Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun · Last updated: 30 October 2026
Vehicle diminished value (değer kaybı) is calculated by deducting the vehicle's second-hand market value after repair from its undamaged second-hand market value immediately before the accident. The difference is multiplied by the other party's fault rate and claimed from the insurer up to the compulsory traffic insurance limit for property damage per vehicle. Since 1 July 2026, the coefficient-based formula in the General Conditions of compulsory traffic insurance has been abolished; the insurer, the Insurance Arbitration Commission and the courts now all apply the same "market value difference" method.
What diminished value is, under which conditions and from whom it can be claimed is explained on our diminished value claim page. This article focuses only on the calculation itself: the formula, the judgments it is based on, worked examples and the mistakes that produce wrong results. Loss of use compensation, claimed for the period during which the vehicle cannot be used while under repair, is a separate item from diminished value.
Formula: Diminished value = Undamaged second-hand value before the accident − Second-hand value after repair.
Fault: Amount that can be claimed = Diminished value × Other party's fault rate.
Limit: Repair costs and diminished value are paid from the same cover; in 2026 this cover is TRY 400,000 per vehicle.
Date: The calculation is made using market values on the accident date.
No fixed rate: Diminished value is not a set percentage of the repair cost or of the vehicle's value; the Court of Cassation considers percentage-based calculations unverifiable.
| Element | What it means | How it is determined |
|---|---|---|
| Undamaged second-hand value before the accident | The price at which the vehicle could have been sold on the second-hand market immediately before the accident, in its condition on that day | Sale values on the accident date of comparable vehicles of the same make, model, trim, year and mileage |
| Second-hand value after repair | The price at which the same vehicle can be sold in its repaired state with the damage record registered | Comparable vehicles with similar parts replaced or repainted; the location and extent of the damage |
| Other party's fault rate | The fault attributed to the other driver in the accident | Accident report, and an expert fault report if necessary |
| Policy limit | The maximum property damage the traffic insurance will pay per vehicle | TRY 400,000 under policies in force in 2026 |
The vehicle's make, age, mileage and previous damage do not enter the formula as separate coefficients. They are already reflected in the two market values.
With the amendment published in Official Gazette No. 33278 of 12 June 2026, Annex 1 on the calculation of diminished value in the General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance was repealed. The amendment entered into force on 1 July 2026.
| Issue | Before 1 July 2026 | After 1 July 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Calculation method | The formula in Annex 1 of the General Conditions: a calculation multiplying the vehicle's value by damage-extent and mileage coefficients (not binding on the courts) | The difference between second-hand sale values before the accident and after repair |
| Who calculates | The insurer and its loss adjuster, according to the formula | An insurance loss adjuster appointed under the procedure to be set by SEDDK (Insurance and Private Pension Regulation and Supervision Agency); the amount is shown separately in the adjuster's report |
| Factors taken into account | Coefficient tables | Make, age, model, level of use, damaged parts, previous damage history |
| Application | Diminished value had to be claimed separately | A person applying for vehicle damage is deemed to have also claimed diminished value |
| Notification | This rule was introduced by the 2026 amendment | The insurer notifies the amount within the business day after the final adjuster's report reaches it |
Since 2020, judicial authorities have applied the market value difference instead of the formula; the 2026 amendment brought insurers' practice into line with this approach.
Constitutional Court, E.2019/40, K.2020/40, 17.07.2020: It annulled the references to the General Conditions in Articles 90 and 92 of the Highway Traffic Law. As a result, compensation came to be determined not according to the calculation tables in the General Conditions, but according to the provisions of the Code of Obligations based on actual loss.
Constitutional Court, E.2021/82, K.2022/167, 29.12.2022 (Official Gazette 14.02.2023, No. 32104): It also annulled the sentence added to Article 90 of the Highway Traffic Law by Law No. 7327 in 2021, which listed the criteria for calculating diminished value. The reasoning was that these rules might not compensate the injured party's actual loss.
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/21252, K.2022/5913, 25.03.2022: Stating that the real difference between second-hand market values before the accident and after repair must be used for diminished value, it reversed, in the interest of the law, a judgment based on the formula in the General Conditions. The Chamber accepted that the Constitutional Court's annulment also applies to pending cases.
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/3822, K.2024/10404, 05.11.2024: It stated that the calculation must take into account the painted areas and the characteristics of the damaged parts, and that percentage-based calculations are not verifiable.
Insurance Arbitration Commission Appeal Board, 2026/İHK-22659, 17.03.2026: It accepted that the calculation methods in the General Conditions cannot be used directly because of the annulment decisions.
As a result, the debate is no longer about the method but about how accurately the two market values are determined. Most disputes arise from the comparable vehicles chosen and the assessment of previous damage.
