A compensation action arising from the maintenance of the land registry is an action filed by a person who has suffered damage due to the land registry being maintained unlawfully or incorrectly, seeking compensation from the State for the actual damage suffered. Pursuant to Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code, the State is liable for all damages arising from the maintenance of the land registry.
This liability may give rise to the State's responsibility regardless of whether the land registry official is at fault. However, in order for compensation to be claimed, there must be an adequate causal link between the maintenance of the land registry and the damage, and actual damage must have occurred.
What Is a Compensation Action Arising from the Maintenance of the Land Registry?
The land registry ensures that ownership and other real rights over immovable properties are reliably recorded. Where a person loses a real right or suffers a decrease in their assets due to an incorrect registry or an unlawful registration, compensation may be claimed under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code.
The primary purpose of this action is to compensate for the actual damage suffered by a person who relied on the land registry being accurately maintained. The action is based not on the personal liability of the land registry official, but on the State's liability arising from law. For other legal aspects of disputes concerning immovable properties, assessments made within the scope of real estate law may also be important.
What Is the State's Liability Arising from the Land Registry?
The liability regulated under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code is a form of strict liability. Therefore, proving that the land registry official was independently at fault is, as a rule, not required for the State's liability to arise.
In the case law of the Court of Cassation, it is also accepted that the State is primarily liable for damages arising from the maintenance of the land registry and that fault is relevant not to the State's liability, but to the recourse relationship with the official. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun states that, in disputes arising from the land registry, the scope of liability and the circumstances of the specific case must be assessed together.
In Which Cases Can a Compensation Action Be Filed?
A claim under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code may arise where actual damage occurs to a person's assets due to an incorrect land registry record, unlawful registration, erroneous cancellation of a registration, or similar registry transactions.
Due to the connection between cadastral procedures and the establishment and maintenance of the land registry, certain cadastral errors may also give rise to the State's liability under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code. However, not every cadastral dispute automatically creates an entitlement to compensation; the nature of the specific case and the source of the damage must be examined.
Conditions of a Compensation Action Arising from the Maintenance of the Land Registry
- There must be an unlawful or erroneous transaction concerning the maintenance of the land registry.
- Actual and identifiable damage must have occurred as a result of this transaction.
- There must be an adequate causal link between the transaction in the land registry and the resulting damage.
- The plaintiff must have a real right or property right worthy of legal protection.
- The action must be filed within the applicable statutory limitation period.
It is particularly important that the element of damage has actually occurred. Not every error in a land registry record by itself gives rise to a right to compensation. The error must have caused an actual loss to the person's assets.
Can a Compensation Action Be Filed Following a Cancellation of the Land Registry Record?
The cancellation of the land registry record of an immovable property may, in certain circumstances, result in damage within the scope of Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code. In particular, if a person acquired ownership relying on the land registry record but that record was subsequently cancelled, the State's liability for compensation may arise depending on the circumstances of the specific case.
In the case law of the Court of Cassation, there are cases in which the damage became apparent upon the finalization of the decision concerning the cancellation of the land registry record. However, it cannot be said that every decision cancelling a land registry record automatically gives rise to a right to compensation; how the land registry record was created, the plaintiff's circumstances, and the connection between the damage and the registry must be separately examined.
Against Whom Is a Compensation Action Arising from the Maintenance of the Land Registry Filed?
Since liability belongs to the State in a compensation action under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code, the action is filed against the Treasury. Naming the land registry director or land registry official personally as the defendant is incompatible with the nature of the primary liability regulated under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code.
The State may exercise recourse against the official whose fault contributed to the occurrence of the damage in respect of the compensation it has paid. This internal relationship does not prevent the injured person from directly filing an action against the Treasury.
Which Court Has Subject-Matter and Territorial Jurisdiction?
Compensation actions arising from the maintenance of the land registry are heard by the judicial courts. As a rule, the Civil Court of First Instance has subject-matter jurisdiction.
Pursuant to Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code, actions concerning the State's liability are to be heard by the court of the place where the relevant land registry is located. Therefore, before filing an action, the location of the land registry concerning the immovable property and the rules on territorial jurisdiction applicable to the specific case must be carefully assessed.
Statute of Limitations for a Compensation Action Arising from the Land Registry
Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code does not provide for a specific limitation period. Accordingly, in the case law of the Court of Cassation, the general 10-year limitation period under Article 146 of the Turkish Code of Obligations is accepted as applicable.
However, the date from which the limitation period begins is determined according to the circumstances of the specific case. In particular, when the damage occurred and when the possibility of correcting the land registry record ceased to exist may be important. Therefore, the limitation period should not be calculated solely by looking at the date of the land registry transaction.
How Is the Amount of Compensation Determined?
The amount of compensation is determined based on the actual loss suffered in the injured person's assets. The purpose is to compensate for the difference between the condition the person's assets would have been in if the damaging transaction had not occurred and their current condition.
Factors such as the nature, size, location, economic value of the immovable property, the extent of the loss of the land registry right, and the date on which the damage occurred may be important in calculating compensation. Therefore, an expert examination may be required by the court. With regard to the scope of compensation claims, the provisions of compensation law must also be assessed according to the specific case.
What Evidence Is Used in a Compensation Action Arising from the Land Registry?
Depending on the nature of the action, land registry records, cadastral documents, land registry transaction files, court decisions, site inspections and expert examinations, official correspondence, and documents demonstrating the value of the immovable property may be used as evidence.
In particular, it must be clearly established which transaction caused the land registry record to become erroneous and what type of damage this error caused to the plaintiff's assets.
Key Elements of a Compensation Action Arising from the Land Registry
Can Compensation Be Claimed If the Error in the Land Registry Can Be Corrected?
Where an error in the land registry has not yet resulted in actual damage requiring compensation, the conditions for claiming compensation under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code may not have been met. In particular, as long as it is possible to correct the registry record, it must be assessed whether a definite loss has occurred in the person's assets.
Therefore, rather than directly making the error in the land registry record the subject of a compensation action, it must be determined in the specific case whether the land registry record can be corrected and whether the damage has definitively occurred.
Points to Consider in a Compensation Action Arising from the Maintenance of the Land Registry
- Not every error in a land registry record automatically gives rise to a right to compensation.
- Actual and identifiable damage must have occurred.
- There must be an adequate causal link between the transaction in the land registry and the damage.
- The action is generally filed against the Treasury.
- As a rule, it is not necessary to separately prove the fault of the land registry official for the State's liability under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code.
- The rules concerning the court with subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction should be assessed before filing the action.
- When calculating the limitation period, the date on which the damage occurred and the circumstances of the specific case must be taken into account.
- The actual value of the immovable property and the actual damage suffered are important in determining the amount of compensation.
In disputes arising from the land registry, it may be necessary to assess not only the compensation claim but also other rights and claims concerning the immovable property together. Therefore, it may be important for Attorney Mehmet Kurşun to examine the documents and land registry records of the specific case and determine the appropriate legal course of action.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the State liable for an error in the land registry?
Yes. Pursuant to Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code, the State is liable for all damages arising from the maintenance of the land registry.
Against whom is a compensation action arising from the land registry filed?
An action under Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code is filed against the State, with the Treasury named as the defendant in practice.
Is fault required in a compensation action arising from the land registry?
The State's liability is a form of strict liability. However, there must be an adequate causal link between the damage and the maintenance of the land registry.
What is the statute of limitations for a compensation action arising from the land registry?
Since Article 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code does not provide for a specific limitation period, the general 10-year limitation period is applied as a rule in the case law of the Court of Cassation.

