Kasko Recourse Action in Turkey: What to Do If a Kasko Insurer Claims Back What It Paid From You

Kasko Recourse Action in Turkey: What to Do If a Kasko Insurer Claims Back What It Paid From You

Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026

A kasko recourse action is a case in which a kasko (comprehensive motor) insurer claims back the damage amount it paid to its own insured from the driver and vehicle owner who caused the accident through their fault. When kasko pays, it is subrogated to the right its own insured had against the party at fault (TTK Art. 1472). It can therefore claim from you at most what its own insured could have claimed from you.

  • Amount: The actual loss is used, not the money kasko paid. The calculation is: (actual loss − salvage) × your fault rate − the amount paid by your traffic insurance.
  • Order: Kasko first applies to the traffic insurer of the vehicle at fault. It usually comes to you for the part exceeding the traffic insurance limit (TRY 400,000 per vehicle in 2026), or if your vehicle has no insurance.
  • Court: This case is not considered a case arising from an insurance policy. If the parties are not merchants, it is heard in the civil court of first instance and no mandatory mediation is required.
  • Period: Kasko's right is subject to the same limitation period as its own insured's right. In a traffic accident, this period is as a rule 2 years from learning of the loss and the person liable, and in any case 10 years from the accident.

What Is Kasko Recourse, and Against Whom Does Kasko Have Recourse?

Kasko pays for the insured vehicle's damage regardless of fault. If someone else caused the damage, kasko is subrogated to its own insured to the extent of the amount it paid and exercises this right against those who caused the accident. This is called subrogation (TTK Art. 1472/1). The kasko insurer has no contract with you. The right it exercises is its own insured's right to compensation against you.

The kasko insurer can exercise this right against the following persons:

  • The driver at fault in the accident.
  • The vehicle's operator, usually the registered owner. The operator is liable for the driver's fault as if it were their own (Highway Traffic Law Art. 85).
  • The traffic insurer of the vehicle at fault (limited to the policy limit) and, if any, the İMM insurer attached to that vehicle's kasko policy.
  • A body that caused the accident through a road defect. The Court of Cassation accepted a kasko insurer's recourse against the municipality in an accident caused by an open manhole cover (4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/4082, K.2024/10342, 04.11.2024).

A person driving the vehicle with permission: If you had an accident while driving a friend's vehicle with their permission, your position is different. The Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, in a file from the period of the old Commercial Code, accepted that a person driving the vehicle with the policyholder's permission cannot be considered a third party. In that case, kasko cannot have recourse against that person (ACC, E.2021/235, K.2022/1634, 01.12.2022).

Those who drive the vehicle without permission, for example a garage employee who uses a vehicle left for repair for their own purposes, cannot benefit from this protection. For new policies, the outcome must be assessed together with the relevant provisions of the policy and the general conditions.

How Much Can the Kasko Insurer Claim From You?

The kasko insurer can claim from you not the amount it paid under its own policy, but the part of its insured's actual loss corresponding to your fault. If the kasko payment exceeds the actual loss, the difference cannot be charged to you. The Court of Cassation sets out the calculation as follows (4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/17161, K.2024/2574, 07.03.2024):

Claimable amount = (Actual loss − Salvage) × Your fault rate − Amount paid by your traffic insurance

Example from the judgment: Kasko paid its insured TRY 53,000 for a vehicle that was a total loss. The expert found the vehicle's undamaged second-hand value on the accident date to be TRY 50,000 and the value of the wreck (salvage) TRY 6,600. The other driver was 75% at fault and their traffic insurance had paid TRY 22,500.

  • After deducting salvage: 50,000 − 6,600 = TRY 43,400
  • Share corresponding to fault: 43,400 × 75% = TRY 32,550
  • After deducting the traffic insurance payment: 32,550 − 22,500 = TRY 10,050

Although kasko paid TRY 53,000, the amount it can claim from the driver and vehicle owner is TRY 10,050. The first-instance court had arrived at a different amount by deducting salvage in full after applying the fault rate. The Court of Cassation reversed the judgment, stating that salvage must be deducted before the fault rate.

