How to Bring an Inheritance Recovery Action

How to Bring an Inheritance Recovery Action
05 Oct

An inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property is an action filed by a legal or appointed heir against a person who possesses the estate or certain assets belonging to the estate, by asserting the heir's superior right to the inheritance. Regulated under Article 637 of the Turkish Civil Code, this action allows the heir to request the return of estate assets that should belong to them.

In order to file the action, the plaintiff must have the status of an heir and assert a superior inheritance right against the person who possesses all or some of the estate assets. In such disputes arising from inheritance law, it is important to properly assess the rules of inheritance law.

What Is an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

An inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property is an inheritance action filed by a person claiming to be an heir against a person who possesses all or part of the estate assets. The primary purpose of the action is to protect the heir's superior right arising from inheritance and to ensure that the estate assets are transferred to the heir.

Not only immovable properties but also movable assets and other property values included in the estate may be the subject of the dispute in this action.

Who Can File an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

According to Article 637 of the Turkish Civil Code, a legal or appointed heir may file an inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property against a person who possesses the estate or certain estate assets.

The plaintiff must establish their claim concerning their status as an heir during the proceedings. If there is a dispute between the parties regarding heirship, this dispute may also be evaluated by the court within the scope of the action.

Under What Conditions Is an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property Filed?

The fundamental requirement for the action is that the plaintiff is a legal or appointed heir and asserts that they have a superior inheritance right over the estate assets. In addition, the estate asset or assets must be in the possession of another person.

The court evaluates the parties' status as heirs and whether the assets in dispute are included in the estate. If the action is upheld, the estate or the asset included in the estate is transferred to the plaintiff within the framework of the provisions concerning possession.

How Is an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property Filed?

The action is filed by submitting a statement of claim to the court with subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction. The statement of claim must explain the plaintiff's status as an heir, the asset or assets claimed to be included in the estate, the person possessing these assets, and the grounds for the plaintiff's superior right to the inheritance.

An inheritance certificate, land registry records, a will, bank records, contracts, and other evidence depending on the nature of the dispute may be submitted to the case file.

What Decision Can the Court Issue in an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

If the court determines that the plaintiff is an heir and has a superior right over the estate asset, it may rule in favor of the plaintiff. Pursuant to Article 638 of the Turkish Civil Code, if the action is upheld, the estate or the asset included in the estate is transferred to the plaintiff in accordance with the provisions concerning possession.

The plaintiff may also request that necessary measures be taken to protect their rights during the proceedings. The law allows measures such as requiring the defendant to provide security or entering an annotation in the land registry in this context.

Is There a Statute of Limitations for an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

Yes. According to Article 639 of the Turkish Civil Code, an action against a good-faith defendant is subject to a one-year limitation period starting from the date on which the plaintiff learns that they are an heir and that the defendant possesses the estate or an estate asset. In any event, the limitation period expires ten years after the death of the deceased or the opening of the will.

If the defendant is not acting in good faith, the limitation period is twenty years. Therefore, both the date of knowledge and the defendant's good-faith status should be carefully assessed before filing the action.

Which Court Hears an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

Inheritance-based actions for recovery of estate property are actions arising from inheritance law. As a general rule, the competent court is the Civil Court of First Instance. With regard to territorial jurisdiction, the deceased's last place of residence and the special jurisdiction rules applicable to the nature of the dispute must be taken into consideration.

The fact that the action concerns an immovable property, the nature of the estate, and the parties' claims may also be important in determining territorial jurisdiction. Therefore, the court with territorial jurisdiction in the specific case must be determined before filing the action. In disputes concerning immovable properties, legal assessments within the scope of real estate law may also be important.

What Evidence Is Used in an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property?

  • Inheritance certificate
  • Will or other documents establishing heirship
  • Land registry records
  • Bank and account records
  • Documents relating to sales, donations, or other transfer transactions
  • Witness statements
  • Other evidence in the form of information and documents

The evidence to be used may vary depending on the nature of the estate asset and the subject matter of the dispute. Particularly in disputes concerning immovable properties, it is important to examine land registry records and inheritance documents.

Difference Between an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property and an Ordinary Action for Recovery of Property

An inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property and an ordinary action for recovery of property are not the same type of action. While an inheritance-based action is based on the plaintiff's superior right to the inheritance, an ordinary action for recovery of property seeks the return of the property based on the right of ownership.

Inheritance-Based Recovery
Ordinary Recovery
Legal Basis
Based on the heir's superior right to the inheritance.
Subject Matter
The inheritance right concerning the estate or specific assets included in the estate.
Statute of Limitations
Under Article 639 of the Turkish Civil Code, different periods apply depending on whether the defendant is acting in good or bad faith.

Points to Consider in an Inheritance-Based Action for Recovery of Estate Property

  • The status as an heir and the superior right to the inheritance must be clearly established.
  • The fact that the asset in dispute is included in the estate should be supported by documents.
  • It should be investigated how and since when the defendant has possessed the asset.
  • The limitation periods under Article 639 of the Turkish Civil Code must be taken into consideration.
  • If an immovable property is involved, current land registry records should be examined.
  • The estate assets claimed in the statement of claim should be clearly specified.

In an inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property, the status as an heir, the estate assets, and the limitation periods must be evaluated together. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may assist in assessing the legal remedies that can be pursued during the proceedings according to the circumstances of the specific case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who can file an inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property?

A legal or appointed heir may file this action by asserting their superior right to the inheritance.

Is there a time limit for an inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property?

Yes. For a good-faith defendant, a one-year limitation period from the date of knowledge and, in any event, a ten-year limitation period apply; for a bad-faith defendant, a twenty-year limitation period applies.

Can an immovable property be recovered through an inheritance-based action for recovery of estate property?

Where the conditions are met, the transfer of an immovable property included in the estate to the plaintiff heir may be requested.

Which court hears this action?

The action is generally filed before the Civil Court of First Instance. The deceased's last place of residence and the special jurisdiction rules are taken into consideration when determining the court with territorial jurisdiction. Depending on the circumstances of the specific case, a legal assessment by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may contribute to the proper determination of jurisdiction and the applicable time limits.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…