The Offence of Issuing and Using False Invoices

The Offence of Issuing and Using False Invoices
05 Oct

The offense of issuing and using fake invoices is one of the tax evasion offenses regulated under paragraph (b) of Article 359 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213. Issuing an invoice or another tax document as if a transaction or situation existed when no genuine transaction or situation actually exists, or using a fake document, constitutes a criminal offense when the conditions specified by law are met.

With regard to fake invoices, also referred to in practice as "fraudulent invoices," merely claiming that an invoice does not reflect the truth is not sufficient. Whether the invoice is based on a genuine commercial or economic transaction, the activities of the persons who issued and used the invoice, payment and delivery records, commercial books, and other evidence are evaluated together.

What Is a Fake Invoice?

Under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law, a document issued as if a transaction or situation existed when no genuine transaction or situation exists is considered a fake document. Therefore, issuing an invoice as if a sale of goods or provision of services had actually taken place when no such transaction occurred may be considered the issuance of a fake document.

For example, issuing an invoice as if a sale of goods had taken place between companies even though no goods were actually delivered may, if the other circumstances of the specific case are also present, give rise to the offense of issuing a fake invoice.

Under Which Law Is the Offense of Issuing and Using Fake Invoices Regulated?

The acts of issuing and using fake invoices are regulated under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law. The law penalizes the preparation, in whole or in part, of fake documents that must be kept, issued, preserved, and submitted pursuant to tax laws, as well as the use of such documents.

This offense is subject to a different legal framework from the general document forgery offenses regulated under the Turkish Penal Code. The primary protected legal interest under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law is the protection of the tax system and tax revenues.

Elements of the Offense of Issuing a Fake Invoice

For the offense of issuing a fake invoice, there must first be a document that is required to be issued and preserved under tax laws. Whether the document is based on a genuine commercial or economic transaction is important in assessing the offense.

Issuing a document as if a transaction had taken place when no genuine transaction occurred is the fundamental example of a fake document. However, the mere fact that an invoice is considered suspicious during a tax inspection may not, by itself, be sufficient for a criminal conviction. Whether the underlying transaction actually occurred must be investigated through concrete evidence.

Offense of Using a Fake Invoice

The use of a fake invoice refers to the use in tax proceedings of a fake document issued by another person or previously created by the offender. The manner in which the document was incorporated into a tax return or commercial records may be important in assessing the case.

In its decision dated October 2, 2024, the Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation addressed the nature of the acts of issuing and using fake documents under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law as alternative acts constituting the offense, and stated that where the acts of issuing and using are carried out together within the scope of the same offense, separate penalties should not be imposed for each act. Nevertheless, the specific circumstances of the case and acts occurring in different periods must be evaluated separately.

Difference Between a Fake Invoice and a Misleading Document in Terms of Content

A fake document and a document misleading in terms of its content are different from each other. In a document misleading in terms of its content regulated under Article 359/a of the Tax Procedure Law, there is a genuine transaction or situation, but its nature or amount is represented contrary to the truth.

In the case of a fake document, however, no genuine transaction or situation exists, yet a document is issued as if one existed. This distinction is important in determining the applicable penalty.

Type of Document / Act
Main Characteristic and Penalty
Issuing a fake document
Issuing a document as if a genuine transaction or situation existed when none existed; imprisonment from 3 to 8 years under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law.
Using a fake document
Using a fake document in tax proceedings; imprisonment from 3 to 8 years under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law.
Document misleading in terms of its content
A genuine transaction exists, but its nature or amount is represented contrary to the truth; imprisonment from 18 months to 5 years under Article 359/a of the Tax Procedure Law.

What Is the Penalty for Issuing a Fake Invoice?

Under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law, persons who issue documents that are wholly or partially fake or who use such documents are subject to imprisonment from 3 to 8 years. This penalty range has been in force following the amendment introduced by Law No. 7394 in 2022.

The penalty applicable in a specific case is determined according to the nature of the act, the defendant's intent, the periods in which the acts were committed, and the evidence contained in the case file. Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law also contains a special provision concerning Article 43 of the Turkish Penal Code for acts committed during more than one calendar year or taxation period within the execution of a single decision to commit the same offense.

Is Using a Fake Invoice Without Knowing It Is Fake a Crime?

Using an invoice without knowing that it is fake is not assessed in the same manner as knowingly using a fake invoice in tax proceedings. In terms of criminal liability, it must be established whether the offender had criminal intent.

Therefore, the subsequent determination that an invoice was fake does not automatically mean that the person who used the invoice is guilty. Matters such as why the invoice was obtained, whether the commercial relationship was genuine, whether payment was made, whether the goods or services were delivered, and whether the person knew about the forgery are examined together.

How Is the Offense of Using a Fake Invoice Proven?

In allegations involving fake invoices, relying solely on a tax technical report prepared regarding the issuer of the invoice may not be sufficient in every case for evidentiary purposes. Whether the alleged commercial transaction underlying the invoice actually took place must be specifically investigated.

In this context, bank transactions, payment records, delivery notes, delivery documents, inventory records, commercial books, contracts, e-invoice records, statements of company employees and the parties, and, where necessary, expert examination may be important. For a conviction in criminal proceedings, it must be established through conclusive and convincing evidence beyond any reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the offense.

Intent in the Offense of Issuing a Fake Invoice

In the offense of issuing or using a fake invoice, the nature of the offender's act and criminal intent are important. In particular, whether the person who used the fake invoice knew that the invoice was not based on a genuine commercial transaction must be assessed based on the specific circumstances of the case.

