufficient for eviction.

The landlord's claim of necessity must be genuine, sincere, and necessary, and the eviction process must be carried out in accordance with the law. In the event of a dispute, these matters are assessed by the court according to the circumstances of the specific case.

What Are the Conditions for Eviction Due to Necessity?

As a general matter, an eviction action due to necessity requires a genuine need to use the leased property as a residence or commercial premises. The Turkish Code of Obligations regulates not only the landlord's own need but also the need arising for the landlord's spouse, descendants, ascendants, and persons whom the landlord is legally obliged to support as grounds for eviction.

It is important that the necessity be clearly and concretely established during the proceedings. Merely wanting to rent out the property at a higher price does not, by itself, constitute grounds for eviction due to necessity.

Should a Landlord Send a Notice to the Tenant if He Will Live in the Property Himself?

The procedure to be followed for eviction due to necessity may vary depending on the term of the lease agreement and the provision on which the ground for eviction is based. In fixed-term lease agreements, attention must be paid to the statutory time limits in order to file an eviction action at the end of the lease term pursuant to Article 350 of the Turkish Code of Obligations.

A notice or written notification may be important for preventing loss of rights in the specific case. The content of the notification, the date of service, and the expiration date of the lease agreement should be evaluated together.

Can a Tenant Be Evicted Before the Lease Agreement Ends?

The term of the lease agreement is important with regard to eviction due to necessity. In a fixed-term lease agreement, the tenant generally cannot be immediately evicted during the term of the agreement merely because the landlord wants to live in the property himself.

If the conditions stipulated in Article 350 of the Turkish Code of Obligations are fulfilled, an eviction action may be filed according to the expiration period of the agreement. Therefore, the start and end dates of the lease agreement should first be determined.

Time Limits for Eviction Due to Necessity

Situation
Applicable Procedure
Fixed-term lease
Eviction due to necessity may be requested at the end of the lease term, taking into account the conditions and filing period set forth in Article 350 of the Turkish Code of Obligations.
Existence of necessity
There must be a genuine and sincere residential or commercial premises need for the landlord himself or the relatives specified by law.
Pre-litigation process
In rental disputes, mandatory mediation as a prerequisite for litigation must generally be pursued before filing a lawsuit.

How Does the Landlord Prove His Need?

In an eviction action due to necessity, the court assesses whether the need asserted by the landlord is genuine and sincere. The landlord's existing housing conditions, family circumstances, the intended use of the property, work or living conditions, and other matters relating to the specific case may be considered as evidence.

The court is not required to decide solely on the basis of the landlord's statement. Documents submitted by the parties, witness statements, and other circumstances of the case may be evaluated together to determine whether the claim of necessity is legally valid.

What Happens If the Landlord Says "I Will Live There Myself" and Then Rents the Property to Someone Else?

If a property evicted due to necessity is subsequently rented to another person, this may have significant legal consequences for the former tenant depending on the circumstances of the specific case. Article 355 of the Turkish Code of Obligations imposes a restriction on renting a property evicted due to necessity to anyone other than the former tenant for a period of three years unless there is a justified reason.

Therefore, consistency between the necessity asserted in the eviction action and the use of the property after eviction is important. If the property is re-rented in violation of the law, the former tenant may have the opportunity to claim compensation. In assessing such claims, rules applicable under compensation law may also be taken into consideration.

Can a Landlord Evict a Tenant Without Going to Court in Order to Live in the Property Himself?

If the tenant voluntarily agrees to vacate the property, the parties may terminate the tenancy relationship by agreement. However, if the tenant does not want to leave, the landlord changing the locks on his own, removing the tenant's belongings, or preventing the tenant from using the property is not a legally valid method of eviction.

When the tenant does not consent, the legal remedies provided by law must be used for eviction. If legal proceedings are to be initiated for eviction due to necessity, the mediation process must also be taken into consideration.

Where Is an Eviction Action Due to Necessity Filed?

Eviction actions due to necessity are generally heard by the Civil Court of Peace at the location where the property is situated. However, before filing a lawsuit, the mandatory mediation requirement must be fulfilled for disputes arising from the tenancy relationship.

As of September 1, 2023, in disputes arising from tenancy relationships, subject to the exceptions provided by law, applying to a mediator before filing a lawsuit is a prerequisite for litigation.

What Documents May Be Required in an Eviction Action Due to Necessity?

  • Lease agreement,
  • Title deed or documents showing ownership of the property,
  • Notice and service documents,
  • Documents demonstrating the necessity,
  • Witnesses and other evidence, if any,
  • Final mediation report.

The required documents may vary depending on the nature of the asserted need and the circumstances of the specific case. In particular, it is important to properly submit evidence demonstrating the reason for the necessity.

Can a Tenant Object to Eviction Due to Necessity?

In an eviction action filed against them, the tenant may argue that the landlord's claim of necessity is not genuine or sincere, that the statutory conditions have not been fulfilled, or that the required filing and notification periods have not been complied with.

The court decides whether the conditions for eviction have been fulfilled by evaluating the parties' allegations and defenses together with the evidence they submit. Therefore, the landlord's statement that "I will live there myself" does not automatically result in eviction.

How Long Does an Eviction Action Due to Necessity Take?

The time required for lawsuits to be concluded may vary depending on the court's workload, the evidence, the parties' allegations and defenses, and the characteristics of the dispute. Therefore, it is not possible to provide a definite period for every case.

Since the mandatory mediation process must be completed before the lawsuit is filed, and the lawsuit must then be initiated, it is important to plan the eviction process in advance by taking the applicable time limits into account. Obtaining legal support from Attorney Mehmet Kurşun for assessing the specific case and determining the legal course of action to be followed may help ensure that the applicable time limits are properly monitored.

Points to Consider

  • The landlord's genuine desire to live in the property himself is not sufficient on its own; there must be a legally valid necessity.
  • The start and end dates of the lease agreement must be checked.
  • Legal time limits must be observed in notices and notifications.
  • Documents and other evidence supporting the claim of necessity should be prepared.
  • The mandatory mediation requirement must be fulfilled before filing a lawsuit.
  • The restrictions set forth in Article 355 of the Turkish Code of Obligations regarding re-renting the property after eviction must be taken into account.
  • Practical methods such as changing the locks or preventing the tenant from accessing the property without the tenant's consent should not be used.

In eviction actions due to necessity, the lease agreement, the claim of necessity, and the statutory time limits must be evaluated together. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may assist in assessing the legal remedies that can be pursued during the eviction process according to the circumstances of the specific case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a landlord evict a tenant if he will live in the property himself?

Yes. If there is a genuine and sincere residential need and the conditions set forth in the Turkish Code of Obligations are complied with, eviction due to necessity may be requested.

Can a landlord evict a tenant whenever he wants?

No. While the lease agreement is still in force, the landlord's desire to live in the property does not, by itself, give him the right to immediately evict the tenant.

Can a landlord rent the property to someone else after evicting the tenant?

In cases of eviction due to necessity, the prohibition and exceptions regarding re-renting regulated under Article 355 of the Turkish Code of Obligations must be taken into consideration.

Is mediation mandatory for eviction due to necessity?

Yes. In eviction disputes arising from a tenancy relationship, except for the exceptions provided by law, mediation must be pursued before filing a lawsuit.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…