Negative Declaratory Actions in Turkey

Negative Declaratory Actions in Turkey

An action for negative declaratory relief is a lawsuit filed to have the court determine that a person is not indebted when a debt is claimed from them or enforcement proceedings are initiated against them despite the fact that they are not actually indebted. This action, regulated under Article 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, may be filed before or during enforcement proceedings and, in certain circumstances, even after the enforcement proceeding has become final.

The primary purpose of an action for negative declaratory relief is to establish by a court decision that the debt relationship asserted by the creditor does not exist. Whether the action is filed before or after the enforcement proceeding may lead to different consequences in terms of interim measures and their effect on the enforcement file. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun states that, in such disputes, the enforcement file and the underlying debt relationship should be evaluated together.

What Is an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

An action for negative declaratory relief is a lawsuit filed to establish that a debt relationship asserted by the defendant does not exist. A person who does not accept that they are indebted may assert before the court that the debt claimed by the creditor does not exist.

The action is not limited to persons against whom enforcement proceedings have already been initiated. Even if enforcement proceedings have not yet begun, an action for negative declaratory relief may be filed if the person has a legal interest in having it established that they are not indebted.

In What Situations Can an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Be Filed?

An action for negative declaratory relief may arise in situations such as a non-existent debt being claimed, payment being demanded again for a debt that has already been paid, or the debt relationship being invalid.

  • The debt never having arisen,
  • The debt having previously been paid,
  • The debt having been extinguished through a release or for another reason,
  • The person against whom the debt is claimed in the enforcement proceeding not being the actual debtor,
  • The promissory note or contract being invalid,
  • The amount of debt claimed in the enforcement proceeding not actually existing,
  • The signature on the promissory note not belonging to the person.

Depending on the circumstances of the specific case, other legal grounds may also constitute the subject matter of an action for negative declaratory relief.

Can an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Be Filed Before Enforcement Proceedings?

Yes. Under Article 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, the debtor may seek a determination that they are not indebted before enforcement proceedings are initiated. However, merely having the possibility that enforcement proceedings may be initiated in the future may not be sufficient to file the action; the person must have a legally protectable interest in having it established that they are not indebted.

In an action for negative declaratory relief filed before enforcement proceedings, the court may, if the statutory conditions are met and upon provision of security, issue an interim measure ordering the suspension of the enforcement proceeding.

Can an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Be Filed After Enforcement Proceedings?

An action for negative declaratory relief may also be filed after enforcement proceedings have begun. Even if an objection to the payment order has not been filed and the enforcement proceeding has become final, a person who asserts that they are not indebted under substantive law may still file an action for negative declaratory relief.

However, a different regulation applies to interim measures in an action for negative declaratory relief filed after enforcement proceedings have begun. An interim measure completely suspending the enforcement proceeding cannot be granted; however, if the statutory conditions are met, an interim measure may be requested to prevent the money held in the enforcement office's account from being paid to the creditor.

Can an Interim Measure Be Obtained in an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

An interim measure in an action for negative declaratory relief is particularly important in limiting the consequences that an ongoing enforcement proceeding may produce. However, the scope of the measure differs depending on whether the action is filed before or after the enforcement proceeding.

In an action filed before enforcement proceedings, suspension of the proceeding may be requested upon provision of the security prescribed by law. In an action filed after enforcement proceedings have begun, the proceeding cannot be suspended; however, under certain conditions, it may be requested that the money held in the enforcement office's account not be paid to the creditor.

Which Court Has Jurisdiction Over an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

The court with subject-matter jurisdiction over an action for negative declaratory relief is determined according to the nature of the underlying debt relationship. As a general rule, the Civil Court of First Instance has general jurisdiction. However, if the dispute constitutes a commercial lawsuit, the Commercial Court of First Instance may have jurisdiction.

In disputes arising from a lease relationship or debt relationships falling within the jurisdiction of a special court, the competent court may be different. Therefore, the legal nature of the underlying debt relationship must be determined before filing the action. It is important to evaluate enforcement proceedings and disputes arising from such proceedings within the scope of enforcement and bankruptcy law.

Where Is an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Filed?

Under Article 72 of the EBL, an action for negative declaratory relief may be filed before the court at the place where the enforcement office conducting the proceeding is located or before the court at the place where the defendant creditor resides. However, special jurisdiction rules and different jurisdiction provisions arising from the nature of the dispute must also be taken into consideration.

If there is an ongoing enforcement file, it is important to accurately determine which enforcement office holds the file and the place of residence of the creditor.

What Must the Debtor Prove in an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

Which party must prove which matter in an action for negative declaratory relief is determined according to the nature of the debt relationship and the characteristics of the allegation made. The plaintiff must submit to the court the facts establishing that they are not indebted and the evidence supporting those facts.

Bank receipts, contracts, receipts, releases, correspondence, commercial records, and promissory notes may be used as evidence depending on the circumstances of the specific case. If the signature on a promissory note is denied, a signature examination may also become necessary.

How Is an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Filed?

An action for negative declaratory relief is filed by submitting a statement of claim to the court with subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction. The statement of claim must clearly specify which debt does not exist, the enforcement file number if applicable, the creditor's allegation, and the legal and factual grounds demonstrating that the plaintiff is not indebted.