The calculation is made in five steps; the result of each step is the input for the next.
Find the pre-accident value. Collect the prices, on the accident date, of comparable vehicles with no damage record of the same make, model, trim, model year and similar mileage as your vehicle. An asking price is not a sale price; the negotiation margin is deducted.
Find the post-repair value. Among the same comparables, look at the prices of vehicles with parts replaced or repainted in a similar area to your vehicle. Repairs to load-bearing areas such as the chassis, pillars or roof reduce value more than repairs to bolt-on panels.
Take the difference. Deduct the post-repair value from the pre-accident value. This is the total diminished value of your vehicle.
Apply the fault rate. Multiply the total diminished value by the other party's fault rate. If the other party is 100% at fault, the whole amount is claimed; if 75% at fault, three quarters.
Check the limit. Add the repair cost calculated according to fault and the diminished value. If the total exceeds the per-vehicle property damage limit of the other vehicle's traffic insurance (TRY 400,000 in 2026), the excess cannot be recovered from the traffic insurance.
The figures below are hypothetical; they are intended to illustrate the method.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Vehicle | 2021 passenger car, 68,000 km, no previous damage record |
| Accident | 10 September 2026, Istanbul; repair and paint of the left rear door and rear quarter panel, replacement of the rear bumper |
| Repair cost | TRY 92,000 |
| Undamaged second-hand value before the accident | TRY 1,180,000 |
| Second-hand value after repair | TRY 1,090,000 |
| Fault | Other driver 75%, vehicle owner 25% |
Calculation:
Total diminished value: 1,180,000 − 1,090,000 = TRY 90,000
Diminished value claimable from the traffic insurance: 90,000 × 0.75 = TRY 67,500
Repair cost at the same fault rate: 92,000 × 0.75 = TRY 69,000
Total claimed from the traffic insurance: 67,500 + 69,000 = TRY 136,500; since it is below the TRY 400,000 limit, the whole amount can be claimed from the traffic insurance.
In this example the diminished value came out close to the repair cost. The reason is that the damage is on the rear quarter panel: second-hand buyers view quarter panel repairs more negatively than the replacement of bolt-on parts.
For high-value vehicles, damage and diminished value together can easily exceed the traffic insurance limit.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Vehicle | 2024 SUV, 25,000 km |
| Fault | Other driver 100% |
| Repair cost | TRY 310,000 |
| Undamaged second-hand value before the accident | TRY 5,200,000 |
| Second-hand value after repair | TRY 4,880,000 |
Calculation:
Diminished value: 5,200,000 − 4,880,000 = TRY 320,000
Total property damage: 310,000 + 320,000 = TRY 630,000
Part covered by the traffic insurance: TRY 400,000
Part not covered by the traffic insurance: TRY 230,000
The excess TRY 230,000 is not lost. If the other vehicle has an excess (voluntary) liability (İMM) policy, this part can be claimed from the insurer issuing that policy, or from the driver and the vehicle's operator. Whom to apply to when the limit is exceeded is explained on our compensation claim against an insurance company page.
Previous damage does not automatically reduce diminished value to zero; however, since it already lowers the pre-accident value, it may narrow the difference between the two values. The regional courts of appeal are not aligned on this issue:
Ankara Regional Court of Appeal 35th Civil Chamber, E.2025/17, K.2026/132, 29.01.2026: It set aside a diminished value judgment given without examining the nature of the previous damage. In other words, previous damage is an input to the calculation, not a reason not to make it.
Antalya Regional Court of Appeal 13th Civil Chamber, E.2024/1685, K.2026/1029, 06.07.2026: It accepted that a diminished value claim may be rejected for a vehicle with a similar damage and repair history in the same area.
For this reason, the part affected by previous damage, its extent and how it was repaired should be documented. A minor earlier damage in a different area and a heavy repair to the same part affect the calculation very differently.
Most diminished value disputes arise from the same mistakes:
Treating diminished value as a percentage of the repair cost. Rates such as "20% of the damage" have no legal basis; the Court of Cassation finds percentage-based calculations unverifiable.
Calculating with the old Annex 1 coefficients. The coefficient formula was removed from the General Conditions on 1 July 2026; even before that, it did not bind the courts or arbitration.
Treating the asking price as the sale price. A realistic sale price is used for both the pre-accident and the post-repair value; a single high listing inflates the calculation.
Using today's prices. The calculation is made with values on the accident date. Loss caused by delay is compensated with interest, not by increasing the diminished value.
Forgetting the fault rate or applying it twice. The fault deduction is made once, on the total diminished value; reducing the comparable prices according to fault as well is a double deduction.
Overlooking that the limit is shared. Repair costs and diminished value are paid from the same property damage cover; the repair payment may already have used part of the limit.
