Objecting to a Loss Adjuster Report and Equivalent Parts in Turkey: What to Do If the Insurer Underpays for Damage

Objecting to a Loss Adjuster Report and Equivalent Parts in Turkey: What to Do If the Insurer Underpays for Damage

Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026

A loss adjuster's (eksper) report is not a binding decision; if the damage amount was underestimated, a written objection is first made to the company, and if that fails, you go to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court. There is no separate statutory objection period for this; the limit is set by the limitation period. In traffic insurance, since 1 July 2026, if an original part was damaged, an original part is paid for; an equivalent part may be used only with the vehicle owner's consent or if the original part cannot be found.

  • Where to get the report: The claim file and the adjuster's report can be viewed via the "My Private Insurance" service on e-Devlet; they can also be requested from the company in writing.
  • Objection: There is no objection button on e-Devlet. The objection is made to the insurer in writing; arbitration or a lawsuit follows.
  • Parts in traffic insurance: An original part is replaced with an original. The burden of proving that the part was not original, or that an equivalent exists, lies with the insurer.
  • Parts and garage in kasko: The clause written in the policy applies; if the policy says nothing, the garage and parts you choose apply.
  • Discount: A discount agreed between the insurer and a contracted garage does not bind you unless the policy provides for it.
  • Release: If you accept the payment without stating "my rights to any excess are reserved", a claim for the difference may be rejected in kasko.

What Is a Loss Adjuster's Report, How Is It Checked, and How Long Does It Take?

A loss adjuster's report is the document in which a licensed insurance loss adjuster examines the vehicle and determines the damage, the parts to be replaced and repaired, and the labour and paint items. The insurer makes payment on the basis of this report.

  • Who appoints the adjuster: Since 1 August 2026, adjusters for traffic insurance and kasko damage have been appointed through a "smart" appointment system developed by SEDDK and based on SBM records; in partial damage cases, adjusters are appointed in rotation. SEDDK Circular No. 2026/11 also accepts that, besides the insurer, the adjuster may be appointed by the insured or a person benefiting from the contract.
  • How to check the report: The claim file and the adjuster's report can be viewed via the "My Private Insurance" service on e-Devlet. Also request a full copy of the report from the company in writing; the objection is made on the basis of the items in this report.
  • How long it takes: There is no definite statutory period for the adjuster's report; the time depends on the vehicle being made available for inspection and on the status of parts and documents.

The periods after the report, however, are fixed:

InsurancePayment periodBasis
Traffic insurance8 business days after the documents are completeHighway Traffic Law Art. 99
KaskoAt the latest 10 business days from delivery of the adjuster's report; compensation becomes due in any case 45 days after notification of the damageKasko General Conditions B.3.3.4.1

If the loss adjustment process is continuing for a reason not attributable to the company, no dispute is yet deemed to have arisen and an arbitration application does not proceed. We explained this rule in our article applying to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. For heavily damaged vehicles, the decision is made on different principles; this is explained in detail in our article total loss vehicle.

Objecting to the Loss Adjuster's Report: Time Limit, Where and Steps

An objection to the adjuster's report is a written application to the insurer against the items in the report. e-Devlet is for viewing the report; there is no objection option there.

Time limit for objection

There is no special statutory period for objecting to the adjuster's report; the limit is set by the limitation period (all periods are in our article traffic accident statute of limitations):

InsuranceLimitation periodBasis
The other party's traffic insurance2 years from learning of the loss and the person liable, in any case 10 years from the accidentHighway Traffic Law Art. 109
Your own kasko2 years from the date the compensation should have been paid, in any case 6 years from the accidentTTK Art. 1420

In practice, the real deadline is when the vehicle is sent for repair. Objecting before the vehicle is repaired and the old parts are discarded makes it easier to prove the damage. The document signed when accepting the payment also affects the right to object; we explain this below in the section on releases.

Where is the objection made?

  • Traffic insurance: A written application to the insurer of the other vehicle is mandatory before litigation and arbitration. If the company does not respond within 15 days or underpays, you go to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court (Highway Traffic Law Art. 97).
  • Kasko: The objection is made to your own insurer. If it fails, you can use the Insurance Arbitration Commission, the consumer arbitration committee, or court after mediation.

How is the objection made?

