Claims and Compensation Lawsuits Against Cryptocurrency Exchanges

Claims and Compensation Lawsuits Against Cryptocurrency Exchanges
06 Oct

A user may seek recovery of funds or crypto assets and, where the legal requirements are met, compensation when a cryptocurrency exchange refuses a lawful withdrawal, executes an unauthorized transfer, processes an order incorrectly, or blocks an account without a sufficient contractual or regulatory basis. An ordinary market loss is different from damage caused by a platform's breach. Liability depends on the duty owed by the exchange, the nature of the breach, proof of loss, causation, and the user's own conduct.

The first task in a crypto-exchange dispute is to separate the technical event from its legal consequences. A failed withdrawal, a compromised account, a phishing incident, a custody failure, insolvency, and an erroneous liquidation do not create the same claim. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can review the account history, contract terms, security data, and platform communications to determine whether the matter should be pursued as a debt claim, contractual damages, tort, unjust enrichment, or a combination permitted by the facts.

What Can Be Claimed from a Cryptocurrency Exchange?

If a cash balance remains visible but cannot be withdrawn, the user may demand payment of the matured balance together with applicable default consequences. If crypto assets that should be delivered or transferred remain under the platform's control, restitution in kind may be requested where technically and legally possible. When performance in kind is impossible, the dispute may focus on the monetary value and the correct valuation date.

Additional damages may arise from an unauthorized transfer, an incorrectly executed order, a security failure, or an unlawful deduction. A claim for lost profit requires more than showing that the asset later increased in value. The claimant must establish, with reasonable certainty, the transaction that would have occurred and the causal link between the breach and the alleged opportunity. Issues involving logs, access controls, digital wallets, and electronic evidence also require principles of information technology law.

The Current Regulatory Framework in Türkiye

Crypto-asset service providers are now expressly regulated under Capital Markets Law No. 6362. Amendments enacted in 2024 defined platforms, wallet and custody services and placed the establishment and operation of service providers under the authority of the Capital Markets Board of Türkiye. Secondary rules published on 13 March 2025 further address authorization, governance, information systems, record keeping, custody, transfers, capital adequacy, internal control, and proof-of-reserve audits.

The Capital Markets Law permits customer contracts to be formed in writing or through qualifying remote methods and provides that contractual clauses excluding or limiting a service provider's liability toward customers are invalid. A private-law claim may nevertheless depend on several bodies of law. The Turkish Code of Obligations governs non-performance, fault, default, and damages; consumer, commercial, and tort rules may also apply according to the parties and purpose of the transaction. Inclusion on a regulatory list must not be confused with a state guarantee of customer assets or conclusive authorization for every activity.

When May the Exchange Be Liable?

  • Failure to execute a valid cash withdrawal or crypto-transfer instruction without a lawful justification,
  • Execution of an order at the wrong price, amount, or direction because of a system defect,
  • Breach of duties concerning segregation, custody, or reconciliation of customer assets,
  • Unauthorized transactions linked to inadequate access controls or deficient security monitoring,
  • Fees, deductions, or liquidations applied contrary to the contract and disclosed trading rules,
  • Misleading information or concealment of an essential feature of the service,
  • Failure to maintain or provide transaction records required for an effective investigation.

A successful damages claim normally requires a breach, actual loss, and an adequate causal connection. The exchange may argue that the incident resulted from malware on the user's device, disclosure of a verification code, use of an insecure email account, or disregard of a clear security warning. The court may consider the conduct of both sides and reduce compensation if the user contributed to the loss. A disclaimer in standard terms does not automatically determine the outcome, particularly where mandatory law invalidates limitations of liability.

How Are the Recoverable Amounts Calculated?

The calculation should not rely only on a screenshot showing a balance. It should reconcile the platform ledger, bank deposits, withdrawals, order history, blockchain transaction identifiers, exchange rates, fees, and any partial repayments. For a token or coin that should have been returned, the proper remedy may be delivery of the same quantity. If delivery is no longer possible or appropriate, the valuation date may depend on the type of action, the time of default, the date of suit, and the causal scope of the breach.

Dispute
Possible remedy
Key evidence
Unpaid withdrawal
Balance, default consequences, interest
Ledger, bank receipt, support tickets
Unauthorized transfer
Restitution or compensatory damages
Transaction hash, IP and session records, alerts
Erroneous order or outage
Proven transaction loss
Order timestamps, market data, outage notices

What Should Be Done Before Filing a Lawsuit?

The user should first submit a precise complaint through the exchange's internal mechanism. The notice should identify the affected account, transaction numbers, disputed amount or asset, the requested remedy, and a reasonable response period. A notarial notice or registered electronic notification may help establish delivery and the date of default. Support chats and in-app messages should be exported or preserved with their dates rather than left solely inside an account that may later become inaccessible.

A complaint to the Capital Markets Board serves a regulatory purpose and does not itself collect a private debt. Likewise, a criminal complaint may be appropriate where fraud, unauthorized access, breach of trust, or another offence is suspected, but a criminal investigation does not automatically replace civil recovery. Limitation periods and procedural requirements for the civil claim should be monitored separately while regulatory or criminal proceedings continue.

