How Do You Bring a Pre-emption Right Claim?

How Do You Bring a Pre-emption Right Claim?
05 Oct

A pre-emption right lawsuit is an action filed by a co-owner of a property subject to joint ownership to exercise the statutory priority right to purchase a share when that share is sold to a third party. The statutory pre-emption right regulated under Articles 732 et seq. of the Turkish Civil Code may, when the relevant conditions are met, allow the share to be acquired from the purchaser and transferred to the holder of the pre-emption right.

Before filing the lawsuit, the nature of the sale transaction, the date of notification, and the commencement of the forfeiture periods must be carefully examined. Therefore, in the legal assessment conducted by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun, it may be important to examine the land registry records and documents concerning the sale together.

What Is the Pre-emption Right?

The pre-emption right is a right that allows the other co-owners of a property subject to joint ownership to acquire a share with priority when one of the co-owners sells their share to a third party. This right concerns the acquisition of the share sold by the co-owner to the third party, rather than the acquisition of the entire property.

The statutory pre-emption right arises from law. In addition, a contractual pre-emption right may also exist. Therefore, before filing a lawsuit, it is important to determine the legal basis on which the asserted pre-emption right is based. As with other disputes concerning immovable property, legal assessments under real estate law may be important in such cases.

Under What Conditions Can a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit Be Filed?

For the statutory pre-emption right to be exercised, there must first be joint ownership, and one of the co-owners must have sold their share to a third party. If the share is transferred to another co-owner, the statutory pre-emption right does not arise.

For the holder of the pre-emption right to file a lawsuit, the sale transaction must have been completed. The actual nature of the sale, the circumstances of the parties, and the land registry records are also examined during the proceedings.

Who Can File a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit?

A statutory pre-emption lawsuit may be filed by a person who is a co-owner of a property subject to joint ownership. If more than one co-owner wishes to exercise the pre-emption right, the legal position of each co-owner is assessed separately.

The lawsuit is filed against the third party who purchased the share in the property. Therefore, it is important to correctly identify the purchaser as the defendant in the statement of claim.

How Is a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit Filed?

A pre-emption right lawsuit is filed by submitting a statement of claim to the court with subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction. The statement of claim should clearly specify the land registry details of the property, the co-ownership status, the sale that took place, the date of sale, the purchaser's information, and the reason for exercising the pre-emption right.

When filing the lawsuit, land registry records, documents concerning the sale, and documents demonstrating the co-ownership may be submitted. Where necessary, the court may also examine the land registry records and other evidence ex officio.

Where Is the Sale Price Deposited in a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit?

The holder of the pre-emption right must deposit the sale price and the land registry expenses attributable to the purchaser in cash within the period determined by the court in order for the share to be registered in their name. Therefore, during the proceedings, the court's interim decision requiring the deposit of the amount must be complied with within the specified period.

The actual amount of the sale price is also one of the important issues in the dispute. If it is alleged that the price stated in the land registry differs from the actual sale price, the parties' allegations and the evidence submitted are assessed by the court.

What Is the Time Limit for a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit?

The law provides for forfeiture periods concerning the exercise of the pre-emption right. If the sale is notified to the holder of the right through a notary public, the pre-emption right must be exercised within three months from the date of notification.

If the sale is not notified to the holder of the right, the pre-emption right is forfeited in all cases upon the expiration of two years from the date of the sale. Since these are forfeiture periods, it is of great importance for the lawsuit that these periods are not allowed to expire.

Competent and Authorized Court in a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit

The court with subject-matter jurisdiction over a pre-emption right lawsuit is generally the Civil Court of First Instance. In lawsuits concerning rights in rem over immovable property, the court of the place where the property is located has mandatory territorial jurisdiction. Therefore, a pre-emption right lawsuit must be filed where the property is located.

If the property has a special status involving more than one judicial district, a separate assessment regarding territorial jurisdiction may be required.

What Documents Are Required in a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit?

Different documents may be used during the proceedings depending on the nature of the dispute. In particular, land registry records and information concerning the sale are among the fundamental documents of the lawsuit.

  • Land registry record and information concerning the property,
  • Documents demonstrating the co-ownership,
  • Land registry records demonstrating the sale transaction,
  • Documents concerning notification made through a notary public, if applicable,
  • Documents concerning the sale price,
  • Written agreements and other evidence, if any.

What Decision Does the Court Make in a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit?

The court examines whether the pre-emption right has arisen, whether the plaintiff is in a position to exercise this right, whether the period for filing the lawsuit has expired, and the nature of the sale transaction.

If the conditions are deemed to have been fulfilled and the required amount has been deposited, the court may order the sold share to be registered in the name of the holder of the pre-emption right. If it is determined that the conditions have not been met or that the forfeiture period has expired, the lawsuit may be dismissed.

Points to Consider in a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit

In pre-emption right lawsuits, it is particularly important to accurately determine the date of sale and whether the sale was notified to the holder of the right. This is because these matters are important in determining the commencement of the three-month and two-year forfeiture periods.

In addition, the sale price stated in the land registry, the actual sale price, the nature of the relationship between the purchaser and seller, and the co-ownership status of the property may also affect the outcome of the lawsuit. Therefore, the land registry records and documents concerning the sale must be examined in detail before filing the lawsuit.

Difference Between the Pre-emption Right and Other Rights

Type of Right
Main Characteristic
Statutory Pre-emption Right
A statutory right that allows a co-owner to acquire with priority the share sold by another co-owner to a third party.
Contractual Pre-emption Right
A priority right to purchase arising from a contract concluded between the parties.
Purchase Right
A contractual right that allows the holder, under certain conditions, to demand that ownership of the immovable property be transferred to them.

How Long Does a Pre-emption Right Lawsuit Take?

The duration of the proceedings may vary depending on the nature of the property, the number of parties, the examination of land registry records, disputes concerning the sale price, and the workload of the court. The parties' evidence and expert examinations may also affect the duration of the proceedings.

Since there are forfeiture periods concerning the pre-emption right, the applicable period for filing the lawsuit must not be allowed to expire regardless of how long the proceedings themselves may take.

Legal Assistance in Property Disputes

In a pre-emption right lawsuit, the nature of the sale transaction, land registry records, notification date, and forfeiture periods must be assessed together. In particular, disputes concerning the sale price and determining the co-ownership status may affect the legal aspects of the proceedings. Therefore, it may also be necessary to assess whether the specific case has a connection with different areas of law, such as inheritance law.

In an examination conducted by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun, whether the pre-emption right has arisen, whether the period for filing the lawsuit has expired, and the legal nature of the sale transaction may be assessed together. Examining the land registry records and documents concerning the sale before filing the lawsuit is important for conducting the process properly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Against whom is a pre-emption right lawsuit filed?

The lawsuit is filed against the third party who purchased the share in the property.

How much time is there to exercise the pre-emption right?

The pre-emption right must be exercised within three months from notification of the sale through a notary public and, in all cases, within two years from the date of the sale.

Is the sale price paid in a pre-emption lawsuit?

Yes. In order for a registration decision to be issued, the sale price and the land registry expenses attributable to the purchaser must be deposited within the period determined by the court.

Which court hears a pre-emption right lawsuit?

The lawsuit is generally filed before the Civil Court of First Instance in the place where the property is located.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…