  1. Get a full copy of the report. A summary amount is not enough; you need the parts list and the labour and paint items.
  2. Compare item by item. Was a part that should be replaced listed for repair, was an equivalent priced instead of an original part, is the part price current, are the labour hours realistic, has a discount been deducted?
  3. Get a detailed repair quote from the garage. It should show part numbers, unit prices and labour hours.
  4. Report hidden damage. Ask the adjuster for an additional inspection of damage revealed during dismantling, and photograph it.
  5. Send a written objection. State which item is short, why and by how much, and attach the quote and photographs. KEP, a notary or the company's written application channel provide proof of date.
  6. Keep the replaced parts and the invoices. If the dispute goes to arbitration or court, the expert will look at them.

What Is an Equivalent Part? Who Pays the Original Part Difference in Traffic Insurance?

An equivalent part is a spare part that is not original but whose quality equal to the original part is certified by an authorised body. A non-OEM aftermarket part without such certification is not an equivalent part. Since equivalent parts are usually cheaper than originals, insurers want to calculate the damage at that price.

Which part the other vehicle's traffic insurance will pay for, under the amendment to the General Conditions that entered into force on 1 July 2026, is as follows:

Damaged partWhat does the insurance pay?
Original and cannot be repairedAn original part. An equivalent or reusable part is used only with the vehicle owner's consent or if the original part cannot be found.
Not original and cannot be repairedFirst an equivalent or reusable part; if these are not possible, an original part
Not original, but an original was fitted in its placeIf an equivalent part is possible, the insurance pays only the price of the equivalent part

Two rules complete this table in the insured's favour. The burden of proving that the part was not original, or that an equivalent exists, lies with the insurer. Even if the repair increases the vehicle's value, this difference cannot be deducted from the compensation. Which text applies is determined by the date the policy was issued; the previous text, in force since 2021, also provided for an original part to be replaced with an original.

What do the courts say?

The Council of State found unlawful a regulation giving priority to replacing an original part in the other party's vehicle with an equivalent part without the owner's consent, since it restricted the right of property without a legal basis (8th Chamber, E.2020/3735, K.2022/6787, 23.11.2022). The Court of Cassation also accepted that if the insurer cannot prove that the parts were not original or that an equivalent exists, the price of the original part must be paid (4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/4296, K.2025/2543, 17.02.2025).

From whom is equivalent part compensation claimed?

If the insurer calculated the original part at the equivalent price, the difference is claimed from the other vehicle's traffic insurance in proportion to the other driver's fault. If the difference exceeds the policy's property damage limit per vehicle, the excess is claimed from the other party's voluntary excess liability insurance, if any, and from the driver who caused the accident and the vehicle's operator (Highway Traffic Law Art. 85). To object to the other party's fault rate, see our article objecting to the accident report and fault rate.

Equivalent Parts, Contracted Garages and Authorised Dealers in Kasko

In kasko, the policy determines which parts and which garage will be used. Under the Kasko General Conditions, the policy must state clearly whether the repair will be carried out at a garage designated by the company or one chosen by the insured, and whether original or equivalent parts will be used. If the policy makes no such provision, the compensation method, garage and parts chosen by the insured apply (B.3.3.2.1).

Clause in the policyWhat does it mean?
Authorised dealerRepair is carried out at the brand's authorised service centre, as a rule with original parts.
Contracted garageRepair is carried out at garages contracted by the insurer; such a garage may not be an authorised dealer.
Equivalent partsThe damage is paid at equivalent part prices; the policy premium is usually lower for this reason.
DeductibleA certain amount or percentage of the damage remains with the insured. The deductible must be written in the policy in at least 14-point type (A.6).

If you have the repair done at a non-contracted garage

If the policy has a contracted garage clause and you have the vehicle repaired at another garage, the company pays the amount determined by the adjuster and the difference may remain with you (Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/17, K.2025/132, 07.01.2025). The Court of Cassation also found justified a discounted calculation based on the claims payment, parts supply and garage clauses in the policy (4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/7530, K.2025/13873, 09.10.2025).

For this reason, the first document to look at in a kasko dispute is the policy itself. A low-premium kasko may contain contracted garage and equivalent part clauses; checking these clauses when renewing the policy prevents disputes after an accident. Cases where kasko rejects the damage entirely are covered separately in our article what to do if kasko will not pay.

