Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026
How you object to a fault rate depends on who drew up the accident report. In an agreed report completed by the parties themselves, the objection is made to your own insurer, only once, within 5 business days from the date the fault rate was notified by SMS or e-mail; if both vehicles are insured with the same company, you apply to the SBM Report Assessment Commission. A police or gendarmerie report, by contrast, cannot be annulled on its own; fault is challenged by requesting an expert examination in a compensation lawsuit, at the Insurance Arbitration Commission or in the criminal file.
Where and how to find out your fault rate is explained in our article checking your fault rate and accident report. This article focuses on the objection itself: where, within what time, with which documents, and what happens if the deadline is missed.
Agreed report: 5 business days from notification, to your own insurer, once only.
If both vehicles are with the same company: The objection is made to the SBM Report Assessment Commission.
Police or gendarmerie report: There is no separate objection authority; fault is redetermined by an expert in the main dispute.
If a traffic fine was also issued: An application against the fine is made to the criminal judgeship of peace within 15 days of service.
If the deadline was missed: According to the Court of Cassation, arbitration and the courts are not bound by the report; fault is investigated again.
The authority and time limit for the objection differ in four situations. First find your own situation in this table.
| Situation | Where | Time limit | When the time limit starts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agreed report, vehicles with different insurers | Your own traffic insurer, in writing and with supporting documents | 5 business days | The date the fault rate was notified by SMS or e-mail |
| Agreed report, both vehicles with the same insurer | SBM Report Assessment Commission (via SBM's report inquiry screen) | 5 business days | The date the fault rate was notified |
| Police or gendarmerie report | No separate objection authority; an expert examination is requested in the compensation lawsuit, at the Insurance Arbitration Commission or in the criminal file | 2 weeks against the expert report in a civil case | Service of the report on you |
| A traffic fine was issued together with the report | Criminal judgeship of peace (against the fine only) | 15 days | Service or pronouncement of the fine |
For an agreed report, the company reassesses your objection within 3 business days. If the result does not change at this stage either, the dispute is taken to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court; a comparison of these routes is on our compensation claim against an insurance company page.
Since the right to object can be used only once, an objection made with incomplete documents uses up this right. So even though the time limit is short, the objection must be prepared in full.
Record the notification date. Take a screenshot of the SMS or e-mail notifying the fault rate. The 5 business days start to run after this date.
Determine the authority. If the other vehicle's traffic insurance is with a different company, you apply to your own company; if it is with the same company, to the SBM Report Assessment Commission.
Write the reason in one sentence. State clearly how the accident happened and which rule the other party failed to follow; mention any box incorrectly ticked in the report. You can check which rate should be given for your type of accident in our article fault rates in traffic accidents.
Attach evidence. The strongest evidence in these objections is usually dashcam footage, photographs showing the points of impact and images showing the position of the vehicles after the accident. If there is a witness not named in the report, attach their written statement and contact details.
Send it in writing in a way that proves the date. Since the day the application was made may later be disputed, use registered e-mail, the company's application screen or a receipt obtained from the agent.
Follow up the result. The company reassesses within 3 business days. Check the new result via SBM or e-Devlet.
An objection made to the wrong authority also stops the time limit. Still, applying to the correct authority speeds up the assessment.
To the Claims Department of [Name of the Insurer]
Subject: Objection to the fault rate determined in claim file no. [claim file number]
In the accident that occurred on [dd.mm.yyyy] in [district/Istanbul], for which an accident report was drawn up by the parties, my fault rate was determined as [..]% according to the assessment notified by SMS on [dd.mm.yyyy]. The accident occurred when the vehicle with plate [plate] hit my vehicle [while changing lanes / without observing the right of way at the junction]. This is established by the attached [dashcam footage, photographs showing the points of impact, witness statement]. Situation no. [..] in the report was ticked incorrectly.
I request that my fault rate be redetermined as [..]%.
Attachments: 1) [ ] 2) [ ] 3) [ ]
Name Surname · Turkish ID No · Telephone · E-mail · Signature
An accident report drawn up by law enforcement is not an administrative sanction but a record of the event. Therefore, no separate lawsuit is filed for the annulment of the report itself; fault is challenged in the file in which the report is used as evidence.
Court of Cassation 19th Criminal Chamber, E.2018/4357, K.2019/9639, 18.06.2019: It stated that an accident report is not in the nature of an administrative sanction or measure, but merely a record of the situation.
Court of Cassation 19th Criminal Chamber, E.2020/3135, K.2021/6717, 16.06.2021: It accepted that annulment of the report cannot be requested from the criminal judgeship of peace and that its content is to be assessed by the court resolving the main dispute.
