How to File a Commercial Receivables Lawsuit in Turkey

How to File a Commercial Receivables Lawsuit in Turkey
06 Oct

A commercial receivables action seeks judicial recovery of money due from a business relationship. The claim may arise from sale, services, works, distribution, logistics, a current account, or another enterprise contract. Before filing, the legal basis, due date, party identities, and evidence should be established.

Issuing an invoice does not prove every claim by itself. Delivery, performance, acceptance, objections, payment records, and the parties' commercial books should be assessed together. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can compare litigation, enforcement, provisional attachment, and settlement in light of actual collectability.

What Is a Commercial Receivable?

Commercial character may depend on whether the parties are merchants and the transaction concerns their businesses, or whether legislation classifies the dispute as commercial regardless of party status. Not every company claim follows identical procedure; consumer, employment, lease, and intellectual-property disputes may trigger special rules.

Correct classification affects the competent court, mediation route, and interest regime. Advice from a commercial litigation lawyer should examine the entire contract and actual performance rather than only the invoice.

Checks Before Filing

  • Full trade names, MERSİS details, and addresses,
  • Contract, orders, proposals, and standard terms,
  • Proof of delivery or performance,
  • Invoices, e-invoices, dispatch notes, and acceptance records,
  • Maturity, default, and interest provisions,
  • Jurisdiction, arbitration, and governing-law clauses,
  • Payments, set-off, returns, and defect objections,
  • Debtor assets and collection risk.

A claim against the wrong legal entity may be dismissed. Similar trade names, corporate groups, and invoices issued by another entity require care. Authority of the person who signed the agreement can also become disputed.

Maturity and Default

If the contract contains a fixed maturity date, the debt becomes due then and default may arise without a separate notice under the applicable rule. Without an agreed date, the nature of the claim, delivery, invoicing, and notice procedure should be reviewed.

A notarial notice, registered electronic mail, or the contractual notice method may determine default and the start of interest. Not every ordinary email qualifies. Delivery to the addressee and identification of the specific debt must be proven.

Mandatory Commercial Mediation

Article 5/A of the Turkish Commercial Code makes pre-action mediation a condition for commercial receivables and compensation claims concerning payment of a sum of money. If no settlement is reached, the final record should accompany the statement of claim.

The parties and heads of claim should be identified correctly in the application. Adding a materially different demand never presented in mediation may create a procedural objection. Statutory effects on limitation and forfeiture periods should also be monitored.

Competent Court and Venue

Commercial courts of first instance generally hear commercial actions. Where no separate commercial court exists, a designated civil court may sit as a commercial court. A consumer, labour, or other special court may remain competent if the legal relationship falls within its field.

Venue may be based on the defendant's domicile, place of contractual performance, or a valid jurisdiction clause. The scope of a jurisdiction agreement between merchants should be checked. An arbitration clause may lead to an objection if proceedings are filed in court.

Contents of the Statement of Claim

The pleading should provide party details, chronology, contract formation, accrual, performance, maturity, default, payments, and clear relief. Each item of evidence should be connected to the fact it proves and submitted legibly in chronological order.

Principal, accrued interest, interest type, and starting date should be separated. For foreign-currency claims, the requested payment currency and any conversion option require a legal basis. An inconsistent prayer can create fee and judgment problems.

Stage
Primary Step
Main Risk
Before action
Evidence, maturity, debtor review
Wrong party or limitation
Mediation
Identify claims and parties
Missing procedural condition
Action and recovery
Proof, judgment, enforcement
Dissipation of assets

Evidence Commonly Used

  • Signed contract and amendments,
  • Orders, proposals, and confirmations,
  • Invoices, e-invoices, dispatch notes, and delivery records,
  • Email, registered electronic mail, messages, and meeting records,
  • Bank receipts and account movements,
  • Commercial books and electronic accounting data,
  • Defect, return, acceptance, and reconciliation documents,
  • Expert analysis and witness evidence.

Evidence must be lawfully obtained. The context, sender account, and integrity of an email matter. A unilateral account statement does not carry the same evidential value as a reconciliation approved by the other party.

Evidential Value of Commercial Books

Properly kept commercial books may serve as evidence for or against their owner under statutory conditions. Opening and closing approvals, internal consistency, and comparison with the other party's books may be reviewed by an expert.

A ledger entry does not by itself prove delivery of goods that were never delivered. Supporting documents should be connected. Failure to produce books or incomplete production may also have procedural consequences.

Invoices and Account Reconciliation

An invoice generally documents performance of an existing relationship rather than independently creating the contract. Failure to object in time may have evidential consequences for parts of its content, but it does not create a debt that never existed.

Current-account statements, tax reporting data, and electronic reconciliations are assessed with other evidence. The authority of the approving person and any reservation should be checked.

Partial and Unquantified Claims

Claiming part of a debt whose full amount is known differs from an unquantified claim where the amount cannot objectively be determined at filing. Selecting the wrong form can affect interest, limitation, and later increases.

The fact that an amount is disputed does not alone make it unquantified. The court considers whether the claimant could calculate it from available information and documents.

Interest

The applicable interest depends on merchant status, the contract, currency, and default date. A contractual rate must be reviewed for validity and period. Commercial default, advance, and foreign-currency interest do not apply identically in every file.

Accrued interest should be calculated and the continuing-interest start date stated. A calculation that fails to explain how payments were allocated may create expert-review problems.

Provisional Attachment and Interim Protection

Provisional attachment may secure a money claim where the debtor may frustrate recovery. Statutory requirements such as absence of adequate security, maturity, and prima facie proof should be examined.

This measure is not final recovery. The order must be implemented in time and followed by the required enforcement or action; the court may require security. An enforcement lawyer can plan the transition from protective attachment to actual collection.

Proceedings and Expert Review

After pleadings, the court conducts preliminary review, defines the issues, and collects evidence. Accountants or other experts may examine commercial books, current accounts, and interest.

Experts provide technical calculations, not the final legal conclusion. Parties should object in time to errors in data, method, allocation, or interest. A generic objection may not correct an incomplete report.

Enforcement of the Judgment

A money judgment may be enforced through judgment-based execution. Appeal does not always suspend enforcement automatically; the debtor may seek a stay under its conditions. Bank accounts, movables, immovables, and receivables from third parties may be investigated.

Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can build the litigation strategy around the debtor's assets and expected defences. A Turkish company law review helps identify the correct obligor in corporate groups, representation disputes, and security arrangements.

Defences and Counterclaims

The defendant may argue that no debt arose, performance was defective or incomplete, payment or set-off occurred, the claim was assigned, or limitation expired. The facts and evidence supporting each defence should be submitted within the period for the statement of defence. Later evidence may be restricted by procedural rules.

A set-off defence or counterclaim may arise where the defendant has a claim from the same relationship. Maturity, currency, and whether the cross-claim is disputed should be considered. For defective performance, timely inspection, notice, and the chosen remedies are important.

How Is Limitation Checked?

There is no single limitation period for every commercial receivable. Different periods apply according to contract type, nature of the claim, party status, and special legislation. Ordinary contract claims, transport, commission, insurance, and negotiable-instrument claims do not necessarily expire at the same time.

The starting point is often connected to maturity. Acknowledgment, partial payment, litigation, or enforcement may affect the running of time under the applicable rules. The mediation and filing timetable should be planned safely before expiry.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an invoice enough to win?

Not always. It should be supported by the contract, delivery or performance, and other commercial records.

May the action be filed without mediation?

Pre-action mediation is generally required for a commercial claim seeking payment of a sum of money.

Is litigation or enforcement better?

The answer depends on the debt document, expected objection, collection risk, and the need for interim protection.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…