Contracted Garage Discounts and VAT: The Most Common Deductions in Adjusters' Reports

Insurers agree discounts on parts and labour with contracted garages and want to deduct this discount from the damage amount. This deduction does not bind the vehicle owner unless it has a basis in the policy or the law.

  • In kasko: If there is no discount clause in the policy, the discount the company agreed with the garage does not bind the insured (Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/10705, K.2024/10720, 07.11.2024). In June 2026 the Insurance Arbitration Commission also decided, in a file where the vehicle was repaired at a garage not applying a discount, that the actual loss must be calculated without deducting the discount (K-2026/343230, 15.06.2026). If the policy has an express clause, the result may differ.
  • In traffic insurance: There is no contract between you and the other party's insurer. In a file upheld with correction by the Court of Cassation, the insurer's discount claim was rejected because the discount had not been notified to the injured party and no supply contract was submitted (4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/5401, K.2025/17415, 25.12.2025).
  • VAT: Since repairs, parts and labour are subject to VAT, the damage amount is as a rule calculated including VAT. The Court of Cassation upheld compensation calculated including VAT in traffic insurance files (4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/4081, K.2025/6485, 24.04.2025; E.2025/4726, K.2025/7862, 15.05.2025).

When examining the adjuster's report, also look separately at the discount line and whether the amounts are stated including or excluding VAT.

Independent Adjuster's Report and Damage Determination

The report of a licensed adjuster you appoint yourself does not bind the insurer, but it gives your objection a concrete basis. If the dispute goes to arbitration or court, this report can be submitted as an expert opinion (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 293); the decision, however, is determined by the examination of the expert appointed by the arbitrator or the court.

  • Cost: In kasko, the insurer pays the reasonable costs of the adjuster appointed by the insured, even if unsuccessful (Kasko General Conditions C.9). In a traffic insurance file, the Court of Cassation also upheld holding the insurer liable for the adjuster's fee (4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/4726, K.2025/7862, 15.05.2025).
  • Determination of damage: If no agreement could be reached with the insurer and the vehicle is to be repaired without waiting, you can ask for the damage to be determined by the court (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 400). The Kasko General Conditions also provide that, if the parties cannot agree, the amount of damage is determined by a preliminary expert examination carried out by the court (B.3.3.4.1).
  • Objection to the expert report: Within two weeks of service of an expert report obtained in arbitration or court, you can object and ask for a supplementary report or a new expert (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 281).

An independent adjuster's report is most useful in respect of the vehicle's condition before repair. A report obtained after the repair is finished can only assess on the basis of invoices, photographs and the replaced parts.

Releases and Settlement: Can a Difference Be Claimed After Accepting the Payment?

When making a payment, the insurer may have you sign a "release" (ibraname), "settlement agreement" or "claim payment approval form". The content of this document determines whether you can later claim a difference.

  • In traffic insurance: Annulment of a compensation agreement or payment that is clearly inadequate can be requested within two years of the agreement or payment date (Highway Traffic Law Art. 111/2). The document you signed is therefore not an absolute bar, but the period is short.
  • In kasko: The Insurance Arbitration Commission rejected a claim for the difference in a file where the insured had fully released the company without making any reservation or reserving rights to any excess (K-2026/340488, 15.06.2026).

The safest course is not to sign any document without seeing the adjuster's report. If you need to sign to receive the payment, write by hand on the document "My objection to the adjuster's report and my rights to any excess are reserved" and keep a copy.

Example: How Is the Difference in the Adjuster's Report Calculated?

Suppose the other vehicle is 75% at fault. The original front bumper and headlight of your vehicle are to be replaced. Suppose the adjuster priced both parts at equivalent prices and deducted a 10% contracted garage discount from the total. All amounts include VAT and are hypothetical.

ItemAdjuster's reportCorrect calculation
Front bumperTRY 9,000 (equivalent)TRY 18,000 (original)
HeadlightTRY 12,000 (equivalent)TRY 26,000 (original)
Labour and paintTRY 15,000TRY 15,000
SubtotalTRY 36,000TRY 59,000
Discount10% deducted: TRY 32,400Not deducted: TRY 59,000
Other party's fault (75%)TRY 24,300TRY 44,250

The difference is TRY 19,950. This amount is claimed from the other vehicle's traffic insurance by written application and, if that fails, through arbitration or a lawsuit. The vehicle's diminished value is not included in this calculation and is claimed separately; we explained how it is calculated in our article how vehicle diminished value is calculated, and how to apply in our article vehicle diminished value application.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a time limit for objecting to the adjuster's report?