Three elements of the calculation may be disputed:

  • Actual loss: For a total loss vehicle, the second-hand market value on the accident date; for a repaired vehicle, the reasonable repair cost to restore it to its pre-accident condition. Kasko's garage invoice does not in itself prove this cost; an expert examination may be requested.
  • Salvage: If the value placed on the wreck is low, the amount claimed from you rises. It should be asked how much the wreck was actually sold for; how salvage is determined is explained in our article total loss vehicle.
  • Fault rate: What is called the "recourse rate" in practice is your fault rate in the accident. If you are 50% at fault, you are liable for half of the actual loss. We explained how to object to the fault rate in our article objecting to the accident report and fault rate.

Items kasko did not pay, for example diminished value and the kasko deductible, may be claimed from you separately by the vehicle owner (TTK Art. 1472/2). However, all claims together cannot exceed the actual loss.

What Happens When the Traffic Insurance Limit Is Exceeded?

In an accident in which you are at fault, the other vehicle's damage is first paid by your traffic insurance. For policies starting in 2026, the property damage limit is TRY 400,000 per vehicle and TRY 800,000 per accident. If the damage exceeds this limit, you and the vehicle's operator remain liable for the excess.

The order the kasko insurer must follow is:

  1. First, your traffic insurer. As reported by the Court of Cassation, the Kasko General Conditions that entered into force on 1 April 2013 provide that the kasko insurer should first direct its recourse claim at the insurer of the vehicle at fault (4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/23216, K.2023/1171, 06.02.2023). In that file, this objection was rejected because kasko had paid before 2013. It can be raised for later payments.
  2. Your İMM cover, if any. If your own vehicle's kasko policy includes voluntary excess liability (İMM) cover, this cover steps in once the traffic insurance limit is exhausted. The Court of Cassation sets out this sequential liability expressly in its judgments (4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7521, K.2025/14512, 22.10.2025).
  3. Finally, you. The part not covered by either cover is claimed from you and the vehicle's operator.

The answer to the question "does kasko cover the other party's damage?" also lies here: your kasko covers the other party's damage only if your policy includes İMM cover, and to the extent of its limit. As soon as a recourse claim arrives, notify your traffic insurer and, if any, your İMM insurer in writing.

If your vehicle has no traffic insurance, the Motor Guarantee Fund does not pay the other vehicle's damage and the kasko insurer comes directly to you. We explained the other consequences awaiting an uninsured driver in our article Motor Guarantee Fund application.

Defences in a Kasko Recourse Action

Since the kasko insurer is subrogated to its insured, you can raise against kasko every defence you could raise against the insured. The first points to look at in the file are:

  1. Fault. If you are not at fault, there is no recourse. If your fault is less, the claim falls accordingly. The accident report, the reports in the criminal file and the expert report in the case should be examined together.
  2. Amount. The claim must match the calculation above: actual loss, salvage, fault rate and the traffic insurance payment. An amount kasko overpaid under its policy cannot be charged to you.
  3. Order. Kasko must first apply to your traffic insurer and, if any, your İMM insurer. It should be requested that these insurers join the case or that the case be notified to them.
  4. Use with permission. If you were driving the vehicle with the insured's permission, you may not be considered a third party (ACC, E.2021/235, K.2022/1634).
  5. Payment to the injured party. If you paid the other vehicle's owner directly after the accident, this payment must be deducted from the claim. Keep the receipt and any release.
  6. Standing as defendant. If the vehicle had been sold or stolen on the accident date, the vehicle owner's status as operator may be disputed. The liability of the driver and of the operator is assessed separately.
  7. Limitation. If the periods described in the next section have expired, the case is dismissed. However, this defence must be raised in time.
  8. Interest. In a judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation, interest ran from kasko's payment date as regards the driver and operator, and from the date of the case as regards the insurers (4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7552, K.2025/4515, 18.03.2025). The type and start of interest should be checked separately.

