Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026
A traffic insurer can claim back from you the compensation it paid to the injured party only in the cases exhaustively listed in Article B.4 of the General Conditions: intent or gross fault, driving without a licence, alcohol or drugs, carrying passengers or loads contrary to the registration, breach of post-accident obligations, fault in the theft of the vehicle, and leaving the accident scene. The burden of proving the recourse ground and the correctness of the payment lies with the insurer; on the alcohol ground, it must also prove that the accident occurred exclusively due to the effect of alcohol. The claim reaches you as a formal notice, enforcement proceedings or a lawsuit; if no objection is made to an enforcement payment order within 7 days of service, the proceedings become final. A recourse claim is time-barred 2 years from the date the insurer paid the injured party.
Recourse grounds are limited: Only the cases listed in General Conditions B.4.
Burden of proof: Lies with the insurer; in the case of leaving the scene, the insured proves the compelling situation.
Alcohol: The accident must have occurred exclusively due to the effect of alcohol (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, 23.06.2025).
No licence: It is not required that the accident resulted from the lack of a licence; it is considered sufficient that the driver was at fault.
Leaving the scene: Also a recourse ground in accidents involving only property damage; the rule was rewritten in the General Conditions on 1 July 2026.
Time limits: 7 days for an enforcement payment order, 2 weeks to respond to a lawsuit; limitation period 2 years from the payment date.
Competent court in Istanbul: Since July 2026, commercial recourse cases have been heard at the Istanbul Commercial Courts of First Instance in Çağlayan regardless of district; consumer cases are heard at the courthouse to which the district is attached.
Traffic insurance gives broad protection to the injured party: even if the driver was drunk or unlicensed, the insurer cannot raise these grounds against the injured party and pays the compensation. However, it may claim back from its insured the amount it had to pay for these reasons, under the insurance contract and the law (Highway Traffic Law Art. 95/2). This is called recourse (rücu).
Recourse cases are exhaustively listed in Article B.4 of the General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance. The insurer cannot have recourse on a ground outside this list; for example, the driver being fully at fault in the accident is not in itself a recourse ground (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E.2021/468, K.2022/1143, 22.09.2022).
| Recourse ground | What the company must prove | Point to examine in the defence |
|---|---|---|
| Intent or gross fault | That the accident was caused intentionally or without exercising the most basic care | Gross fault differs from the fault rate; 100% fault alone is not gross fault |
| No licence (no driving licence, wrong class, invalid or confiscated) | The driver at the time of the accident, the status of the licence and the driver's fault | The class and validity of the licence; no recourse if the driver was not at fault |
| Alcohol or drugs (B.4/c) | Alcohol above the legal limit and that the accident occurred exclusively due to the effect of alcohol | The other party's fault, road and weather conditions, measurement procedure |
| Carrying passengers or loads contrary to the registration | The existence of the breach and that the accident occurred because of it | Registration and transport documents; the accident occurring independently of the breach |
| Breach of post-accident obligations | The breach and that the loss increased as a result | No recourse if the loss did not increase |
| Theft or robbery of the vehicle | Fault of the insured or persons for whom they are responsible | Key, parking and security measures |
| Leaving the scene or failure to draw up documents such as the report or alcohol report (B.4/f) | The leaving or the missing documents | Compelling situation: going to a health facility, personal safety (proved by the insured) |
Establishing that the driver had been drinking is not sufficient in itself for recourse. The Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the insurer must prove with concrete evidence that the accident occurred solely due to the effect of alcohol (E.2021/468, K.2022/1143, 22.09.2022).
When the General Conditions were amended on 1 June 2015, the phrase "loss of the ability to drive safely" was removed from the text, and some regional courts of appeal held that exclusivity should no longer be required. The Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber resolved this divergence on 23 June 2025: for post-2015 policies too, the accident must have occurred exclusively due to the effect of alcohol (E.2025/2402, K.2025/4431, by majority). The judgment also states that the 2015 amendment mainly affected the burden of proof: once the insurer proves that the driver was above the legal alcohol limit, the burden of showing that the accident was not caused by alcohol may shift to the insured.
