Deemed Rejection of Inheritance in Turkey

Deemed Rejection of Inheritance in Turkey

An action for deemed rejection seeks a determination that an inheritance is regarded as renounced by operation of law because the estate was clearly insolvent when the deceased died. Under Article 605/2 of the Turkish Civil Code, the inheritance is deemed rejected if the deceased’s inability to pay was clearly apparent or officially established at death. The applicable inheritance-law rules must be assessed carefully.

This remedy differs from an heir’s unconditional declaration of renunciation before the civil court of peace within the ordinary period. Here, the heir alleges that the estate was insolvent at death and asks the court for a declaratory judgment. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assess the estate’s assets and liabilities and identify the appropriate procedural route.

When Is an Inheritance Deemed Renounced?

The central condition is that the estate was clearly insolvent on the date of death. Insolvency may arise where the total value of the assets is lower than the total liabilities.

The assessment is made as of the date of death. Later economic developments are not decisive on their own. The court examines the assets and liabilities existing on that date.

Assets and Liabilities Are Investigated

Assets may include real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, receivables, and other property. Liabilities may include loans, enforcement debts, taxes, and other legal obligations.

If insolvency is not immediately clear, the court may request records from land registries, vehicle registries, banks, tax authorities, and other institutions.

Does the Three-Month Period Apply?

An action under Article 605/2 is not subject to the ordinary three-month renunciation period in Article 606. Court of Cassation practice likewise accepts that a claim based on deemed rejection is not time-barred by that period.

This does not mean that an heir may freely deal with estate property. Conduct that may amount to acceptance under Article 610 must be evaluated in light of the facts.

Can Deemed Rejection Be Claimed After Acceptance?

The court examines not only insolvency but also whether the heir performed acts amounting to acceptance. Taking possession of estate assets or exceeding ordinary administration may affect the result.

Before seeking deemed rejection, the legal consequences of every transaction involving the estate should therefore be reviewed.

How Is the Action Filed?

The claim asks the court to determine that the estate was insolvent on the date of death and is therefore deemed rejected. The petition should identify the deceased, the date of death, the heirship relationship, known liabilities, and known assets.

  1. Identify the date of death and the heirs.
  2. Investigate assets existing on the date of death.
  3. Identify debts and enforcement proceedings.
  4. Demonstrate that liabilities exceeded assets at death.
  5. Bring the action against the relevant creditors.
  6. Request judicial investigation of the estate’s assets and liabilities.

Which Court Has Subject-Matter Jurisdiction?

These actions are heard by the Civil Court of First Instance. Current Court of Cassation decisions also treat Article 605/2 disputes as matters for that court.

This is different from an ordinary unconditional renunciation filed before the civil court of peace. Correct classification of the claim is therefore important.

Which Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?

Territorial jurisdiction depends on the facts. Established Court of Cassation practice generally recognizes the court at the creditors’ residences on the filing date as competent for Article 605/2 actions.

The creditors, the nature of the liabilities, and the parties must be examined before selecting the court.

Against Whom Is the Action Filed?

The action may be directed against creditors asserting claims against the heir based on estate debts. The petition must identify the relevant creditors and explain why the inheritance should be deemed rejected.

Where there are several creditors, each creditor’s relationship with the estate and whether that creditor must be joined should be assessed separately.

What Documents Are Required?

The evidence should establish the assets and liabilities as of death. Relevant documents may include:

  • Death certificate or civil-registry record
  • Certificate of inheritance
  • Land-registry and vehicle records
  • Bank-account and loan records
  • Enforcement files and payment orders
  • Tax-debt records
  • Documents showing other liabilities
  • An insolvency certificate or similar official record, if available

An heir may not be able to obtain every document in advance. The court may request records from the relevant institutions. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assist in identifying and presenting estate, debt, and enforcement documents.

Does an Insolvency Certificate Prove the Claim?

An insolvency certificate issued after enforcement may be important evidence, but the court may still evaluate the estate’s complete financial position. Rules of enforcement and bankruptcy law may also be relevant.

The absence of such a certificate does not by itself prove solvency. The court may examine all assets and debts existing at death.

What Does the Court Investigate?

The court determines the assets and liabilities at death and considers whether the heirs acted in a manner amounting to acceptance.

Land, banking, vehicle, tax, and other institutional records may be examined. Clear proof of insolvency is a central element of the claim.

How Long Does the Case Take?

Duration depends on the scope of the investigation, number of creditors, evidence, institutional correspondence, and the court’s workload.

Numerous assets or liabilities may lengthen the proceedings, so no fixed duration can be guaranteed. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assess the likely procedural scope by considering the creditors and records involved.

Deemed Rejection and Ordinary Renunciation Compared

Criterion
Deemed Rejection
Ordinary Renunciation
Basis
Clear insolvency at death under Article 605/2
The heir declares that the inheritance is not accepted under Article 605/1
Time limit
Not subject to the ordinary three-month period
Generally subject to a three-month forfeiture period
Procedure
Determined through contentious proceedings
Declared orally or in writing before the civil court of peace

Important Points

  • Insolvency is assessed as of the date of death.
  • Deemed and ordinary renunciation must be distinguished.
  • The ordinary three-month period does not govern deemed rejection.
  • Acts that may amount to acceptance must be examined.
  • Assets and liabilities should be documented as fully as possible.
  • The correct creditors must be named.
  • Subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction should be confirmed before filing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Must the action be filed within three months?

No. An Article 605/2 action based on insolvency is not subject to the ordinary three-month period, although acts amounting to acceptance remain important.

Do the deceased’s debts pass to the heir?

If the court determines that the statutory conditions existed, the inheritance is deemed rejected for that heir. Insolvency at death and the other conditions must be proved.

Can a creditor file the action?

The action principally arises when an heir seeks a declaration that the estate was deemed rejected. A creditor’s rights following renunciation require separate assessment.

Which court hears the action?

The Civil Court of First Instance hears it. Territorial jurisdiction depends particularly on the creditors’ residences and the parties. Depending on the dispute, mediation may also require consideration.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…