If you completed the accident report by agreement with the other party, how binding the admission of fault in the report is later is explained in our article objecting to the accident report and fault rate.

Limitation Period for Kasko Recourse

According to the settled view of the Court of Cassation, a kasko insurer's action based on subrogation is subject to the same limitation period as the action the insured would bring against the same person, and the period starts on the same date (the 17th Civil Chamber view reported in 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/10306, K.2023/14313, 28.12.2023). In a traffic accident, the insured's right is governed by Article 109 of the Highway Traffic Law:

  • 2 years from learning of the loss and the person liable, and in any case 10 years from the accident.
  • If the event constitutes an offence and criminal law provides a longer limitation period, that period applies. This arises mostly in injury accidents; in an accident with property damage only, the 2-year period applies as a rule.

In practice, the period as a rule starts on the accident date. Even if kasko pays months later, the period does not start again for that reason.

However, practice is not uniform. In a file concerning an injury accident, the Court of Cassation first applied the criminal limitation period. In its latest 2025 judgment, however, relying on the 2-year period starting from the payment date provided for recourse among persons liable to pay compensation (Highway Traffic Law Art. 109/4), it accepted that the case was filed in time (4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7552, K.2025/4515, 18.03.2025). For this reason, the accident date, the payment date and the date of the case or enforcement proceedings must be calculated together.

The timing of the defence is at least as important as the period itself. The Court of Cassation did not hear a limitation defence raised after the two-week response period had expired (4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/4082, K.2024/10342, 04.11.2024). The court does not take limitation into account of its own motion; it must be written in the first response.

Competent Court, Venue and Mediation in a Kasko Recourse Action

Competent court: According to the Court of Cassation Grand Chamber's unification of jurisprudence decision of 22.03.1944, a case brought by an insurer against the person liable is not a case arising from an insurance policy. A subrogation action is therefore not automatically a commercial case; it is treated like the case the insured would bring against the person liable. The Court of Cassation still applies this principle today (4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/14877, K.2024/1856, 21.02.2024).

  • If neither kasko's insured nor you are merchants and the event is a tort, the case is heard in the civil court of first instance.
  • If both the insured and you are merchants and the accident relates to your commercial enterprise, the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction (17th Civil Chamber judgment reported in 4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/26674, K.2024/3181, 28.03.2024).

Mediation: In a monetary claim to be heard in the commercial court of first instance, applying to a mediator before filing the case is a precondition (TTK Art. 5/A). For a tort case to be heard in the civil court of first instance, however, mandatory mediation is not provided for. This is an important difference from the recourse action a traffic insurer brings against its own insured.

Venue: The venue rules in the case the insured would bring apply:

  • The defendant's place of residence (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 6).
  • The place where the accident occurred, where the harm arose or the injured party's place of residence (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 16).
  • If the traffic insurer is also a defendant, the place of the insurer's branch or of the agent that issued the policy (Highway Traffic Law Art. 110).

If the kasko insurer started the case or the enforcement proceedings in a place that is not one of these, for example only where its own head office is located, an objection to venue arises. In a lawsuit, this objection must be made in the statement of defence, indicating the competent court (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 19). Which Istanbul district is attached to which courthouse is in the table in our article traffic insurance recourse action.

If a Formal Notice or Enforcement Proceedings Arrive

Kasko insurers usually claim the recourse receivable first by formal notice, then by enforcement proceedings without judgment. If no objection is made to the payment order within 7 days of service, the proceedings become final (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 62). An objection stops the proceedings and the kasko insurer has to file an action for annulment of the objection. All the defences above can be raised in that case.

Before paying, ask for the following:

  • The claim file, the loss adjuster's report and proof of the payment kasko made to its insured.
  • To whom and for how much the salvage was sold.
  • The basis of the fault rate: the report, the criminal file or an expert report.
  • The amount collected from your traffic insurer and, if any, your İMM insurer.