There is no special statutory period. The limitation period is 2 years, in any case 10 years, in traffic insurance; and 2 years, in any case 6 years, in kasko. If you accepted payment from traffic insurance and signed a document, a separate two-year period runs for annulment of an inadequate payment.

Where is an objection to the adjuster's report made?

First to the insurer in writing. If the traffic insurer does not respond within 15 days or underpays, you go to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court.

Can an objection to the adjuster's report be made via e-Devlet?

No. The "My Private Insurance" service on e-Devlet is for viewing the claim file and the adjuster's report. The objection is made to the insurer in writing.

How many days does it take for the adjuster's report to be issued?

There is no statutory period for the report itself. After the report, the traffic insurer must pay within 8 business days of the documents being complete, and the kasko insurer within 10 business days at the latest of delivery of the report.

What does equivalent part mean?

A spare part that is not original but whose quality equal to the original part is certified by an authorised body. A non-OEM aftermarket part without such certification is not an equivalent part.

Can traffic insurance fit equivalent parts to my vehicle?

If the damaged part is original, only with your consent or if the original part cannot be found. If the part was not original in the first place, an equivalent part is used first. The burden of proof lies with the insurer.

What does authorised dealer mean in kasko?

If the policy has an authorised dealer clause, repair is carried out at the brand's authorised service centre, as a rule with original parts. Under a contracted garage clause, repair is carried out at garages contracted by the insurer.

Is an independent adjuster's report valid?

It does not bind the insurer, but it is evidence for the objection and for subsequent arbitration or litigation. In kasko, the insurer pays the reasonable costs of the adjuster appointed by the insured.

The insurer underpaid for the damage; what should I do?

Get a full copy of the adjuster's report, check the part type, discount and VAT lines, get a detailed quote from the garage and object to the company in writing. When accepting the payment, reserve your rights to any excess.

Legal Basis

Legislation

  • Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, Arts. 85, 97, 99, 109, 111
  • Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Arts. 1420, 1426
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Arts. 281, 293, 400
  • General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance B.2, as amended by Official Gazette 12.06.2026, No. 33278; in force 01.07.2026 (summary)
  • General Conditions of Land Vehicle Kasko Insurance A.6, B.3.2, B.3.3.2.1, B.3.3.4.1, C.9
  • SEDDK, Circular on Report Templates to be Used by Insurance Loss Adjusters under Motor Vehicle Insurance (2026/11), 13.05.2026

Judgments

  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/5401, K.2025/17415, 25.12.2025: A supply discount not notified or documented was not applied in traffic insurance; the judgment was upheld with correction (text).
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/7530, K.2025/13873, 09.10.2025: The claims payment, parts supply and garage clauses in the policy justify a discounted calculation in kasko.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2025/4726, K.2025/7862, 15.05.2025 and E.2025/4081, K.2025/6485, 24.04.2025: Compensation including VAT in traffic insurance; the insurer's liability for the adjuster's fee.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/4296, K.2025/2543, 17.02.2025: The burden of proving that parts were not original or that an equivalent exists lies with the insurer.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2023/17, K.2025/132, 07.01.2025: Where there is a contracted garage clause, the difference for repair at a non-contracted garage remains with the insured.
  • Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/10705, K.2024/10720, 07.11.2024: If there is no clause in the policy, the contracted garage discount does not bind the kasko insured.
  • Council of State 8th Chamber, E.2020/3735, K.2022/6787, 23.11.2022: A regulation giving priority to equivalent parts was found unlawful.
  • Insurance Arbitration Commission, K-2026/343230 and K-2026/340488, 15.06.2026: A discount does not bind the insured; a release without reservation bars a claim for the difference (Arbitral Awards Journal).

The difference in the damage amount may arise not from a single item but from the total of the part type, discount, VAT and labour lines. Checking these items before repair begins and before signing any document is easier than claiming the difference later. In Istanbul we handle compensation claims against insurance companies and objection processes in traffic insurance and kasko damage files.

About the Author

Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer in Istanbul who runs his own law office and practises in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He is a graduate of Marmara University Faculty of Law. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.

This article is for general information purposes. Differences in an adjuster's report are assessed separately according to the specific features of the policy and the damage.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…