Being a company executive, shareholder, manager, or person responsible for accounting transactions is not, by itself, sufficient for a conviction for the offense of using fake invoices. The evidence establishing the person's connection to the offense and intent concerning the act must be evaluated.

Effective Remorse in the Offense of Using Fake Invoices

An amendment made to Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law in 2022 introduced a special provision allowing for a reduction in the penalty when certain conditions are met. Depending on the determination that tax loss has occurred, payment of the entire assessed tax, default interest, and late payment surcharge, together with half of the imposed penalties and the corresponding late payment surcharge, may provide a penalty reduction under certain conditions.

If these amounts are paid during the investigation stage, the sentence may be reduced by one-half, while payment until the judgment is rendered during the prosecution stage may result in a one-third reduction. In cases where there is no assessed tax or penalty dependent on the principal tax, a one-half reduction is also provided under the conditions prescribed by law. There are also additional conditions concerning tax litigation and legal remedies for benefiting from this provision.

Is a Tax Penalty Also Imposed in the Offense of Using Fake Invoices?

The imposition of imprisonment under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law does not prevent the separate imposition of a tax loss penalty under tax legislation. Therefore, criminal proceedings and assessments and tax penalties carried out by the tax administration may arise as separate legal processes due to the same incident.

Whether the assessment and tax penalty imposed following a tax inspection comply with the law may also be disputed separately before the tax courts. Since the defense in the criminal case and the dispute before the tax court may involve different aspects, it is important to evaluate the case files together.

Investigation and Trial Process in the Offense of Issuing and Using Fake Invoices

An allegation of issuing or using a fake invoice may arise as a result of a tax inspection. Following the tax inspection and the relevant reports, criminal proceedings may commence upon a criminal complaint being filed with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office.

If it is determined at the end of the investigation that sufficient suspicion exists, a public prosecution may be initiated. In criminal proceedings, whether the invoices are genuine, whether the commercial transactions actually occurred, the defendant's role and intent in the acts, and other evidence are evaluated.

Competent Court in the Offense of Using Fake Invoices

Criminal proceedings for fake invoice offenses regulated under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law are, as a rule, conducted before the Criminal Court of First Instance. However, if other offenses are involved in the case, if the offenses must be evaluated together, or if a special circumstance affecting jurisdiction arises, the issue of jurisdiction must be examined separately.

Statute of Limitations for the Offense of Using Fake Invoices

The statute of limitations for prosecution in the offense of issuing and using fake invoices is determined by taking into account the maximum applicable penalty and the provisions of the law in force on the date the offense was committed. Therefore, it is not correct to automatically calculate the limitation period based on a single date in every case.

In particular, acts occurring during different taxation periods, provisions concerning successive offenses, and acts interrupting the statute of limitations may affect the calculation of the period. Therefore, the statute of limitations must be calculated by considering the entire case file.

Points to Consider in the Offense of Issuing and Using Fake Invoices

  • Whether the invoice is actually fake must be examined based on the underlying commercial transaction.
  • It must be investigated whether the person who used the invoice knew that it was fake.
  • Bank and payment records should be preserved.
  • Documents relating to the delivery of goods or services should be retained.
  • It should be examined whether commercial books and records are consistent with one another.
  • The contents of the tax inspection report and tax technical report should be carefully evaluated.
  • The criminal investigation and the proceedings before the tax court should be considered separately.
  • Whether the conditions for effective remorse under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law are satisfied should be assessed in a timely manner.

Legal Support from an Attorney in Fake Invoice Cases

An allegation of issuing or using fake invoices may have serious consequences in terms of both imprisonment and tax and tax penalties. Therefore, rather than assessing the matter solely on the basis of a determination that an invoice is fake, the authenticity of the commercial transaction underlying the invoice and the person's role in that transaction should be examined in detail.

Attorney Mehmet Kurşun may provide legal analysis concerning the evaluation of tax inspection reports, comparison of bank and commercial records, determination of whether criminal intent exists, and assessment of the possibility of benefiting from effective remorse in fake invoice investigations. In this context, obtaining legal support in the field of criminal law may assist in evaluating the criminal and tax aspects of the case together.

Especially in criminal proceedings, it is important to prepare the defense, establish the authenticity of the transactions underlying the invoices, and evaluate the evidence comprehensively. The legal assessment to be conducted by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun according to the specific characteristics of the case may assist in determining the defense strategy to be followed against an allegation of issuing or using fake invoices.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many years of imprisonment is the penalty for issuing a fake invoice?

Under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law, the penalty for issuing or using a fake document is imprisonment from 3 to 8 years under the current regulation.

Is using a fake invoice a crime?

Yes. Knowingly using a document that meets the characteristics specified as a fake document under the law may constitute an offense under Article 359/b of the Tax Procedure Law.

Will there be a penalty if a fake invoice is used unknowingly?

Using a fake invoice without knowing it is fake is different from knowingly using one. Whether the person knew that the invoice was fake and whether criminal intent existed are assessed based on concrete evidence.

Is effective remorse available in fake invoice offenses?

If the payment and procedural conditions prescribed under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law are fulfilled, a penalty reduction may be applied at the rates provided by law.

Can both imprisonment and a tax penalty be imposed because of a fake invoice?

Imprisonment under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law does not prevent the separate imposition of a tax loss penalty when the relevant conditions are met.

The legal assessment to be conducted by Attorney Mehmet Kurşun according to the specific characteristics of the case may assist in evaluating the criminal and tax proceedings together in allegations involving the issuance or use of fake invoices.

Call Now WhatsApp

Loading…