Under the 2026 rule, the diminished value amount appears separately in the adjuster's report. Before accepting the offer, check these points in the report:
Are the comparables used for the pre-accident value of the same model year, trim and similar mileage as your vehicle?
Do the comparable prices relate to a period close to the accident date?
In the post-repair value, is it correct which parts are counted as replaced and which as painted?
Are previous damage records matched to the correct part, or has damage in a different area been used as a reason for a deduction?
Is the fault rate applied in the report the same as the rate in the accident report?
Are diminished value and repair cost shown as separate items?
If there is an error in any of these points, the routes to follow in case of underpayment or rejection are on our compensation claim against an insurance company page. You can find how to object to the report on which the insurer bases its calculation in our article objecting to the loss adjuster's report, and the documents and order of the application in our article vehicle diminished value application. Even after 1 July 2026, residual diminished value has been calculated in our applications to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. Therefore, it should by no means be assumed that the diminished value calculated by the adjuster and paid by the insurer is full and complete.
Online calculators give at most a rough idea; their results do not replace an adjuster's or a court expert's report. Some calculators work on the logic of the old formula, multiplying the vehicle's value and mileage by coefficients; this logic is no longer used even in insurance practice.
In the market value difference method, what determines the result is the comparable vehicles chosen. A figure produced by a calculator without entering comparable prices does not reflect your vehicle's market. Markets are also dynamic and fast-moving. For example, the price considered to be the market value of the vehicle on the accident date may rise or fall considerably even within a week, depending on the country's current conditions. We therefore recommend proceeding on the basis that these calculators cannot produce accurate results.
There is no fixed percentage. The same repair cost may produce very different diminished values in vehicles of different models and mileage. In its judgment of 05.11.2024, the Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber found percentage-based calculations unverifiable.
Insurers may make offers for these accidents based on the General Conditions in force on the accident date. If the dispute is taken to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or to court, the market value difference is applied. The İzmir Regional Court of Appeal 11th Civil Chamber (E.2024/100, K.2026/970, 05.06.2026) accepted that the General Conditions on the policy date do not change this result.
Yes. The amount depends not on the repair cost but on the fall in market value. A repair to load-bearing areas, or one regarded as serious by buyers, can produce a diminished value exceeding the repair cost even if the cost is low.
Prices on the accident date. The General Conditions use the second-hand sale value "before the accident date", and the Court of Cassation uses the undamaged value on the accident date. Even if prices rise later, the diminished value does not increase; interest is claimed for the delay.
Half. For example, with a diminished value of TRY 80,000, TRY 40,000 can be claimed from the other party's traffic insurance. Half of the other vehicle's diminished value is also paid by your vehicle's traffic insurance.
Under the General Conditions in force from 1 July 2026, a person applying to the traffic insurance for vehicle damage is deemed to have also claimed diminished value. Still, stating diminished value expressly in the application makes it easier to check whether it has been calculated as a separate item in the adjuster's report.
With the same method: the post-repair second-hand value is deducted from the undamaged pre-accident second-hand value and the result is multiplied by the other party's fault rate. The difference is that the comparables must also be motorcycles; the prices of motorcycles of the same make, model, engine capacity and mileage are used. Damage to load-bearing parts such as the frame, fork and engine block reduces value more than damage to body and plastic parts.
Legislation
Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, Arts. 85 and 90
Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Arts. 49–51
General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance, A.5/a (amendment published in Official Gazette No. 33278 of 12.06.2026; in force 01.07.2026)
SEDDK announcement on traffic insurance cover amounts applicable in 2026 (December 2025)
Judgments
Constitutional Court, E.2019/40, K.2020/40, 17.07.2020
Constitutional Court, E.2021/82, K.2022/167, 29.12.2022 (OG 14.02.2023, No. 32104)
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2021/21252, K.2022/5913, 25.03.2022
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2024/3822, K.2024/10404, 05.11.2024
Insurance Arbitration Commission Appeal Board, 2026/İHK-22659, 17.03.2026
Ankara Regional Court of Appeal 35th Civil Chamber, E.2025/17, K.2026/132, 29.01.2026
Antalya Regional Court of Appeal 13th Civil Chamber, E.2024/1685, K.2026/1029, 06.07.2026
İzmir Regional Court of Appeal 11th Civil Chamber, E.2024/100, K.2026/970, 05.06.2026
Att. Mehmet Emin Kurşun is a lawyer practising in Istanbul in traffic accident, comprehensive (kasko) insurance and insurance disputes. He handles insurance applications, Insurance Arbitration Commission proceedings and compensation lawsuits.
This article is for general information purposes. The diminished value of a vehicle is assessed separately according to the specific features of that vehicle and accident.