The Offence of Violating the Inviolability of the Home

The Offence of Violating the Inviolability of the Home
05 Oct

The offense of violating the immunity of residence occurs when a person enters another person's residence or its annexes without consent or fails to leave after initially entering with consent. Regulated under Article 116 of the Turkish Penal Code, this offense aims to protect a person's private living space and their right to live peacefully in their residence.

In the basic form of the offense, investigation and prosecution depend on the victim's complaint. If force or threats are used, or if the act is committed at night, a more severe penalty is imposed. In certain specific circumstances listed in Article 119 of the Turkish Penal Code, the penalty is further increased.

What Is the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence?

Violation of the immunity of residence means entering a legally protected residential area against the consent of the person entitled to its protection or remaining inside despite having initially entered with consent and subsequently being asked to leave by the owner or rights holder.

It is not necessary for the door to be broken or force to be used for the offense to occur. For example, if a person enters a home upon invitation but refuses to leave after being asked to do so, this may constitute the offense of violating the immunity of residence depending on the circumstances of the case.

Penalty for Violating the Immunity of Residence Under Article 116 of the Turkish Penal Code

Article 116 provides different penalties for violations involving residences and certain workplaces. The location, manner, and circumstances in which the act was committed are important in determining the applicable penalty.

Nature of the Act
Penalty Prescribed by Law
Entering a residence or annex without consent / failing to leave
Imprisonment from 6 months to 2 years
Violation involving certain workplaces
Imprisonment from 6 months to 1 year or a judicial fine
Commission by force, threat, or at night
Imprisonment from 1 to 3 years

Elements of the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

For the basic form of the offense to occur, the offender must enter a protected area belonging to another person without consent or fail to leave after entering with consent. Consent is assessed in terms of whether the person who has rights over the residence or workplace has permitted the act.

Entering a Residence Without Consent

Entering a residence without the consent of the owner or the person who has legally protected control over the residence is one of the basic forms of the offense. The fact that the door is open does not, by itself, mean that consent to enter exists in every situation.

Failing to Leave After Entering with Consent

Even if a person initially received permission to enter the residence, the offense may arise if they continue to remain inside despite the owner or rights holder expressly asking them to leave. Therefore, the offense does not occur solely through unauthorized entry.

What Are a Residence and Its Annexes?

The concept of a residence is not limited to the room where a person sleeps or permanently lives. Certain areas where a person conducts their private life and which form an integral part of the residence may also fall within legal protection.

Whether a garden, garage, storage area, or other sections connected to a residence qualify as annexes is determined according to the circumstances of the specific case. The connection of the area to the residence, its purpose of use, and environmental conditions are important in the assessment.

Violation of the Immunity of a Workplace

Under Article 116/2 of the Turkish Penal Code, entering workplaces and their annexes where entry is not customary without requiring explicit consent, without consent, or failing to leave after entering with consent may also constitute an offense.

Entering a store open to the public during normal business hours when customers are ordinarily permitted to enter does not, as a rule, constitute a violation of workplace immunity. However, acting without consent during hours when the workplace is closed or in areas where entry is restricted to certain persons may be assessed differently. The Court of Cassation also evaluates the nature of the workplace and the ordinary circumstances of entry based on the specific case.

Consent in a Shared Residence

Article 116/3 introduces a special provision concerning family members within a marital union or situations where a residence is jointly used by more than one person. The consent of one of these persons may, within the conditions specified by law, prevent the offense from being established.

However, the consent given must serve a legitimate purpose. Therefore, a shared-use relationship does not mean that the immunity of the other person's residence may be violated without limitation in every situation.

Commission of the Offense by Force, Threat, or at Night

If the offense of violating the immunity of residence is committed by using force or threats or at night, a more severe penalty is imposed under Article 116/4 of the Turkish Penal Code. In this case, the penalty is imprisonment from one to three years.

Commission at night is also one of the aggravating circumstances specified by law. Whether force or threats were used and whether the incident occurred at night are evaluated together with the evidence.

Commission with a Weapon or by More Than One Person

If certain aggravated circumstances listed in Article 119 of the Turkish Penal Code are present in the offense of violating the immunity of residence, the applicable penalty is increased by one half. Commission of the offense with a weapon, by making oneself unrecognizable, jointly by more than one person, by taking advantage of the intimidating power created by a criminal organization, or by abusing the influence provided by a public office falls within this scope.

In addition, if the aggravated consequences of intentional injury occur during the commission of the offense, the provisions concerning the offense of injury may also be applied separately.

Complaint in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

The basic forms covered by Articles 116/1 and 116/2 of the Turkish Penal Code generally depend on the victim's complaint. The victim must generally exercise their right to file a complaint within six months from the date they learn of the act and the offender.