In practice, the strongest defence breaking exclusivity is the presence of another factor in the accident: the other driver also being at fault, the effect of road or weather conditions, or a technical fault in the vehicle. That is why the fault report is at the centre of a recourse file; the routes for challenging the fault finding are explained in our article objecting to the accident report and fault rate. Whether kasko and traffic insurance pay in a drunk-driving accident is explained separately in our article does insurance pay in a drunk-driving accident.
The position for driving without a licence differs from alcohol. The Court of Cassation has considered it sufficient for recourse that the driver was unlicensed and at fault in the accident; it has not required that the accident resulted exclusively from the lack of a licence (Court of Cassation 17th Civil Chamber, E.2013/20184, K.2014/574). For this reason, the defence usually focuses on whether the licence was actually missing or invalid and on the driver's fault rate. If the driver was not at fault in the accident, the condition for recourse on the ground of no licence is not met.
Since the old text of sub-paragraph B.4/f began with the words "in traffic accidents causing bodily injury", some regional courts of appeal treated leaving the scene as a recourse ground only in injury accidents. The Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber resolved this divergence on 13 February 2025: leaving the scene is also a recourse ground in accidents involving only property damage; the burden of proving that the leaving was based on a compelling reason lies with the insured (E.2024/11202, K.2025/2473). According to the same judgment, this recourse ground did not exist in policies issued before 1 June 2015.
With the amendment published in Official Gazette No. 33278 of 12 June 2026, which entered into force on 1 July 2026, B.4/f was rewritten. The new text covers all traffic accidents and lists two separate recourse grounds: leaving the accident scene, and breaching the obligation to draw up documents relating to the circumstances of the accident, such as the accident report and the alcohol report. Leaving for personal safety and, in injury accidents, going to a health facility for treatment or help are excluded from these grounds.
If you had to leave after the accident, keep documents such as hospital records, an ambulance call, police records or witness statements; in a recourse case, you must prove the compelling situation.
The insurer can claim the recourse receivable in three ways. Which one you face determines how much time you have.
| Document received | Time limit | If missed |
|---|---|---|
| Recourse notice | No statutory response period; the period given in the notice matters for default and interest | Interest may start to run; a response acknowledging the debt interrupts the limitation period |
| Enforcement payment order | Objection to the enforcement office within 7 days of service (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 62) | The proceedings become final and may move to the attachment stage |
| Invitation to mediation | Attendance at the first meeting | A party failing to attend without excuse is held liable for all the costs of the proceedings even if they win the case |
| Statement of claim | Response within 2 weeks of service; an additional period of up to 1 month may be requested in written proceedings (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 127) | Defences such as limitation and objection to venue may not be raised later |
It is not mandatory to give reasons when objecting to a payment order; it is sufficient to state clearly that the debt and interest are objected to. The objection stops the proceedings; the insurer usually has to claim its receivable through an action for annulment of the objection. General information on the enforcement process is on our enforcement and bankruptcy law page.
The response should not contain statements acknowledging the debt and should ask the insurer for the basis of the recourse:
To the Recourse / Legal Department of [trade name of the insurer]
Sender: [Name Surname, Turkish ID No, address, KEP/e-mail]
Subject: Response to your recourse notice dated [dd.mm.yyyy] and numbered [number]
Explanations: Your notice states that you paid TRY [..] to the injured party due to the accident of [dd.mm.yyyy] involving the vehicle with plate [plate], and that you claim this amount from me on the ground of [recourse ground]. I do not accept your claim. The burden of proving that the recourse ground listed in Article B.4 of the General Conditions occurred in our case, and that the payment made to the injured party corresponds to the actual loss and the fault rate, lies with your company. I request that copies of the claim file, the loss adjuster's and fault reports, the payment documents and the documents relied on for the recourse ground be sent to me.
Name Surname · Signature · Date
No recourse ground, or not proved. The insurer must document the existence of a case listed in B.4: an alcohol measurement report, a driving licence check, a police report and so on.
The accident was not caused exclusively by alcohol. If the other party was at fault or another factor was present, recourse on the alcohol ground does not stand.