A response acknowledging the debt, or a part payment, interrupts the limitation period (Code of Obligations Art. 154). We explained in detail in our article traffic insurance recourse action the points to watch in responding to a formal notice, objecting to enforcement and making a payment or instalment agreement; these steps are the same for a kasko insurer's claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does kasko have recourse?

Yes. Kasko can claim the damage it paid to its insured from the driver at fault in the accident, the vehicle owner and their insurers. If you are the party not at fault in the accident, your own kasko does not have recourse against you.

Does the kasko insurer collect money from the other party?

Yes. It claims first from the other vehicle's traffic insurance, then, if the limit is not enough, from any İMM insurance, and the remainder from the driver and the vehicle owner.

What are the conditions for kasko recourse?

Kasko must have made a valid insurance payment to its insured. It is also required that someone else caused the harm through fault, that the insured has a right to compensation against that person and that the limitation period has not expired. Kasko's right is limited to the amount it paid and to the insured's right (TTK Art. 1472).

If I have no traffic insurance, how much can kasko claim from me?

It can claim the whole part of the other vehicle's actual loss corresponding to your fault, since there is no traffic insurance payment to deduct. The Motor Guarantee Fund does not cover vehicle damage either.

I had an accident and the other party is asking me for money; what should I do?

First notify your own traffic insurer; the other party's vehicle damage and diminished value are paid by your traffic insurance within the policy limit. If you will pay directly, base the amount on documents and obtain a receipt and a release; otherwise a new claim may arrive for the same damage. Damage exceeding the limit and items such as loss of use compensation and the kasko deductible, however, may be claimed from you; if the other party's kasko has paid, a recourse claim will arrive under the rules described in this article.

Legal Basis and Judgments

Legislation

  • Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 Arts. 4, 5/A, 1472
  • Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 Arts. 85, 109, 110
  • Code of Civil Procedure Arts. 6, 16, 19; Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 62; Turkish Code of Obligations Art. 154
  • General Conditions of Land Vehicle Kasko Insurance (in force 01.04.2013), B.4.4.3
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7521, K.2025/14512, 22.10.2025: Sequential liability between traffic insurance and İMM.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7552, K.2025/4515, 18.03.2025: Limitation in kasko recourse (Highway Traffic Law Art. 109) and the start of interest.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/4082, K.2024/10342, 04.11.2024: Deduction of salvage, a limitation defence not raised in time, recourse against a municipality.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/26674, K.2024/3181, 28.03.2024: Jurisdiction of the commercial court in a tort between merchants (17th Civil Chamber judgment reported).
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/17161, K.2024/2574, 07.03.2024: The order of deducting actual loss, salvage, fault rate and the traffic insurance payment.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/14877, K.2024/1856, 21.02.2024: A subrogation action is not a commercial case (citing the unification of jurisprudence decision of 22.03.1944, E.37, K.9).
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/10306, K.2023/14313, 28.12.2023: The subrogated insurer's limitation period depends on the insured's.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/23216, K.2023/1171, 06.02.2023: Under the 2013 Kasko General Conditions, the recourse claim is first directed at the insurer.
  • Court of Cassation ACC, E.2021/235, K.2022/1634, 01.12.2022: Recourse against a person driving the vehicle with the policyholder's permission.

If you have received a formal notice, an enforcement payment order or a statement of claim from a kasko insurer, have the amount, the order and the time limits checked before paying or giving a response acknowledging the debt. In these files, we provide legal support on the driver's and vehicle owner's side as a traffic accident compensation lawyer.

About the Author

Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer in Istanbul who runs his own law office and practises in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He is a graduate of Marmara University Faculty of Law. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.

This article is for general information purposes. The amount and outcome of a kasko recourse claim are assessed separately according to the specific features of the accident and the file.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…