On the other hand, if the act is committed under Article 116/4 by using force or threats or at night, or if one of the aggravated circumstances regulated under Article 119 is present, whether the investigation depends on a complaint must be assessed separately. In such cases, an investigation ex officio may be conducted due to the specific provisions of the law.

Mediation in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

The offense of violating the immunity of residence is among the offenses to which mediation provisions under Article 253 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) apply. Therefore, if the necessary conditions are met during the investigation stage, the case may be referred to the mediation bureau.

If mediation is successfully concluded, the outcome of the investigation or prosecution is determined according to how and at what stage the mediation was reached. However, whether mediation provisions apply to aggravated forms of the offense must be assessed separately.

Evidence in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

Different types of evidence may be used to prove the offense depending on the circumstances of the incident. In particular, statements of the parties, witness testimony, security camera footage, messages, call records, and images relating to the location where the incident occurred may be important.

  • Security camera recordings
  • Witness statements
  • Messaging and communication records
  • Crime scene investigation findings
  • Audio or video recordings
  • Statements of the parties

It is important that evidence is obtained lawfully. Rather than relying solely on a single piece of evidence, the court evaluates the incident as a whole and the consistency between the evidence.

Attempt in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

If the offender begins the acts of execution with the intention of completing the offense but is unable to enter the residence due to a reason beyond their control, the provisions concerning attempt may arise depending on the circumstances of the specific case.

For example, if the offender forces the door but is caught before entering, the matter is assessed in terms of whether the offense was completed and what stage the acts of execution had reached.

Statute of Limitations for the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

The applicable statute of limitations for prosecution in the offense of violating the immunity of residence is determined by taking into account the type of offense and the penalty applicable in the specific case. Under Article 66 of the Turkish Penal Code, an ordinary prosecution limitation period of eight years generally applies to the basic and aggravated forms.

In calculating the limitation period, the date the offense was committed, the manner in which the offense was completed, grounds for interruption or suspension, and whether multiple offenses are involved must also be assessed separately.

Trial Process in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

In the basic forms that depend on a complaint, the investigation process begins when the victim files a complaint within the applicable period. The complaint may be filed with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office or law enforcement authorities. If sufficient suspicion exists at the end of the investigation, a public prosecution may be initiated.

During criminal proceedings, evidence is collected according to the nature of the incident, statements of the parties and witnesses are taken, and it is assessed whether the elements of the offense have been established. The competent court is generally the Criminal Court of First Instance. A detailed legal assessment regarding the general operation of criminal investigations and prosecutions may be conducted within the scope of criminal law. During this process, Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may evaluate a legal roadmap according to the characteristics of the case.

Legal Support from an Attorney in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

In allegations involving a violation of the immunity of residence, it is of great importance to correctly determine which paragraph of the law applies to the incident. Whether consent existed, the nature of the residence or workplace, whether the act occurred at night, and whether force or threats were used may directly affect the determination of the penalty.

Obtaining legal support from an attorney practicing in criminal law may be beneficial to avoid missing the complaint period, collect evidence in a timely manner, and properly conduct the mediation process. If the incident involves an element of threat, legal support concerning the offense of threatening may also be considered. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may provide support in evaluating the legal nature of the incident and the evidence during the investigation and prosecution process.

Legal Liability in the Offense of Violating the Immunity of Residence

If a person suffers material or non-pecuniary harm due to a violation of the immunity of residence, legal liability may also arise in addition to the criminal investigation, depending on the circumstances of the specific case. In particular, the nature and scope of the harm arising from the unlawful act should be separately assessed.

In such cases, it may be necessary to examine the legal aspects of material and non-pecuniary harm that may arise in connection with the criminal investigation. An assessment under compensation law takes into account elements such as the unlawfulness of the act, the harm, and the causal connection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the penalty for violating the immunity of residence?

In the basic form, imprisonment from six months to two years is prescribed. If the offense is committed by force, threat, or at night, the penalty may be imprisonment from one to three years.

Is entering a home without permission a crime?

Entering a residence without the consent of the owner or legally protected rights holder may constitute the offense of violating the immunity of residence if the conditions specified in Article 116 of the Turkish Penal Code are met.

Does a crime occur if a guest refuses to leave the house?

Even if a person initially entered the home with consent, if they continue to remain inside without a justified reason despite being expressly asked to leave, the offense of violating the immunity of residence may arise depending on the circumstances of the specific case.

Is the offense of violating the immunity of residence subject to mediation?

Offenses under Article 116 of the Turkish Penal Code may fall within the scope of mediation under Article 253 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. However, if an aggravated form of the offense is involved or the offense is committed together with other offenses, a separate assessment is required.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…