If enforcement proceedings are ongoing, the payment order, documents contained in the enforcement file, and documents relating to attachment procedures must also be examined. If an interim measure is requested together with the action, the reasons why the measure is necessary must also be explained.

Is There a Time Limit for Filing an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

There is no single general filing period applicable to every action for negative declaratory relief. However, limitation periods applicable to the underlying debt relationship, periods relating to promissory notes, and other special regulations may be important depending on the circumstances of the specific case.

Since short-term legal remedies such as objecting to a payment order may also be available while enforcement proceedings are ongoing, the possibility of filing an action for negative declaratory relief does not mean that these periods can be disregarded.

What Happens If an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief Is Won?

If the court rules that the plaintiff is not liable for the debt subject to the enforcement proceeding, the action for negative declaratory relief is accepted. Once the decision becomes final, it is established under substantive law that the receivable subject to the enforcement proceeding does not exist.

Where enforcement proceedings are ongoing, the necessary procedures are carried out in the enforcement file after the decision becomes final. Restoration of the enforcement proceeding in whole or in part may also come into question as provided by law.

What Happens If the Debt Is Paid During an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief?

If the debt is paid under the threat of enforcement while an action for negative declaratory relief is pending, the action may continue as a restitution action in order to recover the money paid despite the absence of the debt.

Therefore, once payment has been made, the subject matter of the action becomes not only the determination that the person is not indebted but also the recovery of the money paid.

Bad-Faith Compensation in an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief

The fact that an action for negative declaratory relief is concluded in favor of the debtor is not by itself sufficient for an award of compensation. Under Article 72 of the EBL, it must be established that the enforcement proceeding initiated by the creditor was unjustified and conducted in bad faith, and the debtor must also request compensation.

If these conditions are met, the court may order the creditor to compensate the loss suffered by the debtor due to the lawsuit. The compensation prescribed by law cannot be less than twenty percent of the receivable subject to the enforcement proceeding determined to be unjustified. Compensation claims may also be separately assessed within the scope of compensation law.

Difference Between an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief and a Restitution Action

The primary purpose of an action for negative declaratory relief is to establish that the person is not indebted. In a restitution action, however, the person who made a payment as a result of enforcement proceedings despite not being indebted seeks the return of the money paid.

Therefore, if no payment has yet been made during enforcement proceedings, an action for negative declaratory relief may be relevant; if payment has been made, the provisions governing restitution may become applicable depending on the circumstances of the specific case.

Evidence That May Be Used in an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief

  • The enforcement file and payment order,
  • Bank receipts and account statements,
  • Contracts and protocols,
  • Releases and receipts,
  • Promissory notes and other written documents,
  • Correspondence between the parties,
  • Commercial books and records,
  • Expert examination and other legally admissible evidence depending on the nature of the specific case.

Clearly establishing which fact each piece of evidence is intended to prove is important for the proper conduct of the proceedings.

Points to Consider in an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief

Persons against whom enforcement proceedings have been initiated should first check the date on which the payment order was served, the type of enforcement proceeding, the basis of the debt, and the existing procedures in the file. Filing an action for negative declaratory relief does not automatically eliminate other statutory periods for legal remedies, such as the period for objecting to the payment order.

In addition, before filing the action, the court with subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction must be correctly determined, documents demonstrating the absence of the debt must be collected, and if an interim measure is to be requested, the statutory requirements must be assessed. Depending on the nature of the dispute, it should also be checked whether mandatory mediation as a prerequisite for litigation applies before filing the action. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun emphasizes that, when preparing the action, it is particularly important to examine the documents in the enforcement file and the applicable filing periods together.

Key Features of an Action for Negative Declaratory Relief

Subject
Explanation
Purpose of the Action
Having the court determine that the plaintiff is not liable for the debt subject to the enforcement proceeding.
Timing of the Action
It may be filed before or during the enforcement proceeding; even if the proceeding has become final, the action may still be filed if the required conditions are met.
Interim Measure
Before enforcement proceedings, suspension of the proceeding may be requested under certain conditions; after enforcement proceedings have begun, it may be requested under certain conditions that the money held in the enforcement office's account not be paid to the creditor.
Competent Court
Depending on the nature of the debt relationship, it may be the Civil Court of First Instance, Commercial Court of First Instance, or another court with special jurisdiction.
If Payment Is Made
If the debt was paid under the threat of enforcement, the action may, if the conditions are met, continue as a restitution action.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is an action for negative declaratory relief filed?

It is filed to have the court determine that a person who is not actually indebted is not liable for the debt asserted or made the subject of enforcement proceedings.

Can an action for negative declaratory relief be filed before enforcement proceedings?

Yes. An action for negative declaratory relief may also be filed before enforcement proceedings if there is a legal interest in doing so.

Can an action for negative declaratory relief be filed after enforcement proceedings have become final?

Yes. The fact that the enforcement proceeding has become final does not prevent a person who asserts that they are not indebted under substantive law from filing an action for negative declaratory relief if the required conditions are met.

Can compensation be awarded in an action for negative declaratory relief?

If the enforcement proceeding is determined to be unjustified and conducted in bad faith and the debtor requests compensation, compensation may be awarded under Article 72 of the EBL.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…