Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026
In a traffic accident, the fault rate is determined according to which breach of a traffic rule caused the accident. Highway Traffic Law (KTK) Art. 84 lists 12 situations as primary fault, such as running a red light, a rear-end collision, encroaching on a lane and failing to observe right of way at a junction. In an agreed report, insurers give only 0%, 50% or 100% and rely on SBM's accident scenarios. A police report does not state a rate; it states which rule was breached. In court and arbitration, an expert may determine intermediate rates such as 75% to 25%. A driver who hits another vehicle from behind is, as a rule, 100% at fault. However, if the vehicle in front reversed, or stopped suddenly where stopping is prohibited, the rate changes.
Where to find out your fault rate is explained in detail in our article checking your fault rate and accident report, and the routes of objection in our article objecting to the accident report and fault rate.
Primary fault is the breach of a rule that is the main cause of the accident. Secondary fault is a breach that contributed to the accident but did not cause it on its own. Highway Traffic Law Art. 84 and Highway Traffic Regulation Art. 157 treat a driver as primarily at fault in the following situations.
The Regulation also provides an exception. A driver who was forced to breach a basic rule because of another driver's or a pedestrian's unlawful movement, or a vehicle's technical failure, and who was involved in the accident despite taking all precautions, cannot be regarded as primarily at fault (Regulation Art. 157).
The law does not list secondary faults one by one. Breaches not listed in Art. 84, such as exceeding the speed limit, driving drunk or tired, or not using lights, are as a rule considered secondary fault. If the speeding is very serious, the result may change: the Court of Cassation accepted that a driver who entered a junction with a 30 km/h limit at night at more than four times the limit had removed the possibility for a vehicle coming from a side road to avoid the accident (12th Criminal Chamber, E.2021/7843, K.2025/4995, 28.05.2025).
Primary fault shows that the largest share of the fault lies with that driver; it does not show the whole rate. The Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber upheld a judgment based on an expert report giving the insured driver 75% for primary fault and the other driver, who did not comply with the overtaking rules, 25% for secondary fault (E.2025/5401, K.2025/17415, 25.12.2025). If both drivers committed a breach counted as primary fault, the rates are usually equalised.
The fault rate directly determines the compensation you will receive. For example, if your loss is TRY 200,000 and your fault is 25%, you can claim TRY 150,000 from the other party. Which loss is paid from which insurance at rates of 0%, 50% and 100% is shown in a table in our inquiry article.
Who determines fault depends on who drew up the report and where the dispute is taken.
| Stage | Who determines | Which rates | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agreed report (property damage only, drivers agreed) | The parties' insurers; if they cannot agree, the commission within SBM | Only 0%, 50%, 100% | Circular No. 2017/18; the report, sketch, photographs and SBM accident scenarios |
| Police or gendarmerie report | No rate is written in the report, only which rule was breached; the rate is set by the insurer, and in a dispute by an expert | Depending on the case | Regulation Art. 156 |
| Insurance Arbitration Commission or civil court | An expert; if reports conflict, university faculty members, the technical board of the General Directorate of Highways or the Forensic Medicine Institute | Including intermediate rates such as 75% to 25% or 60% to 40% | Code of Civil Procedure Art. 266 |
| Criminal case | The expert in the criminal file | Primary and secondary fault | The civil judge is not bound by the criminal court's assessment of fault (Code of Obligations Art. 74) |
An agreed report cannot be drawn up in every accident. The report is drawn up by law enforcement if one of the drivers is suspected of alcohol or drugs, has no driving licence or one not appropriate to the vehicle class, if one of the vehicles has no traffic insurance, if a public body's vehicle was involved, if public property or third parties' belongings were damaged, if anyone was injured or killed, and in single-vehicle accidents (Circular 2017/18, Art. 1.2).
A driver being shown as "primarily and fully at fault" in the report is also not enough for compensation to be determined at that rate. Arbitration and the courts are not bound by the report; they redetermine fault with an expert report. That is why evidence such as camera footage, photographs and witnesses can change the rate.
