Under What Conditions Can an Heir Be Disinherited?

Under What Conditions Can an Heir Be Disinherited?

Disinheritance is a testamentary disposition that allows the deceased to deprive an heir with a reserved share of inheritance rights when the statutory conditions are satisfied. Under Article 510 of the Turkish Civil Code, an heir may be disinherited if the heir commits a serious crime against the deceased or a person close to the deceased, or seriously fails to perform obligations arising from family law.

Disinheritance cannot be made merely because the deceased wishes it or without stating a reason. The ground must be one recognized by law and must be clearly stated in the testamentary disposition. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can assess whether the alleged ground meets the statutory conditions and whether the disposition satisfies formal validity requirements.

What Is Disinheritance?

Disinheritance is a disposition intended to remove all, or in a special statutory situation part, of the inheritance rights of an heir with a reserved share. It may also be described as exclusion from inheritance.

To the extent the disinheritance is valid, the excluded person does not receive a share of the estate. The rights of that person’s descendants, however, must be assessed separately. Disputes of this kind are generally examined under inheritance law.

Under What Conditions May an Heir Be Disinherited?

Article 510 of the Turkish Civil Code provides two principal grounds for punitive disinheritance: committing a serious crime against the deceased or a close person, and seriously failing to perform obligations arising from family law.

  • The heir commits a serious crime against the deceased or a person close to the deceased.
  • The heir seriously fails to perform family-law obligations owed to the deceased or members of the deceased’s family.
  • The ground is stated in the testamentary disposition.
  • The disinheritance is made in a form permitted by law.

Disinheritance Because of a Serious Crime

If an heir has committed a serious crime against the deceased or a person close to the deceased, the deceased may disinherit that person. Not every criminal offence automatically constitutes a sufficient ground.

The nature of the act, the circumstances, and the relationship between the parties must be assessed to determine whether the statutory threshold is met.

Serious Breach of Family-Law Obligations

Disinheritance may arise where an heir seriously fails to perform obligations owed under family law to the deceased or members of the deceased’s family. Depending on the facts, a serious breach of duties of assistance, care, or similar obligations may qualify.

An ordinary family disagreement or estrangement is not sufficient on its own. The breach must reach the level of seriousness required by law.

How Is Disinheritance Made Through a Will?

Disinheritance must be made through a testamentary disposition. The deceased must therefore use a will or another form of testamentary disposition permitted by law.

The ground must be stated clearly. A failure to state it, or reliance on a ground that does not satisfy the statutory requirements, may lead to a dispute. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can provide legal support when preparing a will or reviewing an existing disposition for these requirements.

Must the Ground for Disinheritance Be Stated?

Yes. Under Article 512 of the Turkish Civil Code, disinheritance is valid only if the deceased states the ground in the testamentary disposition.

If the disinherited person challenges the decision, the heir or legatee who benefits from it bears the burden of proving that the stated ground actually existed.

Can the Disinherited Person’s Descendants Inherit?

Unless the deceased provides otherwise, the share of the disinherited person is treated as though that person died before the deceased. The disinherited person’s descendants may therefore become heirs.

Those descendants may also claim their reserved shares within the conditions established by law.

Disinheritance Because of Insolvency

Article 513 of the Turkish Civil Code provides a special form of disinheritance based on insolvency. A descendant against whom an official certificate of insolvency exists may be disinherited for one half of the descendant’s reserved share.

That half must be allocated to the existing and future children of the disinherited person. The law also contains special rules concerning the status of the insolvency certificate when the succession opens.

Are Disinheritance and Unworthiness to Inherit the Same?

No. Disinheritance results from a testamentary disposition made by the deceased. Unworthiness to inherit arises directly by law when one of the acts listed in the statute occurs.

For example, a person who intentionally and unlawfully kills or attempts to kill the deceased may, if the statutory conditions are met, be unworthy to inherit. This is distinct from disinheritance.

Can a Disinherited Person Challenge the Decision?

Yes. A disinherited person may argue that the statutory conditions were not met and seek a legal remedy. Failure to state the ground, the nonexistence of the alleged ground, or invalidity of the will may all become subjects of dispute.

If the ground cannot be proved, Article 512 provides that the disposition is carried out only beyond the heir’s reserved share. Disinheritance may also be invalid where the deceased acted under a clear mistake about the alleged ground. Attorney Mehmet Kurşun can identify the appropriate cancellation or reduction remedy in light of the particular facts.

Which Court Hears a Disinheritance Dispute?

Depending on the nature of the claim, disputes arising from disinheritance are heard by the Civil Court of First Instance. Court of Cassation practice recognizes that the effect of disinheritance on heirship status must be examined by that court in contentious proceedings.

Territorial jurisdiction is determined by considering the deceased’s last residence and the special rules applicable to inheritance disputes. Whether an alternative dispute-resolution method such as mediation is available must also be considered in light of the dispute.

Disinheritance and Renunciation of Inheritance Compared

Criterion
Disinheritance
Renunciation
How is it made?
Through a testamentary disposition by the deceased.
Through an agreement between the deceased and the heir.
Ground
A statutory ground for disinheritance must exist.
The parties’ agreement is decisive.
Legal result
The heir’s inheritance right ends within the statutory conditions.
The renouncing heir loses heirship status.

Important Points

  • Disinheritance is possible only when a statutory condition exists.
  • The ground must be clearly stated in the testamentary disposition.
  • Not every family disagreement constitutes a ground.
  • The rights of the disinherited person’s descendants require separate assessment.
  • Disinheritance for insolvency is subject to the special conditions of Article 513.
  • The will or other testamentary disposition must comply with formal requirements.
  • The disinherited person may seek legal remedies by alleging that the statutory conditions were not met.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a child be disinherited?

Yes. Having a reserved share does not absolutely prevent a child from being disinherited, but one of the grounds in Article 510 must exist.

Can disinheritance be made by will?

Yes. It may be made through a testamentary disposition, and the ground must be stated in that disposition.

Can the disinherited person’s children inherit?

Yes. Subject to the statutory conditions, the descendants may inherit as though the disinherited person had died before the deceased.

Can disinheritance be cancelled?

Legal remedies may be sought where the conditions did not exist or the will is invalid. Depending on the facts, cancellation or reduction may be available.

Related resources: Title Deed Cancellation Lawyer.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…