The amount paid exceeds the actual loss. The insurer can claim back only the amount it was obliged to pay the injured party. The amount of damage, diminished value or bodily injury and the policy limit can be reviewed by expert examination.
The fault rate is wrong. If a payment exceeding your fault was made to the injured party, the excess cannot be claimed back.
Limitation. If 2 years have passed since the payment date, the limitation defence must be raised; the court does not take it into account of its own motion.
Status as insured. Recourse is directed at the person who was insured under the policy on the accident date. If the vehicle was transferred before the accident, who held the status of insured and operator must be examined separately.
Start of interest. Interest can be claimed from the date the insured was put in default. If there was no notice, the date of the enforcement proceedings or the lawsuit is usually used; a claim for interest from the payment date should therefore be checked.
A 2-year limitation period applies to the insurer's recourse claim against its insured, and the period starts not from the accident date but from the date the insurer paid the injured party. Although court decisions cite Highway Traffic Law Art. 109 and Turkish Commercial Code Art. 1420 on different grounds as the basis of this period, the two-year period and the start from the payment date are common to both. If more than one payment was made to the injured party, the date of each payment should be checked separately.
The limitation period is interrupted by enforcement proceedings, a lawsuit and acknowledgement of the debt (Turkish Code of Obligations Art. 154). A letter accepting the debt, a partial payment or an instalment agreement causes the period to start again. For this reason, the wording used when responding to the notice and when talking to the insurer is important.
A recourse action arises from the insurance contract. In a case brought against an insured who uses the vehicle for personal purposes and is a consumer, the consumer court has jurisdiction; for vehicles registered in a company's name or used for commercial purposes, the commercial court of first instance. In both cases, the insurer's application to a mediator before filing a lawsuit is a precondition (Law No. 6502 Art. 73/A; TTK Art. 5/A).
The mediation meeting is an opportunity to assess the recourse file before a lawsuit is filed: it can be argued at this stage that the recourse ground is weak, that the amount was overcalculated or that the limitation period has expired; instalments or a discount can also be discussed. General information on the process is on our mediation page.
The general rule in a recourse action is that the case is filed in the court of the defendant's, that is the insured's, place of residence (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 6). However, a recourse receivable is a monetary claim arising from a contract; since the place of performance of monetary debts is the creditor's place of residence, the insurer may also start the lawsuit or enforcement proceedings where its head office is located (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 10; Code of Obligations Art. 89). Since most insurers have their head offices in Istanbul, an insured living in another city may also receive a payment order from an Istanbul enforcement office or a statement of claim from an Istanbul court.
If the proceedings or the case were started in a place without venue, the objection to venue is time-limited: in enforcement proceedings it must be made within 7 days together with the objection to the payment order, and in a lawsuit as a preliminary objection in the statement of defence. The party objecting to venue in a lawsuit must also indicate the competent court; otherwise the objection is disregarded (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 19). Whether the objection succeeds depends on the venue rule the insurer relies on.
Which courthouse to go to in Istanbul depends on the type of court:
Commercial court of first instance: By decision No. 282 of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors (HSK) dated 18 February 2026, the Bakırköy, Istanbul Anatolian and Küçükçekmece commercial courts of first instance were merged with the Istanbul Commercial Courts of First Instance; the merger took effect in July 2026. The jurisdiction of the Istanbul Commercial Courts of First Instance now covers the whole province of Istanbul. A commercial recourse action is therefore heard at the Istanbul Courthouse in Çağlayan regardless of district.
Consumer court: A case brought against an insured who is a consumer is heard at the courthouse to which the competent place is attached. If there is no consumer court at the courthouse, the civil court of first instance hears the case acting as a consumer court.