In practice, the objection is made in one of three places:
In the criminal investigation: In accidents involving injury or death, an expert examination on fault is requested by a petition to the prosecutor, and comments are submitted on the resulting report.
In the compensation lawsuit: The court has fault examined by an expert. An objection to the report is made within 2 weeks of its service (Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 281).
At the Insurance Arbitration Commission: The arbitrator may order an expert examination on technical issues, including fault.
If expert reports contradict each other, a report may be requested from a specialist institution. The Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber (E.2023/10361, K.2024/138, 09.01.2024) requires that in this case the file be sent to university traffic departments, the Traffic Technical Board of the General Directorate of Highways or the Traffic Specialisation Department of the Forensic Medicine Institute.
If an administrative fine was also issued with the report, a separate time limit runs: an application against the fine is made to the criminal judgeship of peace within 15 days of service or pronouncement (Law on Misdemeanours, Art. 27). This application concerns only the fine, not the fault rate.
Missing the deadline does not end the dispute over fault; it only closes the fast objection route at the insurer stage. Arbitration and the courts are not bound by the rate determined by the companies or the commission.
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/3198, K.2025/3360, 27.02.2025: It held that relying on the fault finding in the report without conducting a separate investigation of fault amounts to an incomplete examination.
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/2820, K.2025/15010, 04.11.2025: It stated that even if the objection period has been missed, the court must conduct its own investigation without being bound by the report.
In this case, the route is the Insurance Arbitration Commission or a lawsuit following an application to the insurer. Evidence becomes even more important here; since camera recordings can be deleted quickly, collect the evidence immediately even if the deadline has passed.
The other driver writing in an agreed report that they caused the accident is strong evidence. In a file where the other driver admitted fault by writing in the report that they had hit the claimant's vehicle from behind, the Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber reversed an arbitration award rejecting the claim on the ground that the damage did not match the accident described. The Chamber stated that the burden of proving the contrary of the report lies with the insurer (E.2023/4136, K.2025/2904, 20.02.2025, by majority). The same weight also works against you; read carefully any statement admitting fault before you sign it.
The day the notification arrives is not counted; weekends and public holidays are not business days either. For example, if the fault rate was notified on a Monday and there is no holiday in between, the last day is the Monday of the following week. Objecting without waiting for the last day also avoids a possible dispute about the notification date.
For an agreed report, the objection is made to your own insurer, or, if both vehicles are with the same company, to the commission via SBM's report inquiry screen. The "My Private Insurance" page on e-Devlet, as announced, is intended for viewing the fault rate, the report and the loss adjuster's report.
In an agreed report, the right to object can be used once. If the result has not changed, you can take the dispute to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court; there, fault is redetermined by an expert.
The fine is a finding that a traffic rule was breached. For compensation purposes, the fault rate is determined separately through an expert examination. However, since a final fine can be used as evidence against you, do not miss the 15-day objection period if you believe it is unjustified.
Yes. Each driver involved in the accident can object through their own insurer within the same time limit. So a result in your favour may also change; keep the accident evidence until the result becomes final.
There is no court with jurisdiction over the report itself, because the report is not an act that can be annulled on its own. If a traffic fine was issued with the report, an application against the fine is made to the criminal judgeship of peace within 15 days. An objection to fault is raised before the authority hearing the main dispute, that is, the court hearing the compensation case, the Insurance Arbitration Commission or the criminal file. The court with jurisdiction in a compensation case is explained on our traffic accident compensation page.
Legislation
Circular on Accident Reports to be Completed by the Parties in Traffic Accidents Resulting Only in Property Damage (Undersecretariat of Treasury, 2017/18, 07.11.2017; in force 01.01.2018), Art. 4
Law on Misdemeanours No. 5326, Art. 27
Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Arts. 266 and 281
Insurance Information and Monitoring Centre, "Accident Report Inquiry and Objection" service description
Judgments
Court of Cassation 19th Criminal Chamber, E.2018/4357, K.2019/9639, 18.06.2019
Court of Cassation 19th Criminal Chamber, E.2020/3135, K.2021/6717, 16.06.2021
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/10361, K.2024/138, 09.01.2024
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/3198, K.2025/3360, 27.02.2025
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/2820, K.2025/15010, 04.11.2025
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/4136, K.2025/2904, 20.02.2025
Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer in Istanbul who runs his own law office and practises in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He is a graduate of Marmara University Faculty of Law. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.
This article is for general information purposes. The sample petition should be adapted to the circumstances of your own accident.