Mediation, Jurisdiction, and the Competent Court

The competent court and mandatory pre-litigation steps depend on how the legal relationship is classified. A natural person using the service for non-professional purposes may invoke consumer-law rules if the transaction qualifies as a consumer transaction. Claims connected with commercial enterprises may constitute commercial disputes. Monetary consumer and commercial disputes are generally subject to mandatory mediation before suit, subject to the statutory scope and exceptions in force when the application is made.

Venue cannot always be determined solely by a clause in the platform's standard terms. The defendant's registered office, the place of performance, consumer venue protections, and the validity of any jurisdiction or arbitration clause must be examined together. If the matter is commercial, the rules governing commercial litigation may affect the court, evidence, and procedural strategy. Filing in the wrong court or before completing mandatory mediation can cause delay and additional cost.

Evidence Needed in a Crypto-Exchange Claim

  1. The version of the user agreement, fee schedule, and risk notices applicable on the event date,
  2. Complete account statements, balances, deposits, withdrawals, orders, and liquidation records,
  3. Bank receipts, payment-provider data, wallet addresses, and blockchain transaction hashes,
  4. Email, SMS, push notifications, and the full support-ticket history,
  5. Login times, IP and device data, two-factor authentication events, and security alerts,
  6. Reliable market-price data and platform announcements concerning outages or maintenance,
  7. Raw data that allows an expert to reproduce the calculation of each alleged loss.

Screenshots are useful but may be challenged as editable or incomplete. The source, creation time, and integrity of electronic records should therefore be preserved whenever possible. The court may order the exchange or a third party to produce records, obtain an expert examination, or conduct a preliminary determination of evidence. Prompt preservation is essential because a later account closure, system migration, or retention limit may make proof more difficult.

Can Interim Measures or Enforcement Proceedings Be Used?

If there is a concrete risk that assets will be dissipated or recovery will become substantially harder, the claimant may examine the conditions for a preliminary attachment or an interim injunction. These remedies are not automatic. Courts consider the nature of the claim, prima facie evidence, proportionality, and security. A broad request to freeze an unidentified wallet is unlikely to be effective unless ownership, control, and the relationship between the wallet and the defendant can be shown.

For a definite and due monetary claim, debt-enforcement proceedings without a prior judgment may be considered. If the exchange objects, proceedings to set aside or annul the objection may follow. Where liability turns on complex technical facts and the loss requires expert calculation, a direct lawsuit may offer a clearer path. The available enforcement and receivables recovery methods should be compared with the debtor's financial position and the evidence already available.

Limitation Periods and Insolvency Risk

There is no single limitation period for every crypto dispute. Contractual debt, tort, unjust enrichment, consumer claims, and other legal bases may be governed by different periods and commencement rules. If the platform enters liquidation, restructuring, or bankruptcy, creditors may also be required to register their claims within a separate procedural timetable. Waiting for customer support to answer does not necessarily suspend a limitation period.

Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can build a case calendar by comparing the transaction date, the date on which the loss and responsible party became known, formal notices, mediation, and any enforcement step. Protective action should not be postponed merely because the platform promises an internal review. Evidence collection and the procedural step needed to prevent loss of rights can progress at the same time.

How Does the Lawsuit Proceed?

A well-prepared matter begins with identification of the contracting entity and precise formulation of the remedy. Evidence is preserved, the loss is reconciled, and mandatory mediation is completed if applicable. The statement of claim should present the technical incident in a clear chronology and connect every requested amount with its legal basis and supporting record. A partial or unquantified debt action may be examined where the full amount cannot reasonably be calculated at the outset.

The court may collect platform records and appoint experts in information systems, finance, or accounting. Expert work should use reproducible timestamps and market data and should not replace the court's legal assessment. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can coordinate the technical and legal aspects of the file, challenge incomplete expert assumptions, request missing records, and plan enforcement after judgment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the highest later market price be awarded?

Not automatically. The valuation date depends on the remedy, the time of default, whether restitution in kind remains possible, and whether the alleged price difference was caused by the breach. A retrospective selection of the highest price is generally insufficient by itself.

Does an application to the Capital Markets Board replace a lawsuit?

No. Regulatory complaints, criminal proceedings, mediation, enforcement, and civil litigation serve different purposes. The route required to recover a private debt or damages must be pursued separately.

Proceedings Against Foreign-Based Exchanges

Claims against a foreign-based crypto exchange require an early review of jurisdiction, applicable law, the platform’s contractual terms, the location of assets and the enforceability of a judgment. Evidence such as account statements, transaction records, wallet addresses, support correspondence and identity-verification records should be secured before access is lost. Depending on the facts, proceedings in Turkey may be combined with applications in the country where the exchange is established.

My exchange account was closed. Can I claim my balance?

Account closure does not by itself extinguish a documented balance. The contractual basis for the restriction, compliance checks, transaction history and withdrawal requests should be reviewed before a payment, restitution or damages claim is pursued.

Does a hacking incident eliminate the exchange’s liability?

No. A cyberattack does not automatically release the exchange from liability. Security measures, warnings, custody arrangements, the cause of the loss and whether the user contributed to the damage must be examined in the specific case.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…