| Courthouse | Attached districts |
|---|---|
| Istanbul Courthouse (Çağlayan) | Bayrampaşa, Beşiktaş, Beyoğlu, Fatih, Kağıthane, Sarıyer, Şişli |
| Gaziosmanpaşa Courthouse | Arnavutköy, Eyüpsultan, Gaziosmanpaşa, Sultangazi |
| Bakırköy Courthouse | Bağcılar, Bahçelievler, Bakırköy, Esenler, Güngören, Zeytinburnu |
| Küçükçekmece Courthouse | Avcılar, Başakşehir, Küçükçekmece |
| Büyükçekmece Courthouse | Beylikdüzü, Büyükçekmece, Esenyurt |
| Silivri Courthouse and Çatalca Courthouse | Silivri; Çatalca |
| Istanbul Anatolian Courthouse (Kartal) | Ataşehir, Çekmeköy, Kadıköy, Kartal, Maltepe, Pendik, Sancaktepe, Sultanbeyli, Tuzla, Ümraniye, Üsküdar |
| Beykoz, Şile and Adalar courthouses | Beykoz; Şile; Adalar |
From 1 September 2025, Eyüpsultan was separated from the Istanbul Courthouse and attached to the Gaziosmanpaşa Courthouse (HSK, 06.08.2025, decision No. 1081). Since jurisdictional areas can change by HSK decisions, rely on the name of the court and enforcement office in the notification you receive.
Do not pay without checking the recourse ground, the amount paid and the limitation period.
Have the agreement state that, once payment is made, the insurer will make no further claim for the same accident and releases you.
If there are enforcement proceedings, add to the agreement that the proceedings will be closed and an out-of-court collection notice filed after payment.
In an instalment plan, the due dates, amounts and what happens in the event of delay must be stated clearly.
It does, but only in the cases listed in General Conditions B.4: intent or gross fault, no licence, alcohol or drugs, carriage contrary to the registration, breach of post-accident obligations, fault in the theft of the vehicle and leaving the scene. If these cases do not exist, the payment the insurer made to the injured party cannot be claimed back from you.
Recourse is directed at the insured in the policy, that is, the vehicle owner (operator); the driver is not a party to the insurance contract. If the vehicle owner has to pay, they can turn to the driver at fault in their internal relationship. For this reason, it is important to document who used the vehicle and on what terms.
If the insurer paid diminished value to the injured party and there is a recourse ground, it can claim this amount from you as well. However, whether the diminished value paid was correctly calculated can be disputed in the recourse action. How diminished value has been calculated since 1 July 2026 is in our article how vehicle diminished value is calculated.
As a rule, no. Traffic insurance pays the injured party in proportion to the fault of the insured vehicle's driver; if the driver was not at fault, in most cases no payment arises and there is no amount to claim back. Recourse on the ground of no licence also requires the driver to have been at fault.
Interest can be claimed from the date the insured was put in default: the date the period given in the recourse notice expired or, if there was no notice, the date of the enforcement proceedings or lawsuit. The type of interest (statutory interest or advance interest) depends on whether the relationship is a commercial matter from your side.
First, do not give a response accepting payment or the debt. Find out the recourse ground, the payment date and the amount; ask for the claim file and the payment documents. Then check whether the recourse ground fits a case listed in B.4 and check the limitation period. Since enforcement proceedings or a mediation invitation may follow this stage, keep track of notifications.
Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, Arts. 95, 109
General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance, B.4 (including B.4/c and B.4/f); amendment published in Official Gazette No. 33278 of 12.06.2026 (in force 01.07.2026)
Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Arts. 5/A, 1420
Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Art. 154
Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, Art. 62
Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Art. 127
Consumer Protection Law No. 6502, Art. 73/A; Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes, Art. 18/A
Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E.2021/468, K.2022/1143, 22.09.2022
Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E.2025/2402, K.2025/4431, 23.06.2025 (resolution of divergence)
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/11202, K.2025/2473, 13.02.2025 (resolution of divergence)
Court of Cassation 17th Civil Chamber, E.2013/20184, K.2014/574
Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 Arts. 6, 10, 19; Code of Obligations No. 6098 Art. 89
HSK Plenary, decision No. 1081 of 06.08.2025 (Official Gazette 12.08.2025, 32984; in force 01.09.2025)
HSK Plenary, decision No. 282 of 18.02.2026 (Official Gazette 20.02.2026)
Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer registered with the Istanbul Bar Association who runs his own law office and practises in Istanbul in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He is a graduate of Marmara University Faculty of Law. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.
This article is for general information purposes. The outcome of a recourse claim depends on the General Conditions in force when the policy was issued, the fault report and the evidence in the file.