In an agreed report, insurers determine fault on the basis of the Property Damage Accident Scenarios published by the Insurance Information and Monitoring Centre (SBM). The most common situations are:
| Type of accident | Party at fault and rate | SBM situation no. |
|---|---|---|
| Hitting the vehicle in front from behind without keeping a safe following distance | The vehicle hitting from behind 100% | 1A, 9 |
| The vehicle in front stops suddenly where stopping is prohibited, and the one behind hits it | 50% – 50% | 1B |
| The vehicle in front reverses and hits the vehicle behind | The reversing vehicle 100% | 1C |
| Passing on a red light | The one passing on red 100% | 2 |
| Both drivers say their light was green | 50% – 50% | 4 |
| Pulling out from a side road onto a main road without observing right of way | The one pulling onto the main road 100% | 6 |
| Crossing into the opposite lane | The one crossing into the opposite lane 100% | 7 |
| Failing to give way at a junction to a vehicle coming from the right | The one failing to give way 100% | 13 |
| Neither vehicle keeps to the far right lane and each enters the other's lane | 50% – 50% | 14, 19 |
| Hitting a vehicle turning correctly at a roundabout | The one hitting 100% | 33A, 33B |
| Overtaking without waiting for an oncoming vehicle | The overtaking vehicle 100% | 20 |
| Not slowing down when approaching a junction | The one not slowing down 100% | 23 |
| Failing to give way to traffic when leaving an area such as a car park, housing estate or petrol station | The exiting vehicle 100% | 25 |
| Breaching the lane change rule and using two lanes at once | The one breaching the lane 100% | 26 |
| Hitting a vehicle parked in accordance with the rules | The one hitting 100% | 27 |
| Opening a door in front of moving traffic | The one opening the door 100% | 35 |
| A load or part falling from a moving vehicle | The vehicle whose load fell 100% | 46 |
| Making an uncontrolled U-turn | The one making the U-turn 100% | 47 |
| Entering the wrong way | The one entering the wrong way 100% | 48 |
| Chain collision | Each collision is assessed separately; each vehicle hitting the one in front from behind 100% | 30, 31 |
| Four or more vehicles | Insurers determine freely according to the type of accident | 36–42 |
This table is the standard insurers apply in agreed reports. Arbitration and the courts are not bound by this table; depending on the details of the event, an expert may determine different and intermediate rates.
As a rule, yes. Hitting from behind is counted as primary fault in KTK Art. 84. The driver behind must keep a following distance, taking into account that the vehicle in front may stop suddenly (KTK Art. 56/1-c). In the SBM scenarios too, the driver hitting from behind is accepted as 100% at fault.
However, a rear-end collision does not always mean full fault:
An example from the Court of Cassation: a driver who squeezed another vehicle into the right lane on a motorway and stopped suddenly in the lane was accepted as the main cause of the accident, that is, primarily at fault. The tow-truck driver who came from behind and hit them was regarded as secondarily at fault (12th Criminal Chamber, E.2025/7497, K.2025/9070, 22.12.2025). The one hitting from behind was not completely relieved of liability, but their fault remained secondary.
If you are the one who hit from behind and the vehicle in front suddenly changed lanes or stopped without reason, have this written in the report. If only the "rear-end collision" box is ticked in the report, insurers will most likely give you 100% fault. Dashcam footage is the strongest evidence in these files.
Failing to observe right of way at a junction is primary fault. If there are no traffic lights or officer, the driver coming from the minor road must give way to the vehicle on the main road, and on equal roads to the vehicle coming from the right (KTK Art. 57). Every driver is also obliged to reduce speed when approaching a junction.
This obligation may also make the driver on the priority road liable. In a file where neither driver slowed down at an uncontrolled junction, the Court of Cassation found justified an expert report giving 75% fault to the moped rider who did not observe right of way and 25% to the car driver. It reversed an arbitral award that calculated compensation by treating the car driver as 100% at fault (4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/7278, K.2025/14294, 16.10.2025). Excessive speed by the driver on the main road also changes the rate; the 12th Criminal Chamber judgment mentioned in the secondary fault section is an example of this.
Drivers must give pedestrians priority at pedestrian crossings without traffic lights (KTK Art. 74). Pedestrians, too, must use the footway and pedestrian crossings and must not step carelessly into the carriageway (KTK Art. 68).
As regards a pedestrian hit on a pedestrian crossing, fault as a rule lies with the driver. A pedestrian who suddenly steps into the road outside a pedestrian crossing or from between parked vehicles may also be given fault; in that case, the pedestrian's compensation is reduced in proportion to their own fault. Since the report in accidents involving pedestrians is drawn up by law enforcement, SBM scenarios do not apply; the rate is determined by an expert.
No report states a rate. In an agreed report, drivers tick their own manoeuvre from a 15-item list and draw the sketch and the first point of impact; the insurers determine the rate and notify it by SMS or e-mail. A police report states which driver breached which rule (Regulation Art. 156).
It means the two drivers caused the accident equally. Half of each party's damage is paid by the other party's traffic insurance, and the remaining half can only be claimed from kasko. A detailed table is in our article checking your fault rate and accident report.
Yes, in proportion to the other party's fault. For example, a driver 75% primarily at fault can claim 25% of their loss from the other party's traffic insurance; the remainder is covered by kasko, if they have it.
There is no fixed formula. Which breach caused the accident is determined using the report, the sketch, the first point of impact, photographs of the damage, camera footage and witness statements. In an agreed report, this assessment is converted to 0%, 50% or 100% using the SBM scenarios; in a dispute, the expert gives a rate according to the weight of the primary and secondary fault.
Each collision is assessed separately; each vehicle that hit the one in front from behind is considered 100% at fault for that collision. In accidents involving four or more vehicles, insurers determine the rates according to the type of accident (SBM 30, 31, 36–42).
Compensation claims, arbitration and litigation based on the fault rate are explained in detail on our traffic accident compensation lawyer page.
Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer in Istanbul who runs his own law office and practises in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He is a graduate of Marmara University Faculty of Law. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.
This article is for general information purposes. The fault rate is determined according